A perceived lack of action over a warning he gave nearly three years ago about a “possible inappropriate relationship” between a high school teacher and a student was among the factors in the resignation of Plum school director Joseph Tommarello.
But district officials claim that report, in which Mr. Tommarello named high school English teacher Joseph Ruggieri, was fully investigated at the time and that the student and family said the allegations were false.
Mr. Ruggieri was arrested in February and charged with institutional sexual assault, corruption of minors and intimidating a witness for an alleged sexual relationship with a student. His arrest came shortly after the arrest of high school teacher Jason Cooper, who faces the same charges, in connection with a sexual relationship with another female student. A third teacher, Drew Zoldak, was arrested and charged with witness intimidation in April after, investigators said, he singled out one of the victims in his classroom.
“[Mr. Tommarello] makes it sound like nothing happened three years ago and that’s just not true,” said Plum solicitor Lee Price. “The matter was investigated.”
Mr. Tommarello, who recently won a Republican nomination for a second term, hand-delivered his resignation to superintendent Tim Glasspool after Friday’s high school graduation ceremony. At the graduation, Mr. Tommarello presented his sister Natalee with her diploma.
The letter and the district’s response were released Monday afternoon by Mr. Price, with the statement posted to the district’s website.
Read More
In his letter, Mr. Tommarello, a 2011 Plum High School graduate, said he was resigning “due to a major difference of opinions between myself and the district.” He said over the past four months the district has been “plagued with scandal and hardship” and that the administration and board “did not handle these situations properly.”
He said he did not share the board’s “full confidence” in the district’s leaders. His reference was to a statement that board president Sal Colella made at the April 27 board meeting, where he said he had full confidence in Mr. Glasspool, high school principal Ryan Kociela and the entire administrative staff.
Those comments came just days after Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. held a news conference to announce a broad investigation into whether there was faculty and administrative knowledge of inappropriate relationships at the high school.
“How could they say they had full confidence when the investigation had just started and we don’t know how this is going to turn out?” Mr. Tommarello said in an interview.
He said that in the summer or fall of 2012 a student confided in him about an inappropriate relationship with Mr. Ruggieri. He said he took that information to Mr. Glasspool. “From that point on, I did not hear anything,”he said.
Then in February, when Mr. Ruggieiri was arrested, Mr. Tommarello said he pointed out to administrators that he had told them about the alleged inappropriate relationship three years earlier. At that time, he said, district officials told him his report was investigated and that “there was no complaining witness.”
In a statement, Mr. Glasspool said: “To the best of my knowledge, Mr. Tommarello reported one incident. That incident was investigated and found to be unsubstantiated.”
He referred other questions to the Plum police. Reached Monday night, Chief Jeff Armstrong said he didn’t immediately have access to his records.
Mr. Tommarello said he had lost touch with the alleged victim, so he couldn’t confirm those details with her but he believes she may be one of the eight “Jane Does” for whom the district attorney’s office sought records when it presented search warrants at the district last month.
Mr. Tommarello said after he made his comments in February, Chief Armstrong interviewed him about the matter. But he said there was no police interview following his initial report in 2012. He has not been contacted by the district attorney’s office.
Mr. Tommarello said around the same time in February that he spoke of his past warning, former ROTC instructor Scott Kolar sent an email to board members saying that he had warned high school principal Ryan Kociela about possible inappropriate relationships between Mr. Ruggieri and female students two years earlier. Mr. Tommarello said he could not provide a copy of the email because his school district email had been terminated following his resignation.
Mr. Kolar, who appeared in May before an Allegheny County grand jury investigating the Plum situation, now teaches in another district and has declined comment on his email.
Mr. Ruggieri’s attorney, R. Anthony DeLuca, did not return a phone call.
Mr. Colella said in a statement that Mr. Tommarello’s resignation letter was not a total surprise as Mr. Tommarello had attended just four of 22 school board meetings held since Feb. 1.
Mr. Tommarello said health problems prevented him from attending meetings. He said he did not resign from the board earlier because he did not want any retribution against his sister, who was still a student at the high school. That’s why he wanted until after graduation.
Mr. Colella said it was “disheartening” that Mr. Tommarello was abandoning his post on the board just after he was appointed to the newly formed Safety & Supportive Schools Committee, created at the May 26 school board meeting.
School director Michelle Stepnick said she was confused by Mr. Tommarello’s resignation because he asked to be placed on the safety committee. “I am disappointed that Joe walked away when we are at a pivotal point in our district and after hundreds of people voted for him,” she said.
The board is holding a special meeting at 6 p.m. Wednesday in the high school auditorium to accept Mr. Tommarello’s resignation. Mr. Glasspool said a press briefing will be held afterward.
Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.