Police in Westmoreland County were “forced to execute a search warrant” on the Washington County coroner’s office Wednesday, alleging the coroner was holding onto records Monessen police needed for a criminal investigation.

Melanie Jones, a spokeswoman for Westmoreland District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli, said Monessen police were “in need of records and reports pertinent to an investigation and prosecution.” Alongside the DA’s office, Jones said, Monessen police served a search warrant on the office to get those documents.

But Tim Uhrich, an attorney for coroner Tim Warco’s office, said the situation stemmed from Westmoreland County’s refusal to pay the fees Uhrich said apply when another county requests autopsy information.

Rather than pay the fees, Uhrich told the Post-Gazette, Westmoreland authorities “obtained [the records] through force.”

Advertise with us

Ziccarelli declined to elaborate on the investigation or the records but called the need for a search warrant “uncharted territory for our office.

“As a law enforcement agency, Monessen Police Department is entitled to this material pursuant to a criminal investigation and prosecution,” she said in a statement. “Pursuing justice and accountability shouldn’t come at a cost to the victim, the victim’s family, or public safety.”

Uhrich said the Monessen investigation involves a drug-related death in which the victim died at Mon Valley Hospital, which is in Washington County. Because the individual died in Washington County, Warco’s office was the one that carried out the autopsy.

Pennsylvania’s coroners’ statute says a request for services by another county or person “may be complied with at the discretion of the coroner under guidelines established by the county commissioners.”

Uhrich said those fees in Washington County include $500 for an autopsy report and $100 for a toxicology report. The statute further notes that payment of those fees “shall be the responsibility of the county or person requesting the service.”

Advertise with us

“[The District Attorney’s Office] indicated they did not want to pay these fees,” Uhrich said, “so they obtained them through force.”

He said the fees are in place to help offset the cost of post-mortem examinations and related testing which, in this case, cost the office about $2,500.

“We do not believe that the taxpayers of Washington County should have to fund the Westmoreland County prosecution,” he said.

It’s not the first time law enforcement officers have raided Warco’s office for records they said they were entitled to but the coroner said were subject to fees.

In November, officers from the Pennsylvania State Police, Washington City police and Canonsburg police served five search warrants for five autopsy reports. The coroner’s office said at the time the reports were connected to four homicide investigations, some of which had already been charged.

Advertise with us

Uhrich said at the time that Warco’s office had started charging the Washington County District Attorney’s Office the same fee it charges individuals for the same reports and information.

Washington County DA Jason Walsh at the time accused Warco of obstructing criminal investigations — another piece in a long-running feud between the two offices.

Investigators from Walsh’s office raided the offices of both Warco and Uhrich in late 2023 seeking files related to an inquest Warco held earlier that year. The inquest, into the shooting death of a man by Mount Pleasant police, recommended manslaughter charges against the officer who opened fire.

Search warrants were served on the two offices about a month after Warco made his findings public.

Days later, Walsh applied for a restraining order that would force the coroner and his attorney to turn over any records they were still holding on to — and to limit Warco’s ability to obtain investigative records in the future.

Advertise with us

Then last year, Warco wrote in a state Supreme Court filing that Walsh strong-armed him into filing a fraudulent death certificate indicating the 2022 death of an infant in Peters was a homicide. Warco claimed another pathologist’s findings had already indicated that wasn’t the case, and Walsh told him he needed the case to be a homicide “to win an election.”

Walsh has denied the allegation, as well as any wrong-doing in raids and search warrants served on the coroner’s office.