Two days after investigators from Washington County raided the office of county Coroner Tim Warco, they did the same at the Carnegie office of his attorney, Timothy Uhrich.
The search warrant, again, sought all materials related to the coroner’s inquest into the shooting death of Eduardo Hoover Jr. Hoover was shot and killed by a Mount Pleasant police officer after a pursuit through Washington County on April 2.
Mr. Uhrich said around four law enforcement officers came to his office on East Main Street about 2 p.m. Thursday with a search warrant seeking documents related to the inquest, “including but not limited to police reports, evidence, videos, audio, written or electronic notes and/or documents the coroner collected for his investigation, and any derivative copies and notes which relied in whole or in part on this investigative information.”
The searches come just over a month after Mr. Warco recommended that District Attorney Jason Walsh file manslaughter charges against the officer who shot and killed Hoover. Mr. Walsh, in turn, called the coroner’s inquest “theatrical nonsense.”
The inquest lasted several days, and Mr. Warco gave his recommendations Oct. 26. Mr. Walsh had ruled the shooting justified in May, about a month after the deadly shooting.
Mr. Walsh could not be reached Thursday night.
Read More
Mr. Uhrich said he had not seen the search warrant served at the coroner’s office, as a Washington County judge sealed the document for 60 days. On Thursday, however, the warrant to search the attorney’s office was signed off on by the district magistrate in Carnegie and thus not sealed.
The search warrant alluded to a “press conference” held Oct. 26 by Mr. Warco and Mr. Uhrich to give the findings of the inquest. As part of the inquest, Mr. Warco had subpoenaed several officers involved as well as portions of the investigative report. The subpoenas for officer testimony were ultimately quashed.
The DA’s office requested those records back from Mr. Warco and Mr. Uhrich Nov. 21, according to both the search warrant and the attorney’s account of the events. The request was to “demand [the] return of law enforcement investigative records and any derivative copies and notes which relied in whole or in part on these investigative records no later than [12 p.m. Nov. 22].”
Neither complied. Mr. Uhrich said both he and Mr. Warco are legally in possession of the documents and information, which he said was obtained via subpoena.
The search warrant continued: “These records are not public records, and the coroner and any private attorney acting in concert with the coroner behalf are not a defined criminal justice agency …”
The underlying probable cause for the search warrant alleges Mr. Uhrich is in violation of the state law regarding tampering with public records or information.
The records in question were connected to Mr. Warco’s inquest into the April 2 death of Hoover, who was shot and killed by Mount Pleasant police Officer Tyler Evans. In his role as coroner, Mr. Warco ruled the officer was criminally liable for Hoover’s death and “was not justified in his use of deadly force.”
Officer Evans, the coroner wrote in his October ruling, gave statements to state police investigators that were “contrary to what is depicted in his bodycam video.” Mr. Walsh, at the time, called that allegation “not true.”
“Even if it were,” he continued, “that has nothing to do with when [Officer Evans] fired his weapon and what he subjectively believed to be happening at the time.”
Officials said at the time of the April shooting that Hoover had led police on a chase through several municipalities before he was ultimately boxed in by several police cars on Jefferson Avenue.
Police said Hoover reversed his truck into a cruiser, pulled forward and hit a utility pole, then reversed again toward police, prompting an officer now identified as Officer Evans to fire twice at Hoover. He was pronounced dead at about 8 p.m. the night of the shooting.
In his seven-page findings and recommendations, the coroner noted that he was unable to hear testimony from the officers involved in the chase after the courts quashed a subpoena. That included Mount Pleasant Officers Evans and Crystal Metalik, and Chief Matthew Tharp, as well as Smith Township Chief Bernie LaRue and Officer Michael Pasquale.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.