The Washington County District Attorney dismissed a coroner’s calls for charges against a police officer involved in a deadly shooting in April as “theatrical nonsense” during a press conference Friday.

District Attorney Jason Walsh said he’d already ruled months earlier that Mt. Pleasant officer Tyler Evans was justified in the April 2 shooting of Eduardo Hoover Jr. and he continues to stand by that decision.

“I don’t have the time nor the inclination to participate in the coroner’s theatrical nonsense meant for television cameras and political operatives,” Mr. Walsh said.

A day prior, county coroner Tim Warco recommended the DA charge Officer Evans with involuntary manslaughter, saying it was his conclusion that the shooting that killed Hoover was not justified.

Advertise with us

Officer Evans, Mr. Warco wrote in his findings, gave statements to state police investigators that were “contrary to what is depicted in his bodycam video.”

Mr. Walsh was vitriolic in his condemnation of Mr. Warco’s findings and recommendations.

“What was the coroner doing for seven months, because this happened in April? What was the coroner doing in the six months after I justified [the shooting],” he said. “Why hasn’t he convened an inquest in over seven years?”

He called Mr. Warco’s report “cherry-picked only select evidence with a preconceived narrative — all for show.”

Officials said at the time of the shooting that Hoover had led police on a chase through several municipalities before he was ultimately boxed in by several police cars on Jefferson Avenue in Washington.

Advertise with us

Police said Hoover reversed his truck into a cruiser, pulled forward and hit a utility pole, then reversed again toward police, prompting an officer now identified as Officer Evans to fire twice at Hoover. He was pronounced dead at about 8 p.m. the night of the shooting.

Mr. Warco said Hoover ended the chase when he stopped in traffic on Jefferson Avenue and police vehicles boxed in Hoover’s Dodge Ram. According to the inquest, Smith Township Officer Michael Pasquale told investigators he got out of his car and ordered Hoover to get out of the truck. He said Hoover looked at him and reversed his truck, hitting the car Officer Evans was still in. Officer Pasquale fired twice into the truck grill to try to disable it.

“It is important to note,” Mr. Warco wrote, “that Officer Pasquale, despite being out of his vehicle and directly in front of the truck and looking directly at Hoover, chose not to use lethal force.”

Among the contradictions the coroner alleges: Officer Evans told investigators he got out of his car in time to see Hoover’s truck pull forward and hit a utility pole, whereas his bodycam footage shows he was still in the car.

In regard to the alleged contradictions, Mr. Walsh called them nonsense.

Advertise with us

“It’s not true, and … even if it were, that has nothing to do with when [Officer Evans] fired his weapon and what he subjectively believed to be happening at the time,” he said.

In explaining his findings, Mr. Warco noted that Hoover could not have escaped, as his truck was boxed in. Beyond that, he said, Hoover, at the time he was shot, “was neither committing any forcible felony, nor was [he] in possession of a deadly weapon.”

He acknowledged the truck could be construed as a deadly weapon, its boxed-in position left little room for it to move.

Mr. Walsh said there is no way to know if the truck had enough room to move.

“I don’t have to think anything because I wasn’t the one on scene,” he told reporters. “The officer does not have to wait to get run over by a 5,000-pound truck before he protects himself.”

Advertise with us

The district attorney refused to speculate on whether Mr. Warco’s inquest was motivated by the upcoming election.

Mt. Pleasant Police Chief Matthew Tharp declined to comment outside of confirming that Officer Evans remains employed by the township and he stands behind the officer, the state police investigation, and Mr. Walsh’s findings.

Township solicitor Tom McDermott said Mr. Walsh’s determination — that the shooting was justified — was the only conclusion anyone could reach when armed with all the facts.

“We fully support and stand with and behind Tyler,” he said.

Mr. Warco wrote in his recommendations that if the district attorney would not file charges against Officer Evans, he would take his findings to the state Attorney General’s Office.

Advertise with us

Mr. Walsh all but scoffed at that idea. He said there are specific circumstances under which the AG’s office can undertake a case, and the coroner has no “special way of asking the attorney general to do anything.”

“I can tell you — I don’t speak for the attorney general — but that rarely happens,” Mr. Walsh said.