The Washington County coroner said he was strong-armed by District Attorney Jason Walsh into filing a fraudulent death certificate in 2022 indicating a Peters infant’s death was a homicide — despite another pathologist’s findings to the contrary — alleging Mr. Walsh told him he needed the case to be a homicide “to win an election.”

Coroner Tim Warco, in a Supreme Court filing Tuesday, claimed Mr. Walsh manipulated the court system to take control of an autopsy that rightfully belonged to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office to bolster his election campaign. The allegations stem from first-degree murder charges filed against Jordan Clarke in connection with the May 2022 death of his infant son. The Clarke family lived in Peters. The infant died at an Allegheny County hospital.

Mr. Walsh denied the allegations.

“I question Mr. Warco’s mental fitness for office,” Mr. Walsh said. “He has a history showing he doesn’t have a good relationship with this office, and it looks like he’s admitting to a crime — fraudulently filing paperwork with the state.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Warco’s claims were part of a filing submitted Tuesday to bolster a petition filed last week by a group of death penalty defense attorneys asking the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to crack down on Mr. Walsh. The petition alleged the Republican “has abused his power” in seeking the death penalty in cases where it “is clearly not warranted.”

The Atlantic Center, a nonprofit that works with capital-case defendants and their attorneys, filed the petition on July 22 on behalf of two defendants against whom the DA’s office is seeking the death penalty: Mr. Clarke and Joshua George.

The petition alleged Mr. Walsh has wielded the death penalty as a way to “coerce guilty pleas, force cooperation from defendants and accrue political capital.” The Atlantic Center attorneys asked the state Supreme Court to “intervene to stop his abuse of the law and his office.”

Mr. Warco’s sworn affidavit was filed in support of the Atlantic Center’s petition. In it, he claims he was pushed into manipulating the cause and manner of death for 2-month-old Sawyer Clarke, who died at UPMC Children’s Hospital in May 2022.

“In coming forward, the coroner ... [has] provided the level of transparency and accountability that this situation demands,” Atlantic Center attorney Frances Harvey said in a statement, calling Mr. Walsh unfit to pursue capital cases “and, frankly, unfit to be a prosecutor.”

Advertise with us

Similar allegations were laid out in a lawsuit filed late last year by the infant’s family.

That lawsuit — which claimed the DA and coroner allowed Sawyer’s remains to decompose to nearly nothing for months after his death — accused Mr. Walsh of circumventing the Allegheny County medical examiner’s office to force a conclusion of homicide — a move that touched off the saga that allowed the infant to decompose in the coroner’s office for nearly seven months.

In his sworn affidavit, Mr. Warco backed up the Clarke family’s claims: He said he received a call from Mr. Walsh in the hours after Sawyer’s death saying he needed Mr. Warco to take control of the case, allegedly adding: “You know that I need this to be a homicide, I need it to win an election.”

Mr. Warco wrote that when he told the DA he didn’t have jurisdiction in the case because Sawyer Clarke died in Allegheny County, Mr. Walsh reportedly told him: “Don’t worry, I’ll get you a court order.”

Indeed, the affidavit included a copy of an email from First Assistant District Attorney Leslie Ridge — essentially the second in command at the Washington County DA’s office — with a court order from Washington County Common Pleas Judge John F. DiSalle.

Advertise with us

The court order indicates the child’s death happened at his home in Peters. Mr. Warco said he believes the DA intentionally misrepresented to the judge where, exactly, the boy died so he could secure the order that ultimately gave Washington County jurisdiction over the autopsy.

The order said Washington County needed to perform the autopsy “to establish or determine injuries and cause of death, and to aid in establishing manner or death and otherwise assist in the investigation and prosecution related to [an] infant fatality on May, 24, 2022 in Peters Township, Washington County.” Washington County deputies retrieved the infant’s body that night.

Jennifer Hammers, a contract pathologist who performed the autopsy for Washington County, completed her exam the next day.

She ruled the cause of death was blunt force trauma but said she couldn’t determine the manner — that is, whether it was, in this case, a homicide or accidental. She forwarded her findings to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, which in turn submitted a death certificate to the state Department of Health on Dec. 23, 2022.

Even though the infant’s body was handed over to Washington County for the autopsy, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office still issued the death certificate because the child was pronounced dead in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Mr. Warco said Mr. Walsh was not satisfied with Dr. Hammers’ conclusion.

Despite the fact Allegheny County officials had already submitted a death certificate for the infant, Mr. Warco said he was pushed to file his own death certificate days later and was “compelled by Walsh to list the manner of death as homicide, with shaken baby syndrome/abusive trauma as the mechanism.”

How Mr. Warco was compelled by Mr. Walsh isn’t clear.

The death certificate submitted by Mr. Warco was ultimately rejected by the state, with officials citing Washington County’s lack of jurisdiction over the death investigation.

“I was compelled by Walsh to do this, in that he continued to insist that he needed the death of Sawyer Clarke to be a homicide,” Mr. Warco wrote.

Advertise with us

The DA called the coroner’s claims “complete nonsense,” accusing him of concocting the story. He said the charges filed against Mr. Clarke were based on evidence and testimony from doctors at Children’s Hospital, where the child was treated and later died.

Mr. Walsh, a Donora native, was appointed DA in 2021 after the death of his predecessor, Eugene Vittone. He campaigned for the office and was elected in 2023.

He also dismissed the concerns in the Atlantic Center’s request for Supreme Court intervention, which noted Mr. Walsh’s office has prosecuted 18 homicide cases since 2021 and sought the death penalty in 11.

The DA defended those numbers, saying most of those cases involve young children. The death penalty can be an option only for first-degree murder convictions, and there must be certain aggravating factors that make the crime especially heinous. One of those aggravating factors is when the victim is a child.

“This liberal political activist group from Philadelphia, who is anti-death penalty, doesn’t care or doesn’t understand that that’s the law,” Mr. Walsh said. “There’s no magic, there’s no making it up.”

Advertise with us

Fathers charged in alleged shaken-baby cases

The Atlantic Center called Mr. Walsh’s pursuit of the death penalty “arbitrary,” alleging it has “become a crisis in Washington County.” The group said only about 1.6% of Pennsylvania’s population lives in Washington County, but the DA there is prosecuting 26% of the state’s active death penalty cases.

The petition points to a series of what Atlantic Center attorneys say are flaws in the death penalty cases against Mr. Clarke and Mr. George, both of whom are charged with homicide in the deaths of their infant sons.

Mr. Clarke told investigators he tripped on a plastic bag while he was holding Sawyer and fell on top of the infant May 23, 2022. The filing notes the 39-year-old suffers “mobility challenges under the best of circumstances” that were caused by a vehicle crash when he was younger.

Prosecutors, however, allege he violently shook the child, causing brain bleeding and other injuries. The Atlantic Center attorneys point to the alleged smoke and mirrors surrounding the infant’s death certificate as evidence of misconduct by Mr. Walsh.

The charges against Mr. George are similar: The 33-year-old is accused of abusing and shaking his 6-month-old son in late 2021. He left Oliver and his two other children with their grandmother around 8:30 a.m. on Dec. 30, 2021. Shortly before noon, the grandmother called 911 to report the infant was struggling to breathe. The infant died a few days later.

Advertise with us

The Atlantic Center filing alleged that prosecutors never provided testimony from the pathologist who conducted Oliver’s autopsy; rather, they relied on a pediatrician who testified Oliver’s injuries were indicative of abuse. Through a series of hearings last year, it was ultimately revealed the pathologist’s testimony could be exculpatory for Mr. George: The pathologist testified, according to the filing, that symptoms of Oliver’s injuries would have “appeared immediately,” and he’d have died within two hours.

If that were the case, according to the filing, the injuries should have been clear the moment Mr. George dropped off the infant with his grandmother, and the child would have died more than an hour before the woman called 911.

The Atlantic Center’s petition, which is seeking a review of all death penalty cases brought by Mr. Walsh’s office, cites several now-closed cases that attorneys say bolster their claims.

Other cases

Jah Sutton was charged with conspiracy to commit homicide and weapons in connection with the February 2021 murder of Nicolas Tarpley at a Donora convenience store. That Ms. Sutton wasn’t at the scene wasn’t in dispute, and her charges were based on her DNA being found on a shell casing collected at the scene. She was also allegedly dating one of the men suspected in the shooting.

Even though she was not charged with homicide, Mr. Walsh announced he would seek the death penalty in her case. When Ms. Sutton’s defense attorneys pointed out that her charges were not eligible for capital punishment, Mr. Walsh filed amended charges that included homicide.

Advertise with us

Ms. Sutton was jailed for nearly four years before a judge dismissed all of the charges against her.

The filing also cites the case of James May IV and Shannon McKnight, whose 3-month-old daughter died from what was ultimately determined to be fentanyl toxicity. The filing alleges that despite the fact there was no evidence the couple intended to kill their infant daughter — intent is a key element of first-degree murder — Mr. Walsh sought the death penalty against both. They ultimately pleaded guilty to drug delivery resulting in death.

“If DA Walsh is allowed to continue abusing his discretion in seeking death sentences,” the Atlantic Center wrote, “other defendants facing capital trials in Washington County will give up their right to trial to avoid an illegal threat of death.”

The petition asks the state Supreme Court to bar the Washington County DA’s office from seeking death sentences without the approval of an out-of-county judge and without consulting with the state Attorney General’s office.

It also asks the court to appoint an out-of-county judge to review all capital cases charged since 2021 as well as appoint someone to oversee the DA’s office as a whole — specifically someone with the authority to review capital cases. The two named petitioners, Mr. Clarke and Mr. George, are also asking that a death sentence be taken off the table in their cases.