Washington County coroner Tim Warco on Thursday recommended the District Attorney’s Office file manslaughter charges against an officer involved in a fatal shooting in Washington on April 2, contradicting the DA’s own findings that cleared the officer about a month after the deadly encounter.

The coroner’s inquest calls on District Attorney Jason Walsh to file involuntary manslaughter charges against Mt. Pleasant police Officer Tyler Evans. Mr. Warco’s inquest ruled the officer is criminally liable in the death of Eduardo Hoover Jr. and he “was not justified in his use of deadly force.”

Officer Evans, Mr. Warco wrote, gave statements to state police investigators that were “contrary to what is depicted in his bodycam video.”

Mr. Walsh’s office could not immediately be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

Officials said at the time of the shooting that Hoover had led police on a chase through several municipalities before he was ultimately boxed in by several police cars on Jefferson Avenue in Washington.

Police said Hoover reversed his truck into a cruiser, pulled forward and hit a utility pole, then reversed again toward police, prompting an officer now identified as Officer Evans to fire twice at Hoover. He was pronounced dead at about 8 p.m. the night of the shooting.

The district attorney ruled in May that officers were justified in the shooting.

“Mr. Hoover’s actions endangered the lives of countless citizens of this county as well as law enforcement as he led officers on a high-speed pursuit and then wielded his approximately 5,000-pound Dodge Ram truck as a weapon,” Mr. Walsh told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV in May.

Mr. Warco, who has served as Washington County coroner since 1992, disagreed.

Advertise with us

In his seven-page findings and recommendations, Mr. Warco noted he was unable to hear testimony from the officers involved in the chase after the courts quashed a subpoena. That included Mt. Pleasant Officers Evans and Crystal Metalik and Chief Matthew Tharp, as well as Smith Township’s Chief Bernie LaRue and Officer Michael Pasquale.

Mr. Warco said Cpl. Daniel Eddy, the Pennsylvania State Police officer who led the investigation into the shooting, was subpoenaed but did not appear. He was able to review 38 pages of Cpl. Eddy’s 260-page report, he said. That report included statements the officers involved had made during the investigation.

Other evidence included reports from both township police departments and Washington police, Hoover’s autopsy and toxicology reports, a 911 call log and dashcam video from three of four officers involved in the chase. Mr. Warco said he also watched body-worn camera footage of Officer Evans firing the shots and security footage from a store near the scene.

"I felt it was just unjustified the way he was killed," Hoover’s aunt, Lori Cook, told KDKA. "It's just unreal that 38-years-old and he's gone. Three kids living without their dad is unreal."

The TV station reported that Hoover’s family wept as the coroner announced his findings.

Advertise with us

Mr. Warco said the events played out as follows:

Hoover stopped his truck on Jefferson Avenue, effectively ending the chase, and police vehicles boxed in the truck with Hoover still in it. According to the inquest, Officer Pasquale told investigators he got out of his car and ordered Hoover to get out of the truck. He said Hoover looked at him and reversed his truck, hitting the car Officer Evans was still in. Officer Pasquale fired twice into the truck grill to try to disable it.

“It is important to note,” Mr. Warco wrote, “that Officer Pasquale, despite being out of his vehicle and directly in front of the truck and looking directly at Hoover, chose not to use lethal force.”

Among the contradictions the coroner alleges: Officer Evans told investigators he got out of his car in time to see Hoover’s truck pull forward and hit a utility pole, whereas his bodycam footage shows he was still in the car.

Mr. Warco said the footage shows Officer Evans still in the car when Hoover reversed into it from about three to five yards away. He said the officer shouts an expletive and then gets out and “immediately fires two rounds through the rear window of the truck.”

Advertise with us

The coroner questioned Officer Evans’ decision to fire through the truck when other officers were in front of the vehicle. According to the report, Officer Evans told investigators he didn’t think the rounds would go through the truck and endanger other officers.

In explaining his findings, Mr. Warco noted that Hoover could not have escaped, as his truck was boxed in. Beyond that, he said, Hoover, at the time he was shot, “was neither committing any forcible felony, nor was [he] in possession of a deadly weapon.”

He acknowledged the truck could be construed as a deadly weapon, its boxed-in position left little room for it to move.

Mr. Warco called on Mr. Walsh to file involuntary manslaughter charges. Failing that, he wrote, he will offer his findings to the state Attorney General and ask that office to step in and prosecute the officer.

This story will be updated.