One in a series exploring the stories of missing people whose families will take part in Missing Person Awareness Day on June 6.

Tommy Nesbitt was gone by the time his little sister was born but his presence — and absence — loomed large throughout her entire childhood. The little boy and the void left after he disappeared followed her into adulthood, and the mystery remains one that she is determined to unravel even now, more than seven decades later.

Linda Sue Pickel-Domek still has the photo that sat on her late mother’s television stand. It’s a brassy-colored frame with a three-photo matte that’s browned with time. Pictured in the oval cutouts on either side is Pickel-Domek as an infant — white frilly dress, rosy cheeks and shiny black Mary Jane shoes.

In the middle is a brown-eyed boy with a wide smile: Part ghost, part aspiration, part guardian angel.

Advertise with us

“She would always point to him and tell me, ‘This is your older brother: His name’s Thomas William, and Tommy was kidnapped.”

Tommy Nesbitt was 10 when his mother, Josephine Nesbitt, sent him off to what was then St. Peter’s School on Pittsburgh’s North Side.

It was Sept. 28, 1953. Josephine and Tommy’s father, John Earl Nesbitt Jr., were separated by then, with John Nesbitt’s last known address somewhere in Aspinwall. Josephine, 29 at the time, lived on Arch Street, less than a half-mile from St. Peter’s. Reports from the time noted she’d been awarded primary custody of Tommy a few months prior, and he’d spent the weekend before his disappearance with his 35-year-old father.

According to the reports, John Nesbitt picked up Tommy during recess and then they both vanished. “A countywide search” was carried out next day, according to the Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph.

Domek — she doesn’t normally hyphenate it as Pickel-Domek but told the Post-Gazette that Pickel is the last name Tommy would be more likely to recognize — said that life in Tommy’s shadow was complicated. She said her mother told her that when she was pregnant with her, she prayed for a boy.

Advertise with us

“Because she wanted another Tommy,” she said.

“She would always tell me, ‘Your grades are not as good as Tommy’s. You have to do better — you’re smart like him.’”

It was a strange way to grow up, she said, but she always loved him — he was her brother, after all, and she looked up to him the way any little sister would: Someone to cherish and someone she believed would protect her if he ever came back.

“It was weird, but it was like — did you ever feel like you had a guardian angel?” she said, pointing toward her right shoulder. “That’s what it felt like. He was my guardian angel even though he wasn’t here.”

Stacy Domek-Johnson and her mother, Linda Sue Domek, show a frame that Domek's late mother always kept on her television stand. Sandwiched between photos of Domek as an infant is Tommy, the older brother she never met. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Despite his constant presence, Tommy was a relatively off-limits topic in Domek’s home. She said her mother, who remarried after Tommy and Nesbitt Jr. were last seen, “pretty much closed herself off from talking about it,” and his name stopped coming up at all after Domek’s father died.

Advertise with us

“But she never stopped looking for him,” she said.

Not long before Josephine died in 2003, she gave her daughter the photos of Tommy.

“She says, ‘If anything happens to me, find Tommy, get these to him, and tell him I love him,’” Domek recalled.

Domek’s daughter, Stacy Domek-Johnson, has taken up the cause as well. The younger woman said they began looking for Tommy in earnest after Josephine’s death but the search has taken on new life over the past several years.

There are questions surrounding the bits and pieces that Josephine did divulge over the years: For example, the women said, she insisted that Tommy had been kidnapped from a military school. And she told the Pittsburgh Press two week after Tommy disappeared that she no longer believed the boy’s father had him.

Advertise with us

“The boy’s distraught mother, Mrs. Josephine Nesbitt, at first believed her divorced husband had taken young Tommy during the noon hour at St. Peter’s School Sept. 28,” the Oct. 9, 1953, edition of the Pittsburgh Press reported. “But today she said she doesn’t think he would keep the boy away so long.”

Domek said she’s not sure why Josephine’s tone seemed to change in that particular story.

“She honestly believed up till the day she died that John took him — and his family knew where they were,” she said.

Domek believes that, too. She said one of Tommy’s uncles once told Josephine that Tommy went on to become an engineer, fought in the Vietnam War, and was injured but survived.

“But they don’t know where he’s at or anything about him,” she said, voice brimming with sarcasm.

Advertise with us

Another relative on the Nesbitt side put Josephine in touch with a woman in the South who allegedly knew where Tommy was.

She said her mother talked to the woman, who said her son had a friend who looked like Tommy and told people his mother was dead.

“My mom says, ‘Well I have a picture of Tommy and me — I’ll send it to you, but if it’s not him, send it back,’” Domek said.

Josephine sent the photo, Domek said. She never got the photo back. The woman’s phone number was disconnected.

Pittsburgh police said Tommy was never actually entered into their system as a missing person.

Advertise with us

“There were attempts to track down someone in his family, but it’s just one of those things like — there’s just not enough people dedicated to do these types of cold cases,” said missing persons Detective Mike Flynn. “I’m super interested in them. I love them. It’s just with the amount of runaways we have every week and the occasional legit missing adult — it’s just impossible.”

He called the case a tragedy — one that would take “serious brainstorming, sitting down, pulling records, and trying to figure out what the deal with [John Nesbitt] is.” The people who have been able to get the furthest with that so far, he said, are Ruth Brannigan and Tracy Pampena — the women behind the Pennsylvania Missing Persons Foundation.

“There were attempts to track down someone in his family, but it’s just one of those things like — there’s just not enough people dedicated to do these types of cold cases.”

Pampena, a licensed private investigator, told the Post-Gazette earlier this month that she’s spent countless hours diving into records and research to try to find out where Tommy and his father might have gone after Sept. 28, 1953.

She said Domek and her daughter turned to their nonprofit after they struck out trying to file a formal missing person report for Tommy.

Flynn said some in law enforcement scoff when civilians becoming involved in these kinds of cases.

Advertise with us

“I’m the complete opposite way,” he said. I feel like, especially with missing persons, the more information, the more people you have working on it, it’s so much easier to connect the dots and put something together.”

Brannigan called what John Nesbitt allegedly did to his family cruel.

“It’s impressive how many generations it ripples [from someone going] missing,” she said. “There’s a discomfort that’s passed along — that something’s not right, it’s out of kilter.”

And that’s clear from the way in which Tommy and his absence affected his mother, stuck with his sister, and now baffles his niece, who was born decades after he disappeared.

For her part, Domek just wants to make good on her promise to her mother.

Advertise with us

“Please, I just want to make sure he gets the pictures and I can see him one time to tell him she loved him,” she said. “And if he wanted to get to know each other — because he is part of my life.”

She said she believes Tommy is still alive. He’d turn 82 on June 24.

“I know it sounds funny, but it’s like I can feel he’s still here,” she said.

A 30-year delay

Jayqua Harris has a different kind of feeling about her mother.

“I know in my heart my mom’s dead,” she said.

Advertise with us

The last time Harris, now in her 30s, remembers seeing her mother, Lisa Michelle Davis, was in 1991.

Jayqua Harris keeps framed photos of her missing mother, Lisa Michelle Davis, throughout her Hill District apartment.

Harris was about 3 at the time, so her memories of her mother are limited mostly to just her face. She doesn’t have any pictures of herself and her mother, so she has made her own, framing her mother’s high school portrait alongside her own photo on her living room wall.

She was raised largely by her paternal grandmother, as her father left Pittsburgh around the same her mother disappeared. He eventually resurfaced. No records of Lisa exists beyond the early 1990s.

“All my life I was asking my grandmother, ‘Where’s my mom at?’”

The answer, she said, was always some variation of, “I don’t know, stop asking.”

Advertise with us

But she didn’t — to the point that when Harris, who has a seizure disorder, was approached by the Make-a-Wish Foundation, she said her wish was to know what happened to her mother.

“The lady said, ‘What’s your wish? What would you like to do for Make-a-Wish?’ And I said, ‘My wish is to find out where my mom is,’” Harris recalled.

She said her grandma whipped around and told the Make-A-Wish employee to come back later.

“She said, ‘You don’t need to know where your mom is at.’”

As a child, Harris’ options for finding out more were limited. She said her grandmother never talked about her mom and never showed her photos. No one ever reported Lisa missing — not Harris’ father, not her grandmother. Lisa didn’t have any other family outside of her children, Harris said.

Advertise with us

Her grandmother told her she would take it to the grave. Ultimately, she did.

Harris said she took a photo of her mother she’d stolen from her grandmother’s drawer and confronted her in the nursing home where she was living toward the end of her life.

“I said, ‘I want to find out what happened to my mom, with or without your help,’” she said. “And she just shook her head and said, ‘No, no, no.’”

Harris kept looking, becoming more proactive as she got older.

Tommy Nesbitt was last seen at St. Peter’s School on Pittsburgh’s North Side on Sept. 28, 1953. He has brown eyes and was last seen wearing a green sport shirt and a maroon bow tie. He would be turning 82 next month. He was taken by his father, John Earl Nesbitt Jr., who would be 106. His mother’s family has heard various rumors about his life after he disappeared, including that he received an engineering degree, was wounded in the Vietnam War, and might have been in Alabama or Georgia at some point.

Jayqua Harris last remembers seeing her mother, Lisa Michelle Davis, around 1991 when she was 3 years old. Lisa was 26 at the time, and she wasn’t reported missing until Harris made the official report in the early 2020s. She has brown eyes. Anyone with information can contact Pittsburgh police at 412-323-7800.

“I said, now I’m grown, I should be able to know what’s happened to my mom — somebody tell me something.”

Advertise with us

Somebody suggested she call city detectives.

“I called the detectives up and I said, ‘I would like to report my mom missing’ — that’s what I said.”

It was the early 2020s — some 30 years after the disappearance.

All Harris could really tell the detectives, though, was her mother’s name and the last time she remembered seeing her. She said they asked for her mom’s birthday. It was a question she couldn’t answer — she didn’t even know those kind of basic details about her.

Detectives got back to her: They’d found out Lisa’s birthday. It was April 18.

Advertise with us

Harris wept — that’s her daughter’s birthday, too.

“You mean to tell me for 16 years I never knew that but my grandmother knew that, and my dad had to know that,” she said, incredulous.

Flynn said he believes the information Harris has is credible — that there are people still alive and even still living in the Hill District who know what happened.

“I would love to put 100% of my time into it because she’s onto something, there’s no doubt about it,” the detective said. “I just cannot physically do it.”

The loss of three decades between when Lisa was last known to be alive and when she was reported missing obviously makes things even more difficult, he said.

Advertise with us

“The more time goes past, especially with these older cases, people start dying or people get stricken with some illness and they can’t remember.”

Flynn continued: “It’s just an A to Z list of evidence that you lose.”

It’s frustrating, he said, “because I know that the potential to solve Lisa Davis is very probable.”

Her daughter believes that, too.

“What’s done in the dark comes up to the light,” she said. “I think I’m getting closer and closer.”