One in a series exploring the stories of nine missing people whose families will take part in Missing Person Awareness Day on June 6.

In the absence of knowing, Samantha Cummins imagines the worst.

“Could he have been out there alone, hurt, wanting help, needing help, and he didn’t have it?” she said. “Was he begging for us?”

She doesn’t know — not for sure, anyway — what happened to her big brother, Matthew McDonald. He’s been missing for more than three years.

Advertise with us

“The ultimate hardest part of this is not knowing where he is or what happened to him,” she told the Post-Gazette.

It’s cliché but reality for families of the missing: The not knowing is the hardest part.

Cummins called it “the worst thing in the whole entire world.”

It took years for Daisy Peterson to find the right word for it after her mother, Jamie Peterson, vanished in 2011.

“My therapist said it’s basically like my whole life I have lived in limbo,” she said. “I’ve never really had a good word or thought of a good word that would fit so well for my situation, but as soon as I heard that, I was like, ‘Wow, that’s actually the perfect word that I’ve been looking for.’”

Advertise with us

She agreed that the not knowing is hard — but knowing might not be good, either.

“Whichever scenario it is, it’s not great, but at least at some point your brain has those answers that it’s looking for and can try to find the closure it needs,” Peterson said. “But then when your brain has no answers, your brain is just kind of jumping everywhere trying to find that single missing link.”

It’s called ambiguous loss.

An undated portrait of Jamie Peterson, her daughter Daisy, and son Elijah.

The concept is simple, said Pauline Boss, the psychologist and researcher who pioneered the idea in the 1970s: An unclear loss.

The concept came from her research of families of Vietnam War soldiers who were considered missing in action. The families, unsure if their loved one was dead or alive — and, if alive, what state they were in — were left in a terrible limbo. She wrote extensively about the idea and the best approach to dealing with it in her book, “Ambiguous Loss.”

Advertise with us

Death, while sad, comes with certainty. That doesn’t exist for families of the missing, which means the comfort that’s offered in the wake of a death also doesn’t exist.

“In most areas, you have rituals,” said Boss, “They can be religious or they can just be community-based rituals where someone brings a meal to your house because they know there was a death in the family, or they come to comfort you.”

Death offers tangibility, too, she said. There’s a grave or an urn or even just a place where ashes were spread.

“All of this represents certainty, and you have that with a verified death,” Boss said. “With ambiguous loss, you have zero. You have none of these.”

‘The girl whose mom disappeared’

Peterson was 13 when her mom went missing Sept. 26, 2011.

Advertise with us

She doesn’t remember if she and her brother, who is younger by one year, took the bus to school or if their mom drove them that Monday. She does remember that they were running late because she couldn’t decide on an outfit.

“I didn’t like anything I tried on, so she was mad at me, of course,” Peterson said.

Regardless of how they got to their North Hills schools that morning, she said, there was no sign anything was amiss until she got to swim practice after school. Not only would her mom pick her up every day, but she’d usually be there in the stands throughout.

“My mom wasn’t there, everyone had left, I was just standing outside trying to call her, trying to figure out what was going on,” she said. “Maybe she got stuck at work or something happened.”

Calls to her mom’s cell phone went straight to voicemail. After a while, they stopped connecting.

Advertise with us

She eventually got in touch with her grandmother, who lived just down the street from their North Hills apartment. While Peterson had been at swim practice, her younger brother had arrived home to find the door locked and his mother not there. He walked to their grandmother’s house, and they picked up Peterson and went back to the apartment.

Nothing was out of place. Jamie was missing, as were her purse and phone, but the apartment was otherwise exactly as it had been. Her car was still there. Receipts and the restocked refrigerator indicated she’d run errands that day and then returned home.

But after that — no trace of Jamie has ever turned up.

Jamie Peterson holds her son, Elijah, while daughter Daisy is “probably being a silly girl.” (Courtesy of Daisy Peterson)

Within days, she said, her mother’s disappearance was “plastered everywhere … and I was just getting swarmed by kids constantly at school.”

She became the girl whose mom disappeared — and it’s followed her into adulthood.

Advertise with us

“I hated that,” she said. “I hated that pretty much my whole life that I have been known as that — nothing really else.”

Ross Police Deputy Chief Brian Kohlhepp has worked on Jamie’s case since the beginning. He said he still considers it “very active.”

He stays in contact with the District Attorney’s Office; he spoke to prosecutors there as recently as a few months ago — “conferring over where we stand and what the next best steps would be.”

He also stays in contact with Peterson, her brother, and Jamie’s parents. Peterson said Ross police have always made time when she’s had questions or concerns, and they tell her as much as they can, considering it’s still an active investigation.

That two-way relationship between law enforcement and the families of the missing isn’t always the norm.

Advertise with us

Belinda Blaniar, whom the Post-Gazette profiled in the first part of this series, disappeared in 1996. Her sister said she hears little from Arnold police or Westmoreland County detectives.

Cummins said she worries that California Borough police aren’t taking Matthew’s case seriously. She and a core group of supporters she calls Matthew’s Army rallied Friday outside of the Washington County Courthouse to call on authorities to do something — anything. The officer in charge of Matthew’s case did not respond to an email asking to discuss where the investigation stands.

“Just because someone has a past doesn’t mean they don’t have loved ones that care about them and family here that want answers. We deserve answers,” she said. “We deserve to know what happened to him. It’s not hurting him, it’s hurting us.”

A layered mystery

Matthew’s case is a particularly complicated one.

He was technically on the run when he went missing, on parole for a gas station robbery. He cut off his ankle monitor and left the halfway house he was living in on Christmas Eve in 2022. Cummins said none of them realized he’d bailed on his parole until early March 2023.

Advertise with us

His family asked him to turn himself in, she recalled, and he was planning to — once he pulled together gas money to get there. The last time anyone in his family saw him was when he had dinner with his dad on March 7.

Three days later, Matthew’s girlfriend and one of her friends were uploading videos on his social media pages, “pretty much saying, ‘If anyone sees Matt, let us know.’”

From there, the story came out slowly — over the course of nearly three years, Cummins said.

What’s been relayed to this point, largely from the girl Matthew was dating at the time, is this: On March 7, Matthew went to pick up pills for his girlfriend that ended up being meth. Matthew did some of the meth, and his girlfriend sent him back to rob the person who’d given him the meth. The robbery went south, and it allegedly ended with Matthew hiding in the woods for hours.

The girlfriend told his family that when he eventually made it home, he wanted to go to work but was acting paranoid: She claimed he rode in the trunk to the job site he was working at and emerged with a hoodie wrapped around his head, Cummins said.

Advertise with us

A short time later, the girlfriend alleged, he called her and said he was surrounded by police and a SWAT team. That, of course, wasn’t the case, and his girlfriend picked him up. They drove to a nearby cemetery, where she said Matthew realized he had a coworker’s phone instead of his own. He stayed in the cemetery while his girlfriend went to swap phones and, when she came back, he was gone.

It’s a lot to unpack, and Cummins said she doesn’t know what to believe.

Samantha Cummins, of Bentleyville, the sister of Matthew McDonald, holds a sign during a rally Friday, May 15, 2026, outside the Washington County Courthouse. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

There are other names involved beyond just Matthew’s girlfriend: Names of people who had his phone along the way, names of people who picked him up from the woods that night.

She has doubts about the story Matthew’s girlfriend relayed. For one, she said, she didn’t know her brother to dabble in anything other than marijuana, and even for that he had a medical card.

Matthew was working in California, Pa., and disappeared from Long Branch, both small boroughs tucked into the southeast corner of Washington County along the Monongahela River. Cummins lives in Cokeburg, another small borough about 10 miles away. The entire area is dotted with tiny towns, villages and unincorporated communities, where rumors travel fast.

Advertise with us

“He was in the trunk of a car in the river. He was in a mineshaft wrapped in a carpet. He was in concrete buried somewhere,” Cummins said, listing the horror stories that have made their way to Matthew’s family. “We followed every single lead we got. We traced down every single time someone messaged us about something.

“We just followed every lead,” she said. “It didn’t get us anywhere.”

‘You’re stuck with your grief’

Boss, the ambiguous loss expert, said that the grief caused by a missing loved one isn’t like the grief caused by the death of a loved one. There’s no resolution to the grief when there are no answers.

“With a verified death, your hope is that, over time, it’s not an obsession anymore,” she said.

Yes, there’s still sadness.

Advertise with us

But there’s also a functioning path forward without that person — even if that sadness still creeps up from time to time, she said.

With ambiguous loss, she said, “you’re stuck with your grief.” She calls it frozen grief.

“People feel guilty if they grieve because they feel they’re thinking of them as dead,” she said. “And if they don’t grieve, they know they’re feeling like they want to.”

“We just followed every lead. It didn’t get us anywhere.”

The communities from which people go missing often don’t know how to approach the loss. And so they don’t do anything, which leaves the families of the missing feeling isolated.

“They know what to do when there’s a death in the community,” she said. “But they don’t know what to do when somebody just goes missing.”

Advertise with us

Boss worked with families of individuals who were presumed dead but never found after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks in New York, as well as the families of those missing after the 2011 earthquake and tsunami in Japan.

“We encourage monuments … that have the names of the missing. The names are the most important thing,” she said, noting that it doesn’t have to be a grand, elaborate memorial, but rather just something “where other people can see it [and] where the families can go as if they were going to a grave.”

That doesn’t work, really, when it comes to the thousands of individual missing people across the country, including more than 500 in Pennsylvania.

‘His story isn’t over’

Daisy Peterson said she wishes that all of those cases could get the spotlight that the high-profile national cases get.

That’s not to say that those cases and those families don’t deserve that attention, she said; rather, they all do, regardless of who or when or why.

Advertise with us

“She’s not just a statistic,” she said of her mother. “She is a real human person, just like everyone else.”

At the same time, she said, she doesn’t want her family’s horror to be someone else’s entertainment.

“I feel like a lot of people just look at these cases as just another story, another documentary to be obsessed with or watch,” Peterson said. “It’s important to know that this is people’s real lives and real life experiences.”

Jamie was a single mother when she went missing. She had Daisy when she was still in high school. She graduated and went on to Rosedale Technical College and earned an automotive degree. She loved cars, and she passed that love to her kids. They went to car shows and parts stores and, every Saturday, they’d go to Trader Jack’s flea market.

“We always stop at McDonald’s to get breakfast and that’s the one time a week I was allowed to get a small coffee,” Peterson said. “I felt like an adult. I loved it.”

Advertise with us

“People feel guilty if they grieve because they feel they’re thinking of them as dead. And if they don’t grieve, they know they’re feeling like they want to.”

PAULINE BOSS, the psychologist and researcher who pioneered the idea of ambiguous loss

She said Jamie taught her and her brother to be nothing less than authentic.

“She let us dye our hair fun colors, do funky hairstyles … let me get piercings and wear band T-shirts — she was the same way,” she said, noting her mother’s “impeccable music taste.

“One of the things we used to love was jamming out on drives in the car together,” she said. ”She always sang to us, from babies up to her [going] missing.”

Cummins wasn’t on the best of terms with her brother when he went missing, and it’s something she continues to regret.

“Our last conversation wasn’t the best conversation,” she said.

But the last time they were on good terms, “our last conversation was just fun.”

“I made him spaghetti dinner, and he told me I was a good cook,” she said. “And we hung out with our family, and we just had a good time.”

Matthew was funny, she said. He tried to hard make sure everyone was laughing.

He was also protective of those he loved, she said: “He just wanted to make sure they were safe all the time.”

The two have a deep bond: When Matthew was 15, he tried to hang himself in the family’s barn. Cummins was 13 at the time. She saved his life that day, she said, and she’s now trying to save him in whatever way she still can.

“His story isn’t over just because something happened to him,” his sister said. “Just because he had a past doesn’t mean he’s a bad person and he doesn’t deserve to have justice.”

Matthew Clark McDonald was 29 when he was last seen by his girlfriend near Howe Cemetery in Long Branch on March 9, 2023. He has brown hair and brown eyes, stands about 6-foot, 1-inch and weighs about 185 pounds. On his right forearm is a tattoo of hands clasped in prayer with a rosary and the name “Shawn.” His left forearm bears a marijuana leaf, smiley face, and skull.

Anyone with information should contact California police at 724-938-3233.

Jamie Nichole Peterson was 30 when she was last seen at her home in Ross on Sept. 26, 2011. She wears glasses and has green eyes and long brown hair with blonde highlights. She has a large purple bear tattooed on her arm and a cross with the name Elijah on her left shoulder blade. She had a daisy and the name Daisy on her right shoulder blade and a large butterfly on the back of her neck. She’d recently had knee surgery at the time of her disappearance.

Anyone with information can contact Ross police at 412-931-9070.