A landlord who owns property in Chambersburg is suing Primanti Bros. for abandoning its lease earlier this year.
U & Me Chambersburg LLC, a New York company that bought property on the 900 block of Norland Avenue in Chambersburg, says it is out thousands of dollars after the iconic Pittsburgh sandwich chain scuttled its Chambersburg operations in February.
Primanti Bros. closed its Lancaster and Camp Hill operations around the same time as part of its “strategic growth plan.”
U & Me Chambersburg LLC said it had not violated the lease, and Primanti Bros. abruptly pulled out of the lease as part of its business plans.
Primanti Bros. was required to pay $12,083.33 monthly, or $145,000 annually, according to the lease.
The restaurant chain entered its original lease with a different company, Chambersburg MZL LLC, on June 23, 2022, for unit 15 of the property, the lawsuit said. The lease was for 144 months with two five-year renewal options, according to the lawsuit.
Chambersburg MZL LLC handed the property, and lease, over to U & Me Chambersburg LLC in December 2024. Primanti Bros. continued operating its restaurant and paid rent until February this year.
On Feb. 10, Primanti Bros. gave notice to U & Me Chambersburg LLC that it would no longer pay rent.
Primanti Bros. has closed 11 of its 47 locations in recent months as part of a “strategic alignment” that isn’t a sign of decline, according to Gerald Pulsinelli, Primanti Bros. CEO.
Those locations include Capital City Mall in Lower Allen Township, Lancaster Shopping Center in Lancaster County, Monroeville, North Versailles and Hanover. It has also closed locations in West Virginia and Maryland.
In 2025, the chain also backed out of joining the Susquehanna Union Green in Susquehanna Township.
Instead, Primanti Bros. is focused on its core market, especially in Pittsburgh.
The breach in contract cost U & Me Chambersburg more than $75,000. It’s asking for unspecified compensatory and consequential damages in excess of $75,000.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.