Joe Primanti's 1933 sandwich cart in the Strip District was, as the legend goes, built for truckers and produce workers who needed to eat with one hand while they worked.

It was a small, family-run operation — brothers Dick and Stanley would soon join Joe in the endeavor — that eventually became Pittsburgh’s most recognizable culinary export.

Nearly a century later, the grit has been replaced by the polished, data-driven gears of private equity.

Today, Primanti Bros. is a subsidiary of Authentic Restaurant Brands, which sits under the umbrella of Garnett Station Partners — a firm whose holdings include everything from funeral homes to car washes. Under the Authentic Restaurant banner, the brand underwent an aggressive “Road to 50” expansion that saw neon signs pop up in Michigan, Indiana and the Baltimore corridor.

Advertise with us

That growth hit a wall in 2024. After ballooning to 47 locations, the chain began a rapid retreat, shuttering sites across the Midwest and Central Pennsylvania.

“One of the first things I did was look through all of our markets, and we identified places outside of Pittsburgh that weren’t right for us,” says Gerald Pulsinelli, who took over the 93-year-old business as CEO in January 2025.

Pulsinelli describes the closures as “stewardship to set us up for the next 90 years.”

The company's “Road to 50” push predates Pulsinelli, and he frames retreat from outlier markets as strategic recalibration.

The count now stands at 37, including outposts at Pittsburgh’s three major sports arenas, and it is scheduled to drop further with the shuttering of its North Versailles and Monroeville locations, two long-standing suburban pillars that opened in 2000 and 2007, respectively.

Advertise with us

Pulsinelli spent his first year reviewing the Primanti roster and consulting with Jim Patrinos and Nick Nicholas, the previous owners who ran the business after Patrinos purchased it from Dick Primanti in 1974, later expanding Primanti into a small chain. He says they remain landlords at 15 locations, including the two closing sites.

“I grew up in the restaurant business. It's all I've ever done,” Pulsinelli says. “So I always look at it from a people-first standpoint. Do we give people the right tools to run the restaurant? We’re going to spend the next years refocusing on our core market in Pittsburgh.”

He says the shift begins with reinvestment in existing locations, including more than $1 million in staffing over the past year and $1.5 million in capital expenditures to remodel buildings, particularly those more than 15 years old.

Food quality is also in play. The chain moved from frozen, medium-sized chicken wings to fresh, jumbo-sized wings following negative customer feedback. The company is also investing in better fresh-packed tomato sauce, whole-milk mozzarella and improved dough for its pizza.

“We're spending a lot of time and money looking at our food,” Pulsinelli says. “We'll continue to invest in that.”

Advertise with us

To maintain its local identity, Primanti Bros., which is headquartered on the South Side, continues to source from regional vendors including Cellone's Italian Bread Co., Frankie's Sausage and Silverstar Meats.

Whether those investments can rehabilitate the brand's standing — or simply stabilize a formerly small local chain that grew faster than it could sustain under private equity — remains to be seen.