A jury on Monday convicted a security guard of voluntary manslaughter for his role in a hookah bar shooting that left two people dead in Penn Hills in 2024.

Chaz Jackson, 43, was working as a security guard at Ballers Hookah and Cigar Bar early June 2, 2024, when an argument led to gunfire. Two people were killed: 28-year-old Stephanie Stuart and 44-year-old Nathaniel Smiley Jr. Seven others were hurt in the shooting and ensuing melee.

Police ultimately charged Jackson with firing the shots that killed Ms. Stuart, pointing to a distinctive blue polymer coating on a bullet removed from Ms. Stuart at autopsy. Investigators said that coating matched the bullets that Mr. Jackson turned over to investigators — the same bullets he said he had in his gun the night of the shooting.

There were no cameras inside the Laketon Road bar, and police said in the immediate aftermath they believed many witnesses to the shooting took off before authorities arrived. Some estimated there were 50 to 100 patrons at the time of the 3 a.m. shooting.

Advertise with us

No charges have ever been filed in connection with Mr. Smiley’s death.

Jackson’s defense attorney, Frank Walker, said the judge dismissed the possibility of first- and second-degree murder mid-trial, and prosecutors ultimately pushed the jury to find Mr. Jackson guilty of third-degree murder.

Mr. Walker said that while his client is relieved the jury did not come back with a murder conviction, he still may appeal the voluntary manslaughter verdict. He said jurors had a lot of evidence to sort through, and Jackson “understands how the jury came back that way.”

According to the original criminal complaint against Mr. Jackson, he initially told investigators that he had seen Ms. Stuart shooting at Mr. Smiley before she was ultimately hit by gunfire. He said he saw an armed man with dreads standing behind Ms. Stuart, according to the complaint, and the man took off toward Frankstown Road once the shooting stopped.

The next day, however, a witness who was wounded in the shooting reported seeing Ms. Stuart fall to the ground as she was running toward the door, according to the complaint. The witness, who was shot in the leg, said Ms. Stuart was unarmed.

Police said Jackson then changed his version of events, indicating that once he heard the first gunshot, he pulled out his pistol but was pushed backward onto a couch. He said he heard at least four gunshots after that, according to the complaint, and while he fired at least one shot, he wasn’t sure if the rest came from his gun.