A security guard charged with firing at least some of the fatal shots during a double homicide in Penn Hills last month will proceed to trial after his defense attorneys failed to convince a district judge on Friday their client accidentally fired his weapon multiple times.

The gunfire inside Ballers Hookah Lounge and Cigar Bar early June 2 injured seven patrons and killed Stephanie Stuart, 28, and Nathaniel Smiley Jr., 44. Chaz Jackson, a 42-year-old security guard for the bar, is charged with homicide, accused of firing the rounds that killed Stuart.

Ben Jackson, an attorney for Chaz Jackson, never outright said that his client caused Stuart’s death, but he did argue Jackson firing his weapon was an accident and, on top of that, not reckless.

District Judge Hilary Wheatley disagreed, holding the homicide, aggravated assault and reckless endangerment charges against Jackson for court.

Advertise with us

The security guard initially told police in an interview the day after the shooting he’d seen Stuart shooting at Smiley before she was ultimately hit by gunfire. He said a man with dreads took the gun he alleged Stuart was firing and ran out of the bar.

When investigators went to the security guard’s home, he turned over a gun and the ammunition he said was in it the night of the shooting. He also told investigators that he did draw his weapon during the chaos, and he might have accidentally fired at least once as he was knocked to the ground.

Allegheny County Police Detective William Hermann said he asked Jackson whether he fired once. Yes, the detective testified was the answer.

Could it have been twice, he asked? He said “probably” was Jackson’s response.

Three times? “Maybe,” was the response, Det. Hermann said.

Advertise with us

The detective said he asked Jackson if he could have fired four times, to which the security guard told him “no.”

Investigators said the bullets and bullet fragments collected from Stuart and one of the injured bar patrons had a blue polymer coating on them, which matches the ammunition they collected from Jackson.

Ben Jackson, the defense attorney, pointed to the fact that Chaz Jackson neither knew Stuart nor had motive to kill her. Det. Hermann agreed. He also said he did not believe that Jackson fired first.

The defense attorney asked if Det. Hermann would agree that the shooting was accidental.

“I can’t agree to that,” he said. “I can’t find consistency on whether he intended to fire or did not intend to fire. I can’t say for sure one way or another.”

Advertise with us

He continued: “I’m not inclined to believe he accidentally shot three times.”

The defense attorney argued that there was no intent — no “substantial and unjustifiable risk [Chaz Jackson] knew about and disregarded.” It wasn’t reckless, he said, for an armed security guard to return fire when he heard gunshots, especially when a bar full of patrons was at risk.

Assistant District Attorney Lauren Sowko said those circumstances absolutely made Jackson’s actions reckless.

“Jackson that night hears gunshots and the next thing he knows, he’s firing,” she said. “That’s reckless.”