Decades of advancement, from the technological to the philosophical, have changed the way policing is carried out, but even those changes haven’t meaningfully counteracted one primary reason many violent crimes go unsolved: the unwillingness of witnesses to tell authorities what, if anything, they know.
It is an old problem with few new solutions, and it has played out many times across the Pittsburgh region.
At least 15 people were waiting for a bus when Thomas McClellan was gunned down in Homewood in 2015. His case remains unsolved.
At an Airbnb party the night before Easter 2022, some 200 people were crammed into the North Side rental. Multiple people opened fire inside, and two teens were killed. No arrests have been made.
And a week ago, between 50 and 100 people were at Ballers Hookah Lounge and Cigar Bar in Penn Hills when a fight devolved into gunfire. When the shooting stopped, two people were dead, seven were wounded, and a large group of potential witnesses left the scene.
Investigators have said they need those witnesses to come forward to solve the double homicide. As of Saturday, no charges had been filed.
Read More
“People have real-world reasons and practical reasons for not coming forward,” said Rod K. Brunson, chair of the University of Maryland’s Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice.
Those reasons, he said, are often simplified down to rudimentary notions, like the idea that some people just don’t want to support the police or that there’s a pervasive culture of “no snitching.”
“It’s not just that they condone violence or are anti-police,” he said. “It’s much more nuanced and complex.”
As part of a study he co-authored in 2019, Mr. Brunson interviewed 50 young Black men in Brooklyn and the Bronx about their dealings with police and whether they’d offer up information if they had it. The study’s title sums it up: “Oh hell no, we don’t talk to police.”
The sentiment is just the tip of the iceberg, he said, in that the reasoning behind it is far-reaching and, in some ways, cyclical.
“If the perception is that police are ineffective at solving crimes,” Mr. Brunson said, “it’s reasonable for [potential witnesses] to think they can’t keep them safe.”
It’s not a totally unfounded fear. Even Pittsburgh has seen its own high-profile instances of witnesses being targeted and killed.
“Unfortunately we’re in a culture where people are afraid to say things … because there have been numerous times people saw something and had threats on their life,” said the Rev. Cornell Jones, Pittsburgh’s director of Street Outreach.
Leroy Powell, a 15-year-old from Duquesne, was shot and killed in 2014, a week after he testified at the preliminary hearing of a homicide suspect. The same year, Tina Crawford was gunned down in the Hill District shortly before she was supposed to meet with a prosecutor about a drug ring led by Price Montgomery.
Montgomery was eventually convicted in Crawford’s death. Powell’s case remains open.
In 2018, an anonymous Facebook account began posting the names and photos of alleged cooperating witnesses in Pittsburgh. The account would highlight information in criminal complaints that witnesses allegedly gave to police. Eleven years earlier, before social media became a way of life, a similar “snitch list” circulated in paper form around the Allegheny County Jail.
Reluctant witnesses aren’t a new issue for investigators, but it is hard to tell if it’s a growing problem — little baseline information exists.
“It’s hard to say whether people are less likely to come forward [now as opposed to historically],” Mr. Brunson said. “If we look at empirical studies, confidence and legitimacy in police among citizens has decreased over time. You can probably make an extension that that means people are less likely to come forward.”
It’s not an issue unique to Pittsburgh; rather, it has played out again and again across the country.

A fight turned into a shooting at a Fresno house party in 2016, and two people were killed. The party was advertised on social media, and as many as 300 people were there. No charges have been filed.
In April 2021, two people were shot and killed at a party in Wilmington, N.C. At least 30 people were there, and multiple people called 911 from inside the house where a birthday party was being held. No arrests have been made.
In Oakland, Calif., two people started shooting just inside the doors of Rudsdale Newcomer High School. Six people were shot, and one died months later due to complications from the wounds. The shooters have never been identified.
There are things that work, though. Building trust between police and communities is key, said Mr. Brunson, the University of Maryland criminologist.
Some police agencies do it better than others, he said, noting that law enforcement has to treat community members as if they were true partners, not a relationship in which police dictate the rules of engagement.
He said communities and community members are often seen as and treated like a complement or “symbolic community support.” He pointed to police press conferences with bereaved family members and community leaders after high-profile crimes.
“We bring them out when we need to have a press conference or whatever,” he said.
That was a key point in Mr. Brunson’s research — negative interactions with community members on a day-to-day basis marred the relationship to the point that people would no longer provide information if asked. One of the men interviewed said police would come after him for smoking marijuana but they were nowhere to be found when a shooting happened in the same park. That can make an individual reluctant to go to police even when they’re the victim.
“It’s demoralizing when crime victims see the people who are responsible for assaulting them walking around the neighborhood without any consequences,” he said. “It fuels the notion that they have to take justice into their own hands or carry guns because they can’t count on police.”
And that overlaps with the fear many witnesses feel when faced with the prospect of coming forward, Rev. Jones said. And the incident such as the one last week at the hookah lounge, where police believe there were several shooters, illustrates how many people are carrying guns, he said.
“If they did what they did to somebody else, they could do it to another person,” he said of the mindset. “There are a lot of big guns out here and a lot of people who will use them.”
He said witnesses are threatened, their families are threatened, and they might be labeled a snitch. Protectives services for witnesses can help, but then the entire family might have to be uprooted. Even then, he said, they’ll likely just be moved to somewhere else in the area.
“There are so many levels of problems that it brings,” Rev. Jones said.
If the case in which a witness is cooperating goes to court and the defendant is acquitted, it starts all over again.
“Now, once again, their life is being threatened, now they’re considered the opposition,” he said. “There are so many levels that make it dangerous to be able to say something.”
He called it a hardship that he and police and community leaders just have to deal with — it’s something that takes a village.
“I’m a believer that the average person wants whoever did that shooting to be arrested,” he said. “They’re just afraid to be involved because of what could happen. They don’t want to risk the chance of them and their name being involved in the situation.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.