A deadly shooting at an Airbnb party on the North Side two years ago sent local lawmakers into a scramble to find a way to rein in short-term rental units. After more than a year of debate, Pittsburgh City Council members passed new regulations, but lawsuits have held up enforcement of the changes. 

Two teens were killed, nine other people were shot and several injured trying to escape when a shooting broke out at a party inside a unit being rented as an Airbnb on April 17, 2022. Up to 200 people, most of whom were underage, were at the party, according to police reports.

Days later Councilman Bobby Wilson, who represents the North Side, introduced legislation to regulate short-term rentals like the ones listed on popular sites such as Airbnb and Vrbo. 

The goal was to make sure the city knew about the rentals and could reach the owners if needed. Although the April 2022 shooting was the catalyst that sparked the legislation, council members said they had been receiving complaints about such rentals across the city for months. 

Advertise with us

Reports about parties, parking violations and improper disposal of trash, as well as complaints of general nuisance behavior had been flooding council members’ inboxes, they said. 

One version of the legislation suggested that out-of-state owners would have to hire a local representative living within Allegheny County. Police said they had trouble getting in contact with the owners of the Airbnb that was the site of the 2022 shooting because the property was owned by an out-of-state limited liability company. 

The legislation would have also required owners of short-term rentals to keep a log of guests, which would have been made available to code enforcement officers. In the end, neither of those measures made it into the final bill. 

Ultimately, after nearly 18 months of debate, City Council passed a pared-down version of the original legislation that combined the city’s efforts to regulate short-term rentals and to develop a registry of long-term rental units into one bill. For years, the city had been trying to establish a rental registry. 

“This new [bill] includes all rentals, whether someone rents for 24 hours or two years,” Mr. Wilson said when the bill was passed. “It’s stripped down to what we believe can stand the test of time.”

Advertise with us

The legislation requires owners of all rentals to obtain a yearly operating permit from the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections. The permit is contingent upon an inspection of the unit. 

As of Tuesday, there was still no place on the department’s website to apply for a permit, or information about fees and enforcement. PLI Director David Green declined to comment. 

Implementation of the bill is likely “not going anywhere fast,” said Lawrence Fisher, a lawyer representing the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, which filed a lawsuit against the city over the bill last October.

“And that’s a shame actually,” Mr. Fisher said. “Given that shooting, it’s probably not a bad idea to regulate [short-term rentals], but because the city has bootstrapped it to the overall rental registration debacle that they have pursued since 2009, it’s not going to happen. Not anytime soon.”

The apartment association, along with the Landlord Service Bureau Inc., a local organization that represents over 4,000 building owners in the region, filed separate suits against the city last fall, alleging the new permitting requirements are “illegal” and violate the state constitution. 

Advertise with us

Despite no enforcement of the legislation yet, Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh filed a motion in February asking for an injunction to prohibit the city from enacting it. No ruling has been issued. 

An ongoing legal battle

Neither organization is new to this fight. Both have sued the city for past iterations of rental registry legislation, some of which is still winding through the courts. 

While the newest legislation attempts to pair both long and short-term rentals together in the permitting process, the city has been attempting to establish a rental registry of long-term units since 2009. 

City Council approved a rental registry bill in 2021 — the third version of its kind — which was struck down by the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court last year. The court found that the registry, which included mandated training courses and disclosing inspection records in a public database, placed an excessive burden on landlords. The court found the city was “without authority to enact the rental ordinance in its present configuration.”

Last week, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court heard arguments by the city to overturn the lower court’s ruling. There is no timeline for when the state’s high court might issue an opinion. 

Advertise with us

Local owners of short-term rentals say they aren’t opposed to regulation, but they want to see it done properly.

“I believe regulation is a good thing when done properly,” said Chad Wise, a founder of Steel City Short-Term Rental Alliance, which has more than 600 members who own short-term rentals in the region. “If it is overarching and broad brush strokes, I don’t think that is effective.”

Mr. Wise said his concern lies with the inspection process of the rental registry because of the cost and time it is going to take for the city to inspect every long and short-term rental unit. 

“That’s a massive lift,” he said. “I feel like there could be a more effective way to do that.”

When it comes to short-term rentals, Mr. Wise said renter reviews are a “natural mechanism for weeding out bad properties.” 

Advertise with us

“If you’re not a good host and you have bad properties, your property ends up being delisted and shut down by Airbnb,” he said. 

There have also been attempts by corporate Airbnb and by the owners themselves to crack down on things neighbors tend to complain about: parties, loud groups and houses with too many people in them.

Members of Steel City Short-Term Rental Alliance have been using a device called Minute, which has occupancy and decibel sensors. It doesn’t record, but rather monitors those levels and sends an alert to the owner when they exceed the set limit. 

“It’s a way to make sure your property is being well-maintained,” Mr. Wise said. 

In 2022, Airbnb codified its no-party policy, suspending renters who violate the policy. It has also developed a partnership with Vrbo to share information on “repeat party houses,” according to the company’s website. 

Advertise with us

“We want to be good hosts,” Mr. Wise said. “We want to be part of the community.”

In terms of future regulations for short-term rentals, he said he would like to see specific policy on what law enforcement is and isn’t allowed to do when it comes to responding to calls at rentals. 

“I would like to have very clear guidelines on when, if you have a problem and get the authorities involved, what that response looks like,” he said. “Maybe it’s not a party, but we have more people than we expected, what is the process behind that?”

A problem not unique to Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh hasn’t been the only city looking to get a handle on short-term rental units. In 2022, Philadelphia passed regulations in which owners have to get an operating license.

Two bills are currently moving through Hawaii’s legislative process that would ban short-term rental properties not occupied by their owner as the state battles rising home costs. 

Advertise with us

Short-term rentals like Airbnb were originally marketed as a way for homeowners to make extra money by renting out a room over their garage or an extra guest room. Since its inception in 2007, Airbnb has now transformed into a business for some people, where they buy and flip houses to list on rental websites. 

Vrbo, another popular short-term rental website, boasts in its commercials that it only lists entire private rentals, rather than renting a single room out of a home. 

Some City Council members wanted to add a stipulation to Pittsburgh’s legislation that would require the rentals to be the owner’s permanent residence. Ultimately, that measure did not make it to the approved version.