Two years after two teenage boys were killed in a mass shooting at a house party in a North Side Airbnb, information and answers remain hard to come by.

The early morning shooting on April 17, 2022, killed Jaiden Brown and Matthew Steffy-Ross, both 17. Nine other people were wounded by gunfire and others were hurt jumping from second-story windows to escape the shooting.

Investigators have estimated some 200 people were at the party, some of them young adults and many teenagers. Police have said around 100 rounds were fired inside and outside of the Suismon Street home, which was divided into two Airbnb units. They said evidence suggests there were multiple guns involved, including at least one AR 15-style rifle.

But it’s still not clear who rented the Airbnb or whether that person was present at the party. It’s unknown — at least publicly — how many shooters there were and how many guns were in play. And, as far as the public is concerned, it’s unknown what prompted the shooting, if it was targeted, and who pulled the triggers.

Advertise with us

The case went to a grand jury at least a year ago and, to date, no criminal charges have been filed.

Grand juries convene for 18 months at a time and often hear multiple cases. Unlike federal grand juries, those at the state level aren’t charged with rendering a decision.

“A state grand jury is purely investigative,” said Bruce Antkowiak, a Saint Vincent College law professor and former federal attorney. “They collect information, they collect data, and they create a record.”

That record can help guide a prosecutor as to whether charges should be filed.

“A grand jury recommendation is just that — a recommendation,” he said.

Advertise with us

Prosecutors have the obligation to scrutinize the report, Mr. Antkowiak said, but not to act on it. And there is no real timeline for prosecutors to make that decision.

“The question is whether or not they believe there is sufficient evidence to bring a charge,” he said. “If they decide there’s not, that’s the end of it.”

He said it’s unlikely that a prosecutor would announce a decision not to file charges.

‘Is there a meaning in this?’

Lee Davis is at a unique crossroads when it comes to the deadly violence from that night: He works in violence-prevention programs, and he also knew Jaiden and Matthew.

“I’m still kind of wrestling with that,” he said of the fact he knew both boys killed that night. “Is there a meaning in this?”

Advertise with us

He had known Jaiden for years, as the boy used to go to Mr. Davis’ family’s day care. He said he was quiet but “a cool little kid.”

As a 17-year-old, “you get into things,” Mr. Davis said. “But we all have.

“He was at that age where he was just trying to find himself and figure out life,” he said. “I wish I could have seen what he was going to become.”

Among other roles and endeavors, Mr. Davis is the director of violence prevention for Greater Valley Community Services and coordinator for the Greater Valley Coalition Against Violence. Some of his work includes life-skills classes at schools in the area, including the Community School East in Turtle Creek. That’s where he met Matthew.

“He was always sleeping,” Mr. Davis said. “Sometimes staff would come and say, ‘wake up,’ and I would say ‘no, just let him lay there, keep his head down. If he’s sleeping, he’s sleeping. It’s cool.’ ”

Advertise with us

When Matthew was awake, Mr. Davis said, the teen would try to see how far he could push the instructor. Once Matthew saw Mr. Davis wasn’t going to give him a reaction, “he finally started to come around.”

One day, a phone call came. The voice on the other end said he had heard Mr. Davis talk about being an entrepreneur and he had an idea for his own business. Mr. Davis asked who it was. It was Matt, from class, the voice replied.

“I’m like, ‘Matt? The Matt that doesn’t really say anything that just sits there and sleeps?’ ” Mr. Davis recalled asking.

Yes, that Matt.

“He said, ‘But I’ve been listening and I hear everything you’re saying,’ ” Mr. Davis recalled.

Advertise with us

Matthew had design ideas for a clothing company. The first ones Matthew offered up, Mr. Davis said, weren’t the best. He told the teen to try again, don’t take the lazy way out. The next ones were pretty good. They were going to call the company Mindset.

“The day that it happened —“ Mr. Davis started, and then paused.

He lowered his head and took a long pause, the silence almost heavy in the air. A few deep, shaky breaths. Then he continued.

Matthew’s grandma called Mr. Davis first: Had he seen Matthew? She knew he had gone home at some point that Saturday, as she had seen it on the doorbell camera, but then he left again. She hadn’t heard from him since.

Mr. Davis said he would make some calls. It was Easter Sunday.

Advertise with us

“I’d heard something had happened, but I didn’t know the extent of it,” he said of the overnight shooting.

He found out Matthew had been killed. He called the boy’s grandmother back, intending to tell her that he hadn’t found out anything and he’d keep trying. He wasn’t going to tell her what he knew.

But by the time he called, she already knew.

“I had to stop the car because I started crying,” Mr. Davis said. “And when I started crying, my mom, my wife, everybody else in the car just put their hands on me.

“And then I got the call about Jaiden,” he said. “I was just frozen, and then it was like a blur.”

Advertise with us

By the time the shooting started shortly after 12:30 a.m., the party had been going on for hours. Around 11 p.m., a Pittsburgh police officer responded to a noise complaint. While it isn’t clear who called in the complaint, a family staying in a lower rental unit in the building had fled for a hotel because of the noise from the party

A man answered the door, and the officer asked to speak with the homeowner; the man who answered the door said the homeowner was upstairs. The person presented as the homeowner met the officer downstairs, and officials have noted that because of that, the officer wasn’t able to see the area where the party was taking place.

The music was turned down as requested by the officer, police said. The officer left them with a warning that any further noise complaints would mean the party would be shut down. No other noise complaints were called in that night, police said.

Gunfire started about 90 minutes later.

The shooting left the small neighborhood reeling, but the effects went far beyond the North Side: Kids and young adults from all corners of the city and county were at the Saturday party that spilled into Sunday morning. When the shooting stopped, those kids took that trauma home with them.

Advertise with us

And so for the past two years, Mr. Davis has worked to shepherd young people through not just the violent deaths of Jaiden and Matthew, but through all of the others that have come since then.

“Unfortunately, for me and my staff, even though it’s been two years and we’re still dealing with certain things, how many young ones have we lost since then?” he said. “We have to be like medics, we’re on this and helping as much as we can but then we’ve got to get onto this family and then the next one and the next one.”