About 10 hours after a mass shooting early Sunday, the area around an Airbnb in East Allegheny where an under-age party turned violent was eerily quiet.

The scene was quite a contrast to the noisy party with upwards of 200 young people that occurred Saturday night into Sunday morning, a party that had would-be guests lined up on the street outside.

Chaos broke out when a disagreement inside led to dozens of shots fired from several weapons. Panicked guests tried to get away, some jumping out of second-story windows to Suismon Street below.

Two 17-year olds identified as Mathew Steffy-Ross, of Pitcairn, and Jaiden Brown, no home address listed, were killed and nine other people were shot.

Advertise with us

Neighbors described terrified teenagers and young adults sprinting out of the building and running down nearby streets and alleyways in the darkness, knocking on doors of nearby homes desperately looking for a place to escape to safety. Tires screeched as vehicles sped away, barely missing parked cars and rowhouses abutting the narrow roads in the neighborhood.

Hours after the shooting, a Venetian blind flapped outside one of the broken windows and shards of glass remained on the edges of the second one. Another second-story window at the rear also was shattered.

Across Suismon, vehicles belonging to television and newspaper reporters were interspersed with vehicles that had bullet holes in their windows and body panels from the earlier gunfire. Police investigators had been gone for several hours, but glass from the building’s broken windows was spread on the sidewalk and street on Suismon, and two garbage cans up against the building on Suismon were overflowing.

Other than reporters talking with each other and the click of photographers’ cameras, the only sound was the whirl of traffic on Madison.

The shooting was the fourth in less than 30 hours within city limits and the worst mass shooting in Pittsburgh since the 2018 Tree of Life synagogue massacre in Squirrel Hill.

Advertise with us

Marcella Holmes, 56, a lifelong North Side resident, said she’s considered moving away from Allegheny Commons because the violence has become so constant. The gunfire from the party was so loud that she took cover in her apartment out of fear that she might be hit by a stray bullet.

On Saturday, a man was killed in a shooting in the North Side neighborhood of Marshall-Shadeland. Sunday morning’s mass shooting marked the third fatal shooting in a North Side neighborhood in 2022.

“It depresses me,” Ms. Holmes said. “At the same time, it gives me motivation to seek another place to live. I know there is violence and danger everywhere, but there has to be somewhere other than [it] being right outside my window.”

Speaking just two blocks from the scene of the shooting at Cityview Church on Sunday, Ms. Holmes said she believes the violence doesn’t represent the North Side community.

Margo Hinton, 54, of Troy Hill, agreed.

Advertise with us

When she went to bed, Ms. Hinton was bombarded with news about a mass shooting in South Carolina. When she awoke, she was awash in text messages and phone calls from friends warning her about another mass shooting just minutes from her home.

“I’m not really in shock, because this is what’s going on right now,” said Ms. Hinton of her reaction to the shooting.

She said she believes there needs to be an ongoing commitment to social justice, community organizing and love in order to alleviate the violence that has rocked the city since the beginning of the year.

“We can’t really just pray it away,” Ms. Hinton said. “We actually have to get involved. We actually have to be part of the solution.”

North Side shooting

Ten people were shot, two fatally, in Pittsburgh’s East Allegheny neighborhood early Sunday morning.

Advertise with us