The Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office is reviewing the license of an East Carson Street bar that has been a trouble spot in recent weeks, even as large crowds that pour into Pittsburgh’s South Side each weekend have gone from unruly but nonviolent to spawning allegations of gunfire and assaults on police.

Capo’s, known for years as Carson City Saloon, is the subject of a review by the DA’s Nuisance Bar Task Force, officials said Tuesday. A spokesperson for the district attorney’s office declined to elaborate on specific allegations, citing the ongoing investigation.

The bar was sold earlier this year, though it’s not clear who is behind the limited liability company that bought the property for $1 million. The venue wasn’t open Tuesday, and the voicemail box linked to the main telephone number was full.

Recent fights and gunfire tied to the bar, which bills itself as a nightclub featuring “the best rooftop bar and college vibes on Carson” on social media, have led to increased scrutiny by politicians and police already weary from years spent battling the South Side entertainment district’s penchant for mayhem.

Advertise with us

The task force — made up of investigators from the district attorney’s office, Pittsburgh and Allegheny County police, state liquor enforcement agents and others — regularly conducts compliance checks at bars across the county, but also investigates complaints against specific establishments.

The review of the bar comes as new attention has been focused on the South Side, where a concentration of restaurants and bars has long been a draw for large gatherings of people enjoying summer nights and ready to party.

City officials and local establishments welcome the business, but not the disruption that has often followed. Officials have tried different measures to ease crowding and traffic on the South Side over the years, to varying degrees of success.

In summer 2021, as venues reopened with looser COVID-19 restrictions, city officials made the busiest portion of East Carson one way on Fridays and Saturdays. Side streets in that area were also closed to traffic save for South Side residents, and ride-share vehicles weren’t permitted to pick up or drop off along that stretch on weekend nights.

In 2023, the city introduced dedicated South Side Entertainment District patrols, which offered an increased police presence on and near East Carson Street at peak hours from Thursday to Sunday. The move came amid a spate of summer violence that pushed at least one bar — Carson City Saloon, which is now home to Capo’s on Carson — to shut down.

Advertise with us

Police spokeswoman Emily Bourne said this week that meetings about how to solve the South Side’s nightlife issues are ongoing and involve everyone from business owners and neighborhood groups to city government and the DA’s office.

All options, she said, remain on the table, including the possibility of making that stretch of East Carson pedestrian-only during peak hours.

She said that while nothing is set in stone yet, changes are on the horizon. Already, police and city officials are asking restaurants that are normally open past 2 a.m. to shutter alongside bars so patrons have no reason to stick around.

Ms. Bourne said that, up until recently, the crowds that poured into the streets at the bars’ closing time generally dispersed without much incident once a police line was formed to push people out of the area.

“This past weekend was a bit different where we saw [people] launching fireworks at officers,” Ms. Bourne said. She said the “violent nature of the crowd” necessitated the deployment of pepper spray.

Advertise with us

As the Fourth of July bled into July 5 and closing time came, officers detailed to the South Side began to work to physically disperse the lingering crowd — standard procedure, authorities said, when people failed to heed the verbal commands to clear out.

As that was happening, officials said, several people in the crowd launched lit fireworks toward officers and police vehicles. Two officers were hit with firework debris, police spokeswoman Eliza Durham said in a statement, and another was hit with a rock.

Ms. Durham said officers deployed pepper spray and smoke “only after officers and the vehicles were targeted with projectiles.” No tear gas was used, she said, and crowds cleared out by around 3 a.m.

Two teenagers were arrested and charged in connections with the fireworks incident.

About an hour before the closing-time disorder began, a McKees Rocks man was taken into custody not far from Capo’s after he allegedly fired multiple rounds into the air.

Advertise with us

That same stretch of East Carson was the site of multiple arrests the weekend prior.

Shortly after 2 a.m. June 29, officers responded to gunfire near South 14th and Sarah streets — about one block off East Carson.

According to the criminal complaint filed in that incident, two women confronted another woman as she sat in her car, allegedly attacking her once she got out. One woman pulled a gun and fired several shots into the air, police said. She was later charged with carrying a firearm without a license, assault and reckless endangerment.

No one was injured and no property was damaged, according to police. Ms. Bourne said a larger crowd that gathered after the altercation dispersed without incident.

In a separate incident the following night, a man was tasered when he refused to leave Capo’s after a fight with another patron. Authorities said the man continued to resist as the security guard — an off-duty officer with the county housing authority police — tried to maneuver the man down the stairs and out the door.

Advertise with us

Once that man was out of the bar and in police custody, Capo’s closed for the night — at which point “a large influx of unruly patrons began pouring outside,” authorities said.

And the weekend before that — early June 22 — law enforcement agencies from other municipalities sent officers to help clear a crowd of 1,500 to 2,000 people who flowed into the streets following last call.

Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV reported that some in the crowd began fighting, at which point backup was called to assist the dedicated South Side patrol officers.

Last year, the Pittsburgh police sergeant who heads the dedicated patrols suffered a broken leg as he tried to break up a fight outside of the now-closed Oddballs Bar in the 1500 block of East Carson. Oddballs came under the scrutiny of the DA’s nuisance bar task force and ultimately agreed to shut down.