A popular South Side bar permanently shut its doors Wednesday after a fight inside the establishment left a Pittsburgh Police officer with three broken bones, according to the Allegheny County district attorney.
The owners of Oddballs Bar, which is located in the 1500 block of East Carson Street, met with detectives from the DA's Nuisance Bar Task Force this week and agreed to cease business operations immediately, District Attorney Stephen Zappala said at a news conference at the Allegheny County Courthouse.
Mr. Zappala said that with permission from the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board, the business can reopen outside of city limits.
Sgt. Andrew Robinson, a Zone 3 officer and head of the South Side Entertainment Patrol Unit, was injured at the bar Saturday night after responding to a fight and had to undergo surgery due to his injuries. He told the Post-Gazette that he faces a recovery period of up to 12 months.
Jonathan Morin, 23, was charged with felony aggravated assault, resisting arrest and disorderly conduct in connection with the incident. He has a preliminary hearing scheduled for Sept. 18.
According to Mr. Zappala, 11 police reports have been filed in connection with the bar since May. He was unable to provide specific details regarding each incident.
Read More
"We had a discussion, and they understood they have to do that," Mr. Zappala said of Oddballs’ owners. "I'm very proud of these [owners] for sitting down and working this out with us."
In the days since, local leaders have called for the establishment to shutdown. On Sunday, City Councilman Bob Charland, state Sen. Jay Costa, and state Reps. Aerion Abbey and Jessica Benham released a joint statement that said Saturday's incident "highlights the ongoing issues with this establishment [Oddballs]."
In a social media post, the owners of Oddballs Southside said that some of the accusations about the bar's behavior is inaccurate, including being overcrowded, attracting a "nuisance crowd," having violations and operating irresponsibly.
At the time of the fight, Oddballs had 69 patrons inside, which is below their capacity of 113 people, the bar's owners said in the post. Further, the establishment has implemented multiple changes recommended by the Liquor Control Board and Sgt. Robinson himself, such as banning unruly customers, bag checks at the doors by security, hiring more security detail, and installing surveillance cameras inside and outside of the bar.
Overall, Oddballs Southside called the claims by area officials "a lie" and said that the bar has had minimal problems since implementing the changes last year.
Mr. Zappala also pushed back on city officials and the notion that his office bears sole responsibility for shutting down facilities that negatively impact neighborhoods. Anyone who lives within 500 feet of the establishment, the state Attorney General's Office, Pennsylvania State Police or the city of Pittsburgh could have brought the bar to court, he said.
"I appreciate the confidence the community has in me in this office to handle these types of matters. But actually — I don't have to initiate this," he said. "The city has a lot of rights; they don't have to wait for me to do something about it."
He was also critical of city officials' inaction regarding several other establishments the DA's Nuisance Bar Task Force, or NBTF, have previously or currently investigated. Among them are a nightclub in Homewood, a vape store on East Ohio Street, and a bar in Oakland.
"We're taking the lead even though all four establishments [under investigation] are in the City of Pittsburgh," he said.
A city spokesperson could not be reached for comment.
Throughout the past 14 years, the NBTF has conducted 500 inspections at nuisance bars — bars that operate in ways that create negative impacts on communities — which have resulted in about 400 arrests, according to the DA's Office.
Since 2000, 16 bars have consented to close before an injunction was filed and 60 bars have closed on their own following an investigation from the NBTF, according to the DA's Office.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.