A fight that started inside of a South Side bar and went into the street Saturday has left a Pittsburgh police officer with a broken foot and shin, and a man is accused of assaulting the officers trying to arrest him, causing an investigation by law enforcement amid local leaders calling for a shutdown of the establishment.

Jonathan Morin, 23, has been charged with felony aggravated assault, resisting arrest and disorderly conduct, according to court documents. He has a preliminary hearing scheduled for Sept. 18. Mr. Morin — who did not have an attorney listed in his court records — could not be reached for comment.

Pittsburgh police officers were on the South Side for a parking complaint when they heard Sgt. Andrew Robinson report a fight occurring on Carson Street at 1 a.m., according to the criminal complaint.

Sgt. Robinson is a Zone 3 officer and supervises the South Side Entertainment Patrol.

Advertise with us

Arriving at the scene, officers found Sgt. Robinson “actively fighting” with a man, who was later identified as Mr. Morin, at the 1500 block of East Carson Street on the sidewalk, the complaint said. Mr. Morin was trying to get away from the officers and grabbed one of their arms.

Sgt. Robinson grabbed onto Mr. Morin’s legs to stop him from getting away, according to the complaint. At the same time, another officer was trying to get control of Mr. Morin’s arms as he was swinging at the officers while lying on his back.

The officers continued to give Mr. Morin verbal commands to put his hands behind his back, but he kept swinging his arms and tried to grab one of the officers, according to the complaint. In an attempt to make Mr. Morin comply, one of the officers hit him in the left side of his face with a closed fist.

Mr. Morin then punched the officer on the left side of his face, according to the complaint. The officer continued attempting to arrest Mr. Morin while he continued to try to hit the officers.

At this time, “a large hostile crowd” gathered around the officers, the complaint said. Calling for backup, the officers were able to detain Mr. Morin.

Advertise with us

Other officers were trying to control the large crowd when it became clear that Sgt. Robinson was injured. The complaint said that Sgt. Robinson “suffered an obvious deformity to the right ankle” when trying to arrest Mr. Morin.

Pittsburgh EMS eventually transported Sgt. Robinson to a hospital, according to the complaint.

While in the ambulance, Sgt. Robinson said that he was dealing with another individual outside of Oddballs Bar, at the 1500 block of East Carson Street, when Mr. Morin interfered and grabbed another officer by the vest, according to the complaint.

Sgt. Robinson said he tried to stop Mr. Morin and Mr. Morin tried to punch him, the complaint said. Trying to get Mr. Morin into custody, Sgt. Robinson said he believes his foot got caught on the entrance of the bar, causing him to possibly break his ankle.

Sgt. Robinson told the Post-Gazette on Tuesday that he sustained three broken bones, including a broken tibia and fibula, during the incident. He’s scheduled to undergo surgery on Wednesday, and he faces between 6 months to a year of recovery. He will receive workers’ compensation, according to public safety officials.

Advertise with us

In a statement Tuesday, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said that detectives from the Nuisance Bar Task Force are investigating the incident, and met with the owners of the bar and state Liquor Control Enforcement to determine what, if any, administrative measures need to be taken with its license to operate, including, but not limited to, the closure of the establishment.

He said he also intends to meet with a group of South Side merchants as soon as this week.

“The discussion of taking away a business’s ability to operate is a very serious subject,” Mr. Zappala said. “We will be prepared to have that conversation if needed. Right now, we are gathering the necessary information and wishing Sgt. Robinson a quick recovery.”

On Sunday, City Councilman Bob Charland, state Sen. Jay Costa, and state Reps. Aerion Abbey and Jessica Benham released a shared statement that said Saturday’s events, and Sgt. Robinson’s injury, “highlights the ongoing issues with this establishment [Oddballs].”

“This incident underscores a pressing issue: another violent event on our historic main street is one too many and impacts the business district and residents in intolerable ways,” the elected officials said in the statement. “We look forward to swift action from the Nuisance Bar Task Force, LCE, LCB, Mayor Gainey’s Disruptive Properties Program, District Attorney Zappala, and all relevant agencies to address this problematic bar and ensure it shuts down for the safety of everyone on East Carson Street.”

Advertise with us

Sgt. Robinson declined to comment on the business, calling a potential shutdown “outside his authority.”

For more than 13 years, Sgt. Robinson has been stationed on the South Side and has overseen the South Side Entertainment Patrol — a special patrol that allocated more officers to East Carson Street and emphasizes high-visibility and enforcement policing — since its formation in July 2023. In an interview last month, he told the Post-Gazette that assaults on officers from the special patrol were “way down.”

There is no publicly available data on patrol-specific officer assaults.

Following Saturday’s incident, Sgt. Robinson expressed full confidence in the patrol and its ability to carry on in his absence.

“They are experienced and professional and I have no doubt they will get the job done,” he said.

Advertise with us

Despite his injuries, Sgt. Robinson said he’s eager to return to his post on East Carson Street and continue serving South Side community members, who rallied behind him following the incident.

“I have received phone calls, text messages, emails, and even a dinner or two from the business owners, security members, and community members of the South Side — not to mention the support I have received from fellow police officers and administration in the city and around the county,” he said, calling it “amazing.”

In a social media post, the owners of Oddballs Southside said that some of the accusations about the bar’s behavior is inaccurate, including being overcrowded, attracting a “nuisance crowd,” having violations and operating irresponsibly.

At the time of the fight, Oddballs had 69 patrons inside, which is below their capacity of 113 people, the bar’s owners said in the post. Further, the establishment has implemented multiple changes recommended by the Liquor Control Board and Sgt. Robinson himself, such as banning unruly customers, bag checks at the doors by security, hiring more security detail, and installing surveillance cameras inside and outside of the bar.

Overall, Oddballs Southside called the claims by area officials “a lie” and said that the bar has had minimal problems since implementing the changes last year.

Advertise with us

“Closing Oddballs is not the solution to the problems the South Side faces,” the bar’s owners said in the post. “We wish the best for every business that operates responsibly and look forward to seeing more progress be made. We wish Sgt. Robinson a full recovery and a quick return to the Entertainment Task Force, which has undoubtedly been successful in its mission to curb crime.”

In an interview with the Post-Gazette last month, Theo Cospy, 33, a bouncer at Oddballs, said fights and unruliness on East Carson Street — which heightened during and after the pandemic — were on a downward trajectory.

“There was a time where people who didn’t belong down here, underage kids, robberies, breaking into cars and starting fights,” he said, standing outside of Oddballs on a Thursday night in August. “And I feel like now it’s becoming back to what it used to be.”

So far this year, 95 aggravated assaults were reported in Zone 3 — where the South Side is located — according to police data.