Though investigators failed to determine exactly how fast Andrew Voigt was driving as he crossed the Mansfield Bridge from McKeesport into Dravosburg early Sept. 20, 2023, a judge said Thursday there’s enough evidence to know that it was far too fast for rush hour during a school year.
And, Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer said, Mr. Voigt had to have known that: He took that route to work often, the judge said, and he knew that speeding through that stretch created a risk to everyone on the road.
And on that morning, that included 15-year-old Samantha Kalkbrenner, her three classmates and the driver of the Ford transit van taking them to Serra Catholic High School.
Although Mr. Voigt’s car never struck the school van, his speed still put them at risk — even, the judge said, if he wasn’t racing the car that actually struck the van and killed the teenager.
Prosecutors have alleged that Mr. Voigt and William Soliday were racing in the miles leading up to the crash, pointing to the fact that both men worked for Bettis Labs in West Mifflin and to testimony from multiple witnesses that it looked like Mr. Voigt was trying to catch Soliday.
“Context is everything,” Judge Beemer said. “I agree that speed in and of itself does not necessarily establish recklessness, but it is all contextual.”
Read More
Two vehicles speeding at 90 to 100 mph on Interstate 279 creates a “vastly different risk” than the one Mr. Voigt helped create as he and another man sped through the commercial section of McKeesport into the residential area of Dravosburg.
The judge found Mr. Voigt, 56, guilty of five counts of recklessly endangering another person along with several driving violations. He found Mr. Voigt not guilty of racing and failing to stop at an accident scene.
Mr. Voigt slumped in his seat as Judge Beemer explained his verdict. He did not look at the judge. Sentencing is scheduled for Aug. 19.
He has denied that he was in any sort of race with Soliday, and his defense attorney, Kevin Chernosky, argued that prosecutors provided no proof other than the perception of several witnesses on the road that morning.
Soliday pleaded guilty last month to third-degree murder and was sentenced to 5½ to 12 years in prison.
“It’s just as likely that two people with cars that can drive fast were going fast on a road where people go fast,” Mr. Chernosky said, telling Judge Beemer that no one could prove how fast Mr. Voigt was going, and there was no proof the men had agreed to race that morning.
Judge Beemer agreed in part, finding Mr. Voigt not guilty of racing.
“Candidly, that question remains open,” he said.
Even though prosecutors couldn’t prove exactly how fast Mr. Voigt was going — his Jeep Grand Cherokee’s event data recorder made no records that morning because he was not involved in any sort of event that would trigger it — the evidence was there, Judge Beemer said.
He pointed to video of the crash captured by a Tesla heading in the opposite direction. It shows school van driver Richard Maleski pulling from Third Avenue onto Richland Avenue, followed by Soliday’s white Volkswagen Jetta smashing into the side of it. The van jerks unnaturally, and it ultimately lifted off the ground before landing on its side. Three of the students inside were thrown out of the windows, including Samantha.
But the video shows something else, too: Mr. Voigt’s Jeep passing the crash scene within seconds of impact — two seconds, to be exact, the judge said. Still images from the video showed Mr. Voigt was past the scene before the van had even come to a rest on its side.
But for those two seconds, Judge Beemer said, Mr. Voigt would have been the one who hit the van.
Testimony in the non-jury trial began Wednesday afternoon and continued into Thursday morning. Assistant District Attorney Lauren Sowko called four drivers who were on the road and saw Mr. Voigt and Soliday that morning and two detectives in the case.
Mr. Chernosky called Mr. Maleski as his only witness. Hospital records showed Mr. Maleski had cocaine metabolites — essentially, the remnants of cocaine — in his system. He told hospital staff he had last used cocaine six days earlier, although he said Thursday he couldn’t remember anything about his time in the hospital.
Mr. Chernosky asked if the cocaine affected his decision to pull out.
“No,” he said. “I was not high.”
Mr. Maleski has not been charged in any facet of the crash, and the District Attorney’s office offered him immunity in exchange for his testimony.
He was hospitalized for four days. He suffered a broken sternum and ribs and a torn rotator cuff, biceps and labrum.
He had just picked up Sam when he came to the intersection of Third and Richland. He paused and looked both directions, he said, and then Sam dropped her water bottle. He told her to go ahead and get it. Then he looked again, he said, and pulled onto Richland.
“The way was clear. It was safe,” he said. “I never seen that car.”
The next thing he knew, he said, he was upside down, and the girls and one of the boys he was responsible for were missing. He helped the remaining boy out of the van and tried to look for the girls. The van was on top of Sam, and he tried to push it off.
“I was yelling for help,” he said.
Eventually, help did come, in the form of passersby who testified they had seen the white Jetta and dark Jeep speeding in and out of traffic just before the crash.
‘Fishtailed all over the place’
Jessica McCauley was in the passenger seat of her family’s Prius as she and her husband, Gregory, drove their son to school that morning. She was the first in her car to notice the Jeep, she said — she yelled out as the Jeep fishtailed and its tires briefly squealed.
“I said to my husband it looked like a road-rage incident because of the way he was driving,” she said, recalling that the Jeep sped into the lane in front of them and then back out to go around a truck pulling a trailer in front of them.
“He kind of fishtailed all over the place,” said her husband, who admitted that he was speeding at around 60 mph and couldn’t keep up with the Jeep, which he said “just kind of disappeared.”
They were the first ones to come upon the scene moments later, Mr. McCauley said, and his voice cracked as he described the flaming Jetta and mangled school van. The Jeep, he testified, was nowhere in sight.
Michael Sisko was behind the wheel of the truck in front of the McCauley family. He said the white Jetta and the Jeep caught his attention “because of their high rate of speed.” He said the Jetta flew up behind him and then around him, followed a few seconds later by the Jeep.
When he came upon the crash scene, he testified, the Jeep wasn’t there.
In his initial interview with police, played in court Thursday morning, Mr. Voigt said he left the scene because he was scared.
He met four detectives the same day as the crash at a pizza place across the street from Bettis, where he and Soliday worked. Both have maintained they didn’t know one another.
But, Mr. Voigt said in the interview recorded on Detective Blake Maloney’s body-worn camera that he did notice the white Jetta and saw the crash.
“He was going pretty fast,” Mr. Voigt said of Soliday’s white GTI Volkswagen Jetta. “I was behind the Volkswagen and saw the truck pull out in front of him.”
He saw the impact, he said, and then panicked and pulled his Jeep Grand Cherokee onto a cross street.
“I lost control of my bowels … I started throwing up,” he said, recalling that as the Jetta pulled away from him coming across the Mansfield Bridge he thought, “I hope he slows down.”
How did Mr. Voigt know it was a “he,” one of the detectives asked.
“I assumed it was a guy to be driving that fast,” he said.
As detectives pressed him on his actions — and inactions, as he failed to stop at the crash scene or call 911 — they pushed him to admit that he was racing with the Jetta.
“I think there’s a lot more to it,” one detective said.
He denied numerous times that he was racing the driver of the Jetta, and he denied speeding to the point that he fishtailed on the Mansfield Bridge like witnesses reported to police. He conceded that he was probably speeding and he should have called 911 or contacted police about what he saw.
“I was upset,” he said. “I saw a serious accident.”
“It was so serious that you wet yourself and puked on yourself but you chose not to call 911 and not stick around on scene and talk to police?” Detective Maloney asked?
Mr. Voigt said he panicked and locked up.
Detectives told him that witnesses believed he had been chasing the Volkswagen and was going so fast that he fishtailed going around the last curve of the bridge. Mr. Voigt said he never fishtailed.
“I would have to be going pretty fast for that,” he said.
“I agree,” Detective Maloney told him. “I think you were going pretty fast. That’s what I think.”
Mr. Voigt said he drove home, cleaned himself up, and drove to work. Police showed him a photo of his Jeep taken from a traffic camera early that morning, pointing out a sticker on his rear windshield: A tank running over stick figures that said “no one cares about your stick figure family.”
Where was that sticker now, detectives asked. Mr. Voigt said he scraped it off — “it sent a bad message.”
“You picked a really odd time to take it off, if you follow me,” a detective said.
Detectives leaned into Mr. Voigt’s military history — he said he retired from the military in 2009 after two tours of duty in Iraq, where he had been a tanker.
Detective Maloney recounted Mr. Voigt’s story back to him: A combat veteran doesn’t stop at the scene, wets himself and pukes on himself, thinks about calling 911 but doesn’t, goes home and decides while he’s changing his clothes to take the sticker off because it “sends a bad message,” and then drives to work in a different car.
“Does any of that sound silly as [expletive] to you?” the detective asked?
“It sounds like someone who didn’t do the right thing,” Mr. Voigt said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.