Nenita Kalkbrenner spoke quickly, rushing through her victim impact statement so fast each word ran together — as if she needed to push past each pause before the sobs she held in broke through.
“Where do I even begin?” she asked.
She started with the morning of Sept. 20, 2023 — the morning her daughter, Samantha, was killed when a car driven by William Soliday II slammed into her school van. She talked about that first night at home without her, and how the world crumbled when she saw her only child in a casket. She spoke of struggling to find meaning each day since.
As she neared the end of her prepared statement, she pulled a photo of the 15-year-old from the folder she had carried to the front of Judge Bruce Beemer’s courtroom.
“Look, Mr. Soliday,” she demanded, her voice rising with each word. “This is my daughter that you took from us.”
Sheriff’s deputies moved closer but did not stop her from addressing directly the man who caused the crash that killed her daughter.
Read More
Soliday, hands shackled and shoulders hunched, looked at the photo and then bowed his head, weeping.
“I want you to remember her smile,” Ms. Kalkbrenner told him.
Soliday, 44, pleaded guilty Tuesday morning to third-degree murder for causing the violent crash that killed Samantha and injured three of her Serra Catholic classmates. His plea, which spared the court a trial set to begin that morning, was in exchange for 5½ to 12 years in prison.
Friends and family members filled half of the fifth-floor courtroom, and dozens more watched via video feed from another room. The judge received another 47 impact statements ahead of sentencing.
“You stole her from so many people that loved her,” Judge Beemer said. “I hope that every day you continue to think about your actions … and what this world has been robbed of.”
Soliday, through sobs, told the Kalkbrenner family that he was sorry but acknowledged that “no words can ease the pain.”
“I carry immense sorry and regret for my actions,” Soliday said. “My heart will always bear the weight of this tragedy.”
The Rev. Aaron Garber, of Calvin Presbyterian Church in North Huntingdon, said he met Soliday after the crash and has worshipped with him almost every week since then. He said Soliday prays for Samantha and her family daily.
Flanna Soliday said her husband is not a monster — rather, he is a flawed human who made a mistake.
“Our phone calls are laden with pain, sorrow, and genuine remorse,” she said.

’The best of all of us’
Ms. Kalkbrenner said her family agreed to the plea deal in part because they had to think beyond just themselves — three other students on the van were seriously injured in the crash, she said, and they had been through enough.
Among them was Cullen Boring, whose mother, Denise Boring, told the court her son hasn’t been the same since the day of the crash. When she first spoke to him at the hospital, she said, he kept telling her, “Sam is trapped.”
“He saw the car speeding toward the bus,” she said. “He knew they were going to be hit right before it happened.”
The teenager was thrown from the van and landed on the flaming hood of Soliday’s Volkswagen GTI. Ms. Boring said her son remains distant, determined to move forward without help. She said it’s difficult not knowing the depths of the pain he’s going through.
Alonna Morton was in the van, too. She said the softball field had long been her happy place, but the spinal injuries she suffered have left her unable to play like she used to.
She told Soliday she wishes he had just been more careful.
“It didn’t just hurt my body,” Ms. Morton said, “it broke my spirit.”
Friends described erratic sleep patterns, falling grades and irreparable damage to their hearts and minds in the aftermath of Samantha’s death. Milestones, they said — driver’s licenses, proms, graduations — are reminders of the things their friend would never get to do.
They were supposed to graduate together, said her boyfriend, Tyler Sapida. He called her his best friend.
“Even in the pain, there’s a sense of joy for having known and loved Sam,” he said.
Another defendant in the case, 38-year-old Andrew Voigt, was not involved in the crash itself, but investigators have maintained that he and Soliday were racing that morning. Both men have denied the claim, and the illegal racing charge against Soliday was withdrawn as part of his plea agreement.
Investigators say the men, who both worked at Bettis Atomic Power in West Mifflin but maintain they don’t know each other, reached speeds over 100 mph as they sped through McKeesport in the moments leading up to the Richland Avenue crash. The force of the impact caused the Ford transit van to leave the road, and it spun in midair before landing on its side. Three of the four students on board were thrown out of the van, including Samantha.
Soliday’s Volkswagen caught fire. Mr. Voigt, investigators say, kept driving. He later told police he pulled his Jeep Grand Cherokee onto a side street where he vomited on himself and “lost control of his bowels.” He said he went home, cleaned up and took a different vehicle to work.
Carl Kalkbrenner said his daughter was like if you took the best part of everyone she knew and put them all together.
“She was as close to perfect as a child can get,” he said. “She loved her life and everything in it. She was the best of all of us.”
At each mention of her daughter’s death, Ms. Kalkbrenner sobbed in the courtroom gallery. After the hearing, as dozens of her daughter’s friends poured into the hall, she smiled. She said she asked her daughter for strength that morning.
“All I said was, ‘Mommy’s ready — whatever the outcome, we’re ready,’ ” she said. “Because we choose to be good. If we choose to be good, we know that we’re going to see her in heaven. That’s all we have to remember.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.