Silence hung heavy over the packed courtroom Tuesday, broken only by the stifled sobs of two mothers, sitting on opposite sides of the room.
More than two dozen people crowded the benches on the fifth floor of the Allegheny County Courthouse, waiting anxiously for Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer to hand down the final sentence in a crash that killed 15-year-old Samantha Kalkbrenner nearly two years ago.
Among them was Samantha’s mother, Nenita Kalkbrenner, and Linda Phillips, the mother-in-law of Andrew Voigt — each trembling as they latched on to every word spoken by Judge Beemer.
“I consider this one of the most difficult sentencing decisions this court has seen,” Judge Beemer said, before ultimately ordering Voigt to up to 4½ years in state prison in connection to the crash.
Voigt was one of two men found to be speeding along the Mansfield Bridge from McKeesport into Dravosburg in the minutes leading up to the moment a school van carrying four Serra Catholic High School students was violently hit on its side. Witnesses testified that both drivers appeared to be weaving in and out of traffic at speeds pushing 90 to 100 mph.
While video evidence showed Voigt’s Jeep passed the crash site just two seconds after the impact, he denied racing and was ultimately acquitted of the charge.
Read More
Instead, he was found guilty of five counts of reckless endangerment of another person, along with several other driving violations during a nonjury trial in May. On Tuesday, his sentencing included a minimum of 16 months and maximum of 54 months in prison, with no bond.
William Soliday II, the driver who actually struck the school van, was sentenced to up to 12 years in prison in April.
“It’s sheer luck that you didn’t strike the van instead of Mr. Soliday,” Judge Beemer said Tuesday.
‘I ask her for strength’
Coming up on what would have been Samantha’s senior year of high school, family and friends delivered final statements to the court.
Serra Catholic Principal Robert Childs was one of the first on scene following the crash. While reading a prepared statement, his hands shook. He told Judge Beemer that he still sees images of Samantha when he closes his eyes.
“The trouble comes when things are not busy,” he said.
He still goes to Samantha’s memorial in the school and talks to her.
“I ask her for strength, not just for myself, but for others,” he said.
For Maggie Bevan, “the whole morning plays on repeat for the last two years, every Wednesday.”
Ms. Bevan’s son, Tyler, was Sam’s first friend in kindergarten, she said. When she told her children, “neither of them would get in the car,” she said.
“This was an accident that could have been avoided,” she said. “If one chose not to speed, maybe the other wouldn’t have.”
Supporters and loved ones also criticized Voigt’s behavior following the crash. Voigt told investigators he witnessed the crash and then panicked and pulled his Jeep Grand Cherokee onto a cross street.
“I lost control of my bowels. … I started throwing up,” he told investigators. Voigt said he then drove home, cleaned himself up, and drove to work — in a different car.
Detectives noted that Voigt also scraped a sticker off the rear windshield of his Jeep, one that showed a tank running over stick figures with the caption, “no one cares about your stick figure family.”
In their final statements to the court, Voigt’s family explained his reactions as a result of post-traumatic stress disorder, a diagnosis he received after two tours in Iraq.
“I believe he had a flashback from Iraq,” said Voigt’s mother-in-law, Linda Phillips. Since the accident, she said it just has been “a constant reminder of Iraq” for him.
But Samantha’s father, Karl Kalkbrenner, said he wasn’t convinced. Mr. Kalkbrenner, an ex-Marine, said he was “appalled” to learn that a combat veteran would leave the scene when there was the possibility that people needed help.
“We all have PTSD,” he said. “It’s not an excuse.”
‘Total incarceration is necessary’
Voigt’s defense attorney, Kevin Chernosky, pressed for leniency. Citing Voigt’s lack of a criminal record, his military service and more than 20 letters of support from friends and family, Mr. Chernosky asked the judge to set aside the reckless driving conviction and to consider supervision instead of incarceration.
“This does not give the full picture of Mr. Voigt’s character,” Mr. Chernosky said.
Those who spoke on his behalf described him as a family man and a man of faith. They said he had a strong moral compass and is the “kind of person who would help others if he could.”
Eric Voigt said he has been on numerous road trips with his brother and said he was a safe driver. He also noted Voigt’s role as a caretaker for their aging parents.
“If he can’t drive, our parents will suffer,” he said.
The last to speak was Voigt himself, who, as he looked over his shoulder at Samantha’s loved ones, described how painful the day of the crash was.
He said he constantly prays “he’ll wake up and this was all just a nightmare.”
Moments later, he asked the onlookers in the courtroom to join him as he read a prayer aloud. Members of his family mouthed the words behind him.
After hearing final statements from both sides, Judge Beemer said he considered all actions — before, during and after the crash.
“Up until that day, you lived a productive life full of strong relationships,” he said. “But I’m forced to try to balance that with the utter devastation you are partially responsible for.”
He ultimately decided that “total incarceration is necessary.”
As the sentence was read, Voigt’s face paled. When he stood up from his seat at the defense table, his balance wavered and he looked as though he might faint.
Deputies patted his face with tissues before ultimately pulling him up from his chair and placing him in handcuffs.
Then he was escorted out of the courtroom, avoiding eye contact with those who looked on with grim faces.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.