A former Pittsburgh police commander accused of spying on his officers using planted body-worn cameras — and who faces a federal lawsuit in connection with those allegations — is suing the city in an attempt to force them to pay for his civil defense, alleging the entire incident was part of a criminal investigation into what he called salary fraud and official misconduct.
Matthew Lackner, 51, retired in October 2023, weeks after he was caught hiding department-issued body-worn cameras in certain police vehicles and, in one case, to record a conversation with an officer in his Zone 2 office. Officers using the cruisers ultimately discovered the cameras, though the then-commander had recorded 75 hours of video and audio across 11 separate recordings by then, Allegheny County detectives said.
Seven officers who were captured on camera filed a federal lawsuit in March 2024 against Lackner, the city and other police officials, though the court has dismissed all defendants other than Lackner.
In his lawsuit, Lackner claims he and his attorneys have asked the city four times for defense and indemnification as it relates to the federal lawsuit, claiming he used the cameras to investigate “official misconduct” by the officers suing him.
He alleged the officers “were driving their work-owned undercover vehicles to their private residences and spending their on-the-job hours at home and still wrongly collecting compensation for it.”
“The evidence will overwhelmingly show that Cmdr. Lackner’s actions were very much within the scope of his office and duties, as it was indeed required by them,” the lawsuit claims.
Read More
State law dictates that government agencies must indemnify, or protect against legal liability, employees who are acting within the scope of their official duties. In this case, Lackner has alleged that he used the body cams as part of an official investigation, and so the city must pay for his defense in the officers’ federal lawsuit.
Neither Mayor Ed Gainey’s office nor Lackner’s attorneys responded to requests for comment.
Richardson Todd Eagen, the attorney representing the seven officers in the federal lawsuit, denied any misconduct on the part of his clients. He balked at the fact that Lackner is only now alleging that he was investigating misconduct.
“This is simply Lackner’s response in an effort to try to get the city to pay the legal fees — and the judgement he knows is coming,” Mr. Eagen said.
Among the reasons the city can be free from indemnification is if there’s a “judicial determination” that the employee’s actions constitute “a crime, actual fraud, actual malice or willful misconduct.”
Lackner claimed in his lawsuit the city is denying indemnification on the grounds that the original criminal complaint filed against him in 2024 — which charged him with four felony counts of violating the state’s wiretap laws — constitutes such a judicial determination.
Lackner said that neither a criminal complaint nor a judge’s signature on a criminal complaint prove that his actions constituted a crime or misconduct. The District Attorney’s office allowed Lackner to enter an Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, or ARD. Entering into the ARD program does not constitute a guilty plea, conviction or admission of wrongdoing.
“As such,” the lawsuit claimed, “no court has determined that Cmdr. Lackner’s alleged actions at issue were not within the scope of his office or his duties” or that they amounted to a crime, fraud, malice or misconduct..
A similar issue involving a former Pittsburgh police officer made it to the state Supreme Court. In that case, then-Officer Colby Neidig in 2012 chased down and punched a teenager he caught smashing pumpkins in the officer’s neighborhood.
The teen sued the officer and the city, though the city was ultimately dismissed from the lawsuit, and Mr. Neidig was ordered to pay $75,000 plus attorney’s fees. The city and fought the indemnification, saying Mr. Neidig was acting as a private citizens and was solely responsible for the claim.
The issue went to the state Supreme Court, where the plaintiff’s attorneys argued the federal jury had found Mr. Neidig was acting under the “color of the law” when he chased and punched the teen, who by that point in 2022 was in his 20s. His attorneys said “color of law” and “within the scope of his office or duties” were interchangeable.
The court ruled in favor of the city, saying the two phrases did not mean the same thing and thus “a police officer may sometimes act both under the color of state law and beyond the scope of his or her employment.”
Pennsylvania courts have ultimately ruled that an employee’s actions are considered with the scope of their employment if: it’s in line with his job; it occurs during a time and place that’s within the scope of the job; and it’s done, at least in part, in furtherance of an employer’s interests.
Lackner’s lawsuit claims he meets all of those prongs: part of his job was to supervise subordinates; the actions were done while he was a Zone 2 commander; and it was all in the interest of the bureau and city because the investigation was into “criminal acts victimizing the city and its taxpayers.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.