The state Supreme Court this week announced it would take on the case of a man who seeks payment from the City of Pittsburgh after an off-duty police officer injured him over a teenage prank in 2012.

Shane McGuire, who was 16 at the time, had his nose broken by now-Sgt. Colby Neidig after the teen smashed pumpkins in the officer’s New Homestead neighborhood and repeatedly rang his doorbell.

A federal jury in 2017 said that even though Sgt. Neidig did not have a badge or gun on him, he was acting under color of state law as a police officer, and he used excessive force to subdue Mr. McGuire. The jury awarded Mr. McGuire $75,000. The officer the said the city should be responsible for the payment, citing a Pennsylvania statute regarding indemnification — compensation for harm — for municipal employees.

But when attorneys for the city told a jury in the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court that Sgt. Neidig was acting as a private citizen, despite the federal jury’s findings, they agreed, and the court told the city that it wasn’t responsible. After Mr. McGuire appealed the case, the Commonwealth Court ruled in March that it was not the city’s duty to pay him.

Advertise with us

If that decision is upheld by the state Supreme Court, Mr. McGuire — now 25 years old and serving overseas in the Navy — won’t receive any money at all because Sgt. Neidig assigned his right to indemnification to Mr. McGuire after the man agreed not to pursue the sergeant personally, a common arrangement in this type of case.

The issue now in front of the court is whether the federal jury’s finding that the police officer acted “under color of state law” counts as a “judicial determination.” The court will also determine legal criteria regarding how courts decide employee indemnification.

“The Commonwealth Court's ruling frustrates the [law] by permitting a municipality to deny indemnification to a police officer who used force that did not rise to the level of willful misconduct, but was later determined to be objectively unreasonable,” Mr. McGuire’s appeal reads.

It continues: “The practical impact of this is that officers, who are required to use force as part of their jobs, have no assurance of indemnification when they do so. Every time a police officer is found, after the fact, to have used objectively unreasonable force in his official capacity, the municipality can refuse to indemnify that officer, claiming that he acted outside the ‘scope of his office or duties.’”

Timothy O’Brien, Mr. McGuire’s attorney, said the case not only provides his client an opportunity to finally receive the compensation, but will settle the debate on whether or not cities are responsible to pay in these types of matters.

Advertise with us

“This case may result in a Supreme Court decision that defines, once and for all, when and under what circumstances municipalities must indemnify their police officers who have violated citizens constitutional rights,” he said in a phone interview.

A spokesperson said the city is unable to comment on pending litigation. .

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli