When Colby Neidig chased a teenager who had been smashing pumpkins in his New Homestead neighborhood and then rang his doorbell repeatedly in 2012, he told a jury, he did not have his Pittsburgh police-issued badge or gun on him.
Instead, he said, he set out to protect his family from what he thought might be an attempted home invasion.
In 2017, a federal jury found that now-Sgt. Neidig was acting under color of state law and that he used excessive force to subdue Shane McGuire — including breaking the 16-year-old’s nose.
The federal jury awarded $75,000 to Mr. McGuire, who is enlisted as a Navy corpsman and was recently in Afghanistan.
Sgt. Neidig sought to be indemnified by his employer, the city of Pittsburgh, asking that it be responsible for paying the judgment against him, citing the Pennsylvania statute that governs indemnification for municipal employees.
Attorneys for the city claim, however, that Sgt. Neidig’s actions were that of a private citizen, and that he was not acting under the authority of the Pittsburgh police at the time of the incident. Therefore, the city should not be held responsible to pay the federal award.
Read More
In August, an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court jury agreed, finding that Sgt. Neidig was not acting within the scope of his employment as a police officer, which meant the city is not required to pay the federal judgment.
That means that Mr. McGuire, 23, won’t receive any money, because Sgt. Neidig assigned his right to indemnification to Mr. McGuire, who, in exchange, agreed not to pursue the sergeant personally — a common practice in cases like this.
The result is that the young man and the person who hit him are now basically on the same side.
Sgt. Neidig would be judgment-proof because he does not have individual, personal assets to cover the amount of money awarded, said Timothy P. O’Brien, Mr. McGuire’s lawyer.
On Tuesday, Mr. O’Brien argued that Common Pleas Judge Michael Della Vecchia ought to throw out that verdict and require the city to pay.
“The case should have never have been given to a jury,” Mr. O’Brien said.
Because the federal jury found that Sgt. Neidig was acting under the color of law, the lawyer said, the city should be on the hook for the money.
The federal jury verdict has never been reversed or overturned, Mr. O’Brien said. Therefore, there should have been no question that the city was responsible to pay.
“That’s why this case is a travesty,” Mr. O’Brien said. “A citizen should not be put through the wringer two times in any case, especially when that citizen is out fighting for [his] country.”
Mr. O’Brien said later that he believed the city was going to settle and pay the federal court judgment and attorney fees, which would have been around $225,000. However, he said that when it was time for Mayor Bill Peduto to sign off on the settlement, the mayor refused.
City spokesman Timothy McNulty said he can’t comment on pending legal action.
According to court testimony, Sgt. Neidig had just returned to his home with his wife and infant the night of Nov. 10, 2012, when he noticed smashed pumpkins along the street and at his house. As he was unloading groceries in his garage, he heard loud banging and then his wife screamed.
He believed someone was trying to break in, so he chased him.
Sgt. Neidig chased the person for about a half-mile into nearby woods before finally catching up to him. He said he grabbed him by his sweatshirt, and punched the person once in the face.
He never identified himself as a police officer.
It turns out, Mr. O’Brien said, that Mr. McGuire was out pulling pranks with his friends that night — smashing pumpkins and ringing doorbells and running away. As part of the prank at the Neidig home, Mr. McGuire said, he also stacked bricks on the front porch. As he tried to run away, he tripped over the bricks, knocking them down.
During the August trial, Mr. McGuire said Sgt. Neidig punched him in the face approximately 10 times. The injuries to his nose required two surgeries.
Pulling a prank, Mr. McGuire’s attorney argues, should not warrant being beaten and sustaining a broken nose.
As part of their argument, Mr. McGuire’s attorneys contend that the city of Pittsburgh requires its officers to be able to respond to a criminal matter 24 hours a day — whether on-duty or off.
But Julie Koren, who represents the city, argued during Tuesday’s hearing that the 24-hour, on-call concept is for serious crime.
“You’re talking about vandalism — ringing doorbells, smashing pumpkins,” she said. “An off-duty police officer did not have to run out the door and chase him for half a mile.”
After the incident that night, Sgt. Neidig testified in the Common Pleas trial, he was never disciplined for his actions and never had to undergo additional training because of them. He never authored any police reports for his role in the incident, either.
He was promoted to sergeant in 2017.
During the argument on Tuesday, Judge Della Vecchia, who said he would reach a decision in the next couple of weeks, repeatedly noted that Sgt. Neidig never identified himself to Mr. McGuire as an officer and never showed him his badge. In fact, the judge continued, Mr. McGuire, at some point during the incident, asked Sgt. Neidig if he was an officer, and the man refused to answer.
“Even the city has certain rights, and they have the right to defend themselves,” the judge said. “It was clear to the jury this wasn’t their obligation.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.