A 20-year-old Munhall man said an off-duty Pittsburgh police officer attacked him after he and his friends smashed pumpkins outside the officer’s house five years ago, repeatedly punching him in the face and breaking his nose.

“He said, ‘I work in Wilkinsburg. I deal with worse [expletive] than you,” Shane McGuire told a jury on the first day of trial in his federal civil rights suit against Officer Colby Neidig.

Mr. McGuire filed suit in 2014 against Officer Neidig.

He was 16 on Nov. 10, 2012, when he said he and some friends were walking along Cassabill Drive in New Homestead and smashing leftover Halloween pumpkins in the neighborhood for fun. Among them were pumpkins in front of Officer Neidig’s home.

Advertise with us

Mr. McGuire said he and his four friends also piled up some bricks from a nearby construction site on Officer Neidig’s porch, apparently as some kind of prank, and then on a dare from the others he ran up and rang the doorbell.

He said he had no idea the homeowner was a police officer.

After he rang the doorbell a few times, he ran and Officer Neidig chased him down, tackled him, punched him repeatedly in the face and broke his nose, he said.

Mr. McGuire’s lawyer, Mark Eck, said in his opening statement that the case is about “stupid teenagers doing stupid teenage things” in smashing the pumpkins and causing mischief but that his client did not fight the officer and did not deserve to be beaten so badly he ended up in the hospital.

But Officer Neidig and his lawyer, Paul Krepps, told a different story.

Advertise with us

Mr. Krepps said the officer, his wife and their 1-year-old had just returned from shopping that evening when Mr. McGuire ran up to their house and began pounding violently on the door as if trying to break in, and then ran away.

Officer Neidig bolted after him across the street and into nearby woods until he caught up with Mr. McGuire, who squared up to fight, Mr. Krepps said.

Officer Neidig and Mr. McGuire grappled and Mr. McGuire tried to punch and kick him, so Officer Neidig punched him once to subdue him, the lawyer said.

He then picked him up and walked him to a nearby house to call 911 for the police to respond. An ambulance took Mr. McGuire to a hospital.

Mr. Krepps said Mr. McGuire caused his own problems by vandalizing property, banging on the door, running, refusing to stop and then trying to fight with the officer.

Advertise with us

“He instigated this, he initiated all of this,” he told the jury. “And now he appears before you and wants money.”

Testimony will resume Thursday before U.S. District Judge Mark Kearney.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.