A former Pittsburgh police commander accused of surreptitiously recording his colleagues now faces a federal lawsuit from the officers investigators say he spied on.

Matthew Lackner, 50, retired from the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police in mid-October, shortly after he was caught using body-worn cameras to record private conversations among other officers. Criminal charges were filed last month, and he faces four counts of violating the state’s wiretap laws.

The seven officers he’s accused of recording allege that Mr. Lackner violated federal wiretap laws as well as their civil rights when he planted loose cameras in their patrol vehicles.

The lawsuit also names the city as a defendant, alleging Mr. Lackner was acting as an employee of the city when he made the recordings. Beyond that, the lawsuit claimed, the city should have been aware that Mr. Lackner was using the cameras to record his colleagues without their consent but lacked the proper policies and oversight.

Advertise with us

The criminal investigation, led by Allegheny County Police, began a few days after officers discovered the hidden cameras in several unmarked police vehicles at the bureau’s Zone 2 station in the Hill District.

In total, county police Detective Jason Binder wrote in the complaint, Mr. Lackner recorded 75 hours of illegal video and audio across 11 separate recordings. In some cases, Mr. Lackner’s face was actually recorded on the cameras as he was hiding them in vehicles. In at least one instance, his own body-worn camera recorded him hiding the cameras.

The recordings spanned from Sept. 27 to Oct. 4, according to the complaint. In one from Sept. 27, Mr. Lackner is caught in his own recording putting a piece of paper of his body cam, concealing it under his shirt, and then recording a 20-minute conversation with a lieutenant.

In several instances, cameras outside of the Zone 2 police station showed Mr. Lackner going in and out of the cars at the Hill District station, according to the complaint.

His fiddling around near the unmarked cars is what ultimately drew the suspicion of fellow officers. Two detectives ultimately took their vehicle to a car wash midday Oct. 4 to look for a GPS tracker or recording device. They found one, according to the complaint, and it subsequently captured the long silence as the pair drove back to the station.

Advertise with us

When he was ultimately confronted by detectives who had been recorded, Mr. Lackner allegedly told them — as well as the lieutenant the detectives had sought out for advice — that a “particular plainclothes detective” was under federal investigation, according to the complaint.

One officer told investigators Mr. Lackner told him there was an investigation going on “way above” even Mr. Lackner’s head, and the commander ordered him not to discuss it.

Later that day, Oct. 5, Mr. Lackner was placed on administrative leave. He retired roughly two weeks later.

Pennsylvania is what’s commonly called a two-party consent state: In most circumstances, it is illegal to record or intercept a phone call or conversation unless everyone involved consents to the recording. Law enforcement officers need special certification to record conversations, and authorities must have special authorization and the direct involvement of a judge in order to record conversations in which none of the parties involved knows they’re being recorded.

Pennsylvania’s strict wiretap laws are why it took until the mid-2010s for Pittsburgh police to be equipped with body-worn cameras, and even then it took a special amendment by the state Senate.