Caught secretly recording colleagues on hidden cameras, a former Pittsburgh police commander allegedly tried to play off his deceptive surveillance, telling the officers he’d recorded that it was all part of a larger federal investigation that came from “way above” and ordering them not to speak of it again.
In reality, according to Allegheny County Police detectives, there was no federal investigation, and now-retired Cmdr. Matthew Lackner was attempting to explain away his recording to subordinates as they went about their daily duties.
Mr. Lackner, 50, retired from the bureau in mid-October, about a week after the alleged surveillance scheme fell apart. He was charged Thursday with four counts of felony wiretapping for recordings made from Sept. 27 to Oct. 4.
County police Detective Jason Binder began investigating allegations against Mr. Lackner on Oct. 11, a few days after the cameras were discovered hidden in several unmarked police vehicles. Mr. Lackner, at the time, was the commander of the city’s Zone 2 station, which covers Downtown, the Hill District, Lawrenceville and surrounding neighborhoods.
In total, Detective Binder wrote in the criminal complaint, Mr. Lackner recorded 75 hours of illegal video and audio across 11 separate recordings. In some cases, hidden body-worn cameras that were not then in use by a detective were used by Mr. Lackner and captured him placing them in a vehicle. In at least one instance, his own body-worn camera recorded the placement.
Pennsylvania is what’s commonly called a two-party consent state: In most circumstances, it is illegal to record or intercept a phone call or conversation unless everyone involved consents to the recording. Law enforcement officers need special certification to record conversations, and authorities must have special authorization and the direct involvement of a judge in order to record conversations in which none of the parties involved knows they’re being recorded.
Read More
Pennsylvania’s strict wiretap laws are why it took until the mid-2010s for Pittsburgh police to be equipped with body-worn cameras, and even then it took a special amendment by the state Senate.
In one recording captured Sept. 27, Mr. Lackner is allegedly caught in his own footage placing a piece of paper over his body cam and then concealing it under his shirt, according to the complaint. He recorded a roughly 20-minute conversation in his office with a Zone 2 lieutenant.
Two days later, he allegedly hid another officer’s body cam in one of the unmarked police vehicles, during which time it briefly captured his face, according to the complaint. That recording was around four hours long and captured the conversations of two detectives using the car to go about their duties.
A similar scene played out four days later with a different unmarked vehicle. According to the complaint, Mr. Lackner’s face isn’t caught by the hidden camera as he’s placing it, but corresponding security footage outside the Hill District station showed him going into that car at the same time.
That recording went on for more than eight hours, Detective Binder wrote in the complaint.
Several Zone 2 officers and detectives became suspicious after they saw their commander fiddling near the unmarked cars. According to the complaint, two detectives ultimately took their vehicle to a car wash midday Oct. 4 to look for a GPS tracker or recording device.
After about 20 minutes of recording, one of the detectives uncovered the camera. The recording captured silence as the pair drove back to the Zone 2 station, Detective Binder wrote.
When he was ultimately confronted by detectives who had been recorded, Mr. Lackner allegedly told them — as well as the lieutenant the detectives had sought out for advice — that a “particular plainclothes detective” was under federal investigation, according to the complaint.
One officer told investigators Mr. Lackner told him there was an investigation going on “way above” even Mr. Lackner’s head, and the commander ordered him not to discuss it.
Later that day, Oct. 5, Mr. Lackner was placed on administrative leave. He retired roughly two weeks later.
Detective Binder, the Allegheny County officer investigating the alleged wiretapping, said no one within the county District Attorney’s Office, the state Attorney General’s Office or the U.S. Attorney’s Office had authorized any type of investigation involving intercepts of any Zone 2 officer.
The complaint does not say whether investigators have any alternative reason for Mr. Lackner’s actions.
Mr. Lackner could not be reached for comment Saturday.
He was not taken into custody, and a preliminary hearing is scheduled for April 10.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.