Christopher Shepherd was sitting on the ground with a knife in his hand outside Upper St. Clair home in January when four South Hills officers fired 21 shots at him early this year, actions that District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. ruled were justified — even as he acknowledged that “things probably could have or should be been done differently.”

“But that doesn’t make it a criminal matter,” Mr. Zappala said at a press conference on Friday detailing his investigation into the Jan. 7 shooting on Lamar Road. “I don’t see a crime being committed by police.”

The shooting was the deadly culmination of a worsening mental health crisis that the 48-year-old Shepherd was experiencing.

Upper St. Clair police were familiar with Shepherd because they’d helped his family have him involuntarily committed for psychiatric treatment in the past. He’d never before been violent, and his family has said he often went years without an episode.

Advertise with us

His mother, Susan, didn’t feel safe in their home that January day, and she sought police help to once again seek what she hoped would be long-term treatment for her son.

“I called for help in this situation as a mother, but it didn’t end up being helpful. It ended up being the death of my son,” Ms. Shepherd told Mr. Zappala on Friday.

Ms. Shepherd and other family members, including Christopher’s half-sister, Michelle Kippelen, attended the DA’s press conference on Friday. They weren’t told about it by officials, Ms. Kippelen said — she found out from a member of the media a few hours beforehand.

“It’s difficult to make sense out of anybody saying it was justified that they killed my son,” Ms. Shepherd said, as Mr. Zappala told her that justification is a relative term.

“I’m trying not to lay blame anywhere, you know, but maybe it could have been handled in a different way,” she said. “Destroying my house, destroying my heart, and destroying my son.”

Advertise with us

From mental health matter to police matter

When Upper St. Clair officers tried to make contact with Shepherd after his mother had filled out the involuntary commitment paperwork — a process often referred to as a “302” — he jabbed a kitchen knife through a piece of plywood that was covering a window of their home.

“The significance is that it’s no longer a mental health matter. It is now a police matter,” Mr. Zappala said.

Family members said Shepherd’s delusions made him paranoid, and he believed the police were there to hurt him.

Upper St. Clair officers retreated and filed an assault charge against Shepherd, though Mr. Zappala was clear: “He’s a defendant at this point, but Christopher is not a criminal.”

Police backup came in the form of the SHACOG CIRT unit — the critical incident response team made up of officers from communities within the South Hills Area Council of Governments.

Advertise with us

For four hours, authorities, negotiators and at least one crisis counselor from Re:Solve crisis services tried to hail Shepherd out of the home.

Phone calls and text messages to him went unanswered. Flash bangs meant to drive Shepherd to the back of the home so officers could breach the front failed. Pepper gas finally drew him out through the garage. He had a lamp in one hand and the kitchen knife in the other.

When he ran out of the house, he was running toward the unarmed crisis counselors and medics stationed behind a large SWAT vehicle known generally referred to as the bear or bearcat.

A Bethel Park police officer released a police K-9, which took Shepherd to the ground. The officer was quickly given the order to call off the dog — something that has to be done physically rather than via a command.

As Bethel Park officer did so, those involved told Mr. Zappala, Shepherd slashed out with the knife. Within five seconds, four officers fired 21 shots, 18 of which hit Shepherd.

Advertise with us

“If it works perfectly, the K-9 would lock on his arm — wherever the weapon is, that side of his body. That was apparently not the case,” Mr. Zappala said, noting that he didn’t know why the K-9 officer was ordered to remove the dog so quickly.

He said there is footage of the moment Shepherd was shot.

No Upper St. Clair officers were part of the CIRT team, Mr. Zappala said, and they were giving advice to those trying to get Shepherd out of the home. Those who did open fire were from Brentwood, Baldwin and Bethel Park. A lawsuit filed by Ms. Shepherd is pending against those officers.

“I don’t think it was their intention [to use lethal force],” he said of the officers. “When [Shepherd] leaves the house, he’s forcing the issue.”

He continued: “Was lethal force necessary? I think, at that point, he is now a danger and is proximate enough to a human being that I’m not going to second guess.”

Advertise with us

‘He was a good man’

Ms. Kippelen said she feels her brother was failed not only by the judicial system, but by the mental health care system, too. She said her brother had been deteriorating in recent weeks, and several times they’d had him involuntarily committed. Each time he was released within a few days even though it was clear, she said, that he needed longer term treatment.

When she heard on Jan. 7 that her brother was wielding a knife, she was actually relieved, she said.

“In my head, I thought, ‘thank God, this is the time … they finally have enough [justification] to keep him in the hospital because he has a knife,’” she said.

The family recently received the names of the officers who fired at Shepherd through their lawsuit’s discovery process. Reading them, she said, she cried.

“I didn’t know whether to be mad at them or sorry for them, because they also went through the process of shooting and killing a human being,” she said. “And that can’t be easy.”

Advertise with us

Still, Ms. Kippelen said, hearing that Mr. Zappala ruled the officers’ actions justified broke her heart.

“I don’t think that my brother — who was the kindest, most gentle man I’ve ever met in my life, who was in the throes of a mental health crisis — was justified in being murdered that day,” she said.

Officers, she said, should have used the myriad less-lethal options at their disposal. Mr. Zappala said they did try that during the four hours preceding the shooting. The intent was to breach the home and secure him or draw him out and do the same.

“I know it has nothing to do with you or your job,” Ms. Kippelen said to Mr. Zappala, “but I want you to know that he was a good man. He would … take the clothes off his back and give them to a homeless man. He was just one of the best men I’ve ever met in my life.

“I’m sorry,” she told the district attorney, “that he was born sick.”