SWAT officers who killed a man suffering a mental health crisis in Upper St. Clair earlier this year shot him eight times in the back as he ran away, a federal lawsuit alleges.
Family members say 48-year-old Christopher Shepherd knew he suffered from mental health issues, and he worked hard to avoid the triggers that would send him into a paranoid and delusional episode.
“At the time he was shot and killed, Mr. Shepherd did not pose a threat of serious harm to the … officers or anyone else,” the lawsuit alleged. “Mr. Shepherd was holding a kitchen knife and was running away from the officers when they shot him.”
The lawsuit continues: “The officers were standing a considerable distance from Mr. Shepherd and were not in harm’s way.”
The lawsuit names the boroughs of Bethel Park, Brentwood and Baldwin, as well as the South Hills Area Council of Governments, 20 unnamed police officers and a named detective.
Ashley Wagner, solicitor for Baldwin, declined to comment, as did Gavin Robb, solicitor for Brentwood. Attorneys for the other defendants did not immediately return requests for comment.
Read More
On Jan. 7, the day he was killed, Shepherd was in the midst of one of those episodes, and his mother sought to have him involuntarily committed for treatment. When Upper St. Clair police officers first tried to take him into custody, he allegedly jabbed through a boarded up window with a kitchen knife.
The knife, according to the lawsuit, was a symptom of Shepherd’s delusions.
“He thought the officers were there to harm him and he used the knife defensively to ward off a perceived threat rather than to assault the officers,” attorneys for the family wrote in the lawsuit.
The Upper St. Clair officers retreated and requested assistance from the SHACOG CIRT unit — the critical incident response team made up of officers from departments in the South Hills Area Council of Governments.
What ensued, the lawsuit claims, was a one-sided standoff.
The lawsuit, which alleges wrongful death, battery and other claims, specifically names Giles Wright, a detective with the Bethel Park police and commander of the critical incident team.
After a CIRT negotiator failed to gain ground with Shepherd — who, according to the lawsuit, “could not understand … because of his delusional thoughts” — Detective Wright “decided to escalate the encounter.”
That alleged escalation came in the form of tear gas shot into the home where Shepherd was holed up, “even though Mr. Shepherd’s continued presence in his own home was not posing an immediate threat of harm to the officers or the public.”
Shepherd eventually emerged through a garage door, allegedly still armed with a kitchen knife. When CIRT officers shouted commands at Shepherd from their position at the end of the driveway, according to the lawsuit, Shepherd tried to run away. It’s unclear how many officers opened fire, but officials have said that four fired shots that struck Shepherd.
The lawsuit noted that officers at the scene were armed with pepper spray, batons, tasers, beanbag rounds and other less-lethal options. To open fire on Shepherd, attorneys wrote, was a response more reasonable for an active shooter.
The lawsuit alleged that officers’ failure to use less-lethal force against Shepherd — and Detective Wright’s failure to instruct them to — violated Shepherd’s civil rights.
“Detective Wright’s only ‘plan’ was for the CIRT team to force Mr. Shepherd from his home, shout commands they knew he wouldn’t understand, and then shoot him,” according to the lawsuit.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.