The Bethel Park man who tried to kill former President Donald Trump had previously searched for information on convicted Michigan school-shooter Ethan Crumbley and his parents — the latest piece of information that has trickled out as tight-lipped federal investigators continue the search for the motivation behind Thomas Matthew Crooks’ attempt on Trump’s life.

Authorities told legislators on Wednesday they’d found an image of Crumbley’s arrest photo on Crooks’ primary phone, as well as information about the teen and his parents, according to CNN.

Crumbley killed four students in the 2021 shooting at Oxford High School in Michigan, and his parents were convicted of involuntary manslaughter for failing to secure the gun used in the shooting and for dismissing concerns about their son’s mental health.

It’s not clear when those photos and details were accessed, but James R. Fitzgerald, a retired FBI supervisory special agent and profiler, said it’s indicative of a common theme among shooters.

Advertise with us

“These shooters tend to study other mass shooters or assassins online,” Mr. Fitzgerald said, noting that such research is chief among clues investigators would be looking for in the aftermath of Saturday shooting.

He likened Crooks’ lack of digital footprint to Stephen Paddock, who killed 60 people when he opened fire at a music festival on the Las Vegas Strip in 2017, but he compared Crooks’ attempts to use both explosives and a firearm to an overseas mass killer.

“I wouldn’t be surprised if someone in his internet searches — in his obsessiveness with killing a presidential candidate, with committing this massive worldwide recognized act of violence — he somehow related to … Anders Breivik,” he said.

Breivik in 2011 killed eight people in Norway with a car bomb and then shot and killed 69 people at a youth camp on a nearby island.

Crooks was armed with an AR-style rifle that his father bought more than a decade ago, investigators have said. He also had improvised explosive materials in the truck of his Hyundai Sonata, and authorities found similar materials in the home he shared with his parents.

Advertise with us

Criminal snipers on their own are rare, Mr. Fitzgerald said. So are criminal bombers.

“It’s the rarest of the rare to have a sniper and a bomber in the same person,” he said. “It requires different skillsets, trade crafts, different technical knowledge to be both.”

A lack of clear motive, too, makes the Crooks case an unusual one, said Seamus Hughes, a researcher at the National Counterterrorism Innovation, Technology and Education Center at the University of Nebraska Omaha.

“If a target is a politician or elected officials, there is usually a clear-cut ideological bent to it,” he said, noting that, so far, the only real clue as to motivation is the target itself — in this case, Trump, who received his party’s nomination as the GOP presidential candidate five days after the shooting.

“Barring [a clear motive], the vacuum gets filled with conspiracy theories and everything in between,” Mr. Hughes said.

Advertise with us

He, too, compared Crooks to Paddock, Las Vegas shooter. Paddock died from a self-inflected gunshot wound, and investigators never did determine a concrete motive for the shooting.

“Investigators turned over every stone and still weren’t really able to [determine a motive],” he said.

It could come down to what he calls “the Joker effect.”

“There is a subset of people that just want to watch the world burn,” Mr. Hughes said.

Indeed, Mr. Fitzgerald said, shooters who target elected officials generally fall into one of two categories: grievance or performative.

Advertise with us

The grievance, perceived or real, can be of any nature, he said: Political, spiritual, ideological, philosophical, personal — anything, really.

Performative political assassinations “really came around in the early 1980s,” Mr. Fitzgerald said, alluding to John Hinckley Jr.’s 1981 assassination attempt on then-President Ronald Reagan. He called it wanting fame without work.

Mr. Fitzgerald described Crooks as someone who might have been bullied — classmates differ on whether he was subjected to bullying in high school — and hadn’t “made very much of a mark in life at age 20.

“What better way to get fame without work … than to try to kill a presidential candidate?” he asked.

Mr. Hughes said it’s likely that there were hints of trouble to Crooks’ associates, but not necessarily enough to put the pieces together.

Advertise with us

“In a majority of [mass shooter-type] cases, family members or friends saw something concerning but couldn’t wrap their head around what it was,” he said. “They knew a train wreck was happening but couldn’t stop the train.”

It was the same metaphor Oakland County, Mich., Judge Cheryl Matthews used when she sentenced Ethan Crumbley’s parents to at least 10 years in prison.

“These convictions are not about poor parenting,” Judge Matthews said during the April 9 sentencing hearing. “These convictions confirm repeated acts, or lack of acts, that could have halted an oncoming runaway train.”

It remains unclear if mental health concerns might have played a role in the attempted assassination. In the briefing with legislators, authorities said the 20-year-old searched for information on major depressive disorder and depressive crisis treatment, according to CNN.

Experts told CBS News it is too early and too little is known to assess whether Crooks’ parents could be held criminal liable.

Advertise with us

"The facts would need to approach or exceed the egregious level of the Crumbley case: multiple serious warning signs over a longer period of time, improper storage, close involvement with the shooter's use of guns, etc.," Andrew Willinger, executive director of the Duke Center for Firearms Law, said.

The successful prosecution of the Crumbley parents earlier this year was built upon three key tenets: they ignored or outright dismissed myriad signs their son was troubled; they bought the firearm specifically for their son, who was too young to legally own one; and they failed to secure the gun even after school officials voiced concerns for the teen’s mental health.

The AR-style rifle Crooks used belonged to his father, who bought the gun legally in 2013, sources told CBS.

Investigators told the TV network that Crooks’ father, Matthew B. Crooks, called police before the shooting, concerned about his son’s whereabouts.

Adam Garber, executive director of CeaseFire PA, a gun violence prevention organization in Pennsylvania, said the details of that call to local police, or what the parents knew and when, could yield more answers as to whether charges may be brought.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania has no safe storage laws, meaning gun owners are not obligated to secure firearms in a home with minors. Beyond that, Crooks was old enough to use and purchase a rifle, which Pennsylvanians can do at 18. They must be 21, though, to purchase a handgun.

"The DA will need to ask two key questions. First, what did the parents know about their son's intentions and when did they know it?" Garber told CBS. "Second, how did their son get the firearm — and did they know where he was taking it? Those questions of the intent and access are key to assessing their culpability."