For at least an hour before Thomas Matthew Crooks crawled to the peak of an unguarded metal roof and aimed his rifle at Donald Trump, he slipped in and out of view of law enforcement officers who had noticed something suspicious about the skinny, long-haired 20-year-old.

One alerted his colleagues, but lost track of him. Another, this one a sniper, took his photo.

In that crucial period before the worst Secret Service security failure in a generation, however, no one noticed the true danger Crooks posed until moments before he opened fire from an elevated position with a clear line of sight to the Republican nominee.

During the days since, the extent of the breakdowns that led to the death of a rally-goer, the wounding of two others and a bloody injury to the former president have begun to emerge. They began in the run-up to the event itself, when Secret Service agents and local law enforcement officers were formulating a flawed plan to protect the former president and his supporters with limited resources.

Advertise with us

Security preparations had begun days earlier, on July 8, when Secret Service agents and local police walked the site to assess the dangers and figure out how to neutralize them, The New York Times reported.

One clear threat would’ve become clear immediately: a building with a low, sloped roof just 150 or so yards north of where the podium would stand.

“No supervisor I ever worked with would not have noticed that,” said Jason Russell, a former Secret Service agent who protected presidents and candidates through two election cycles in 2004 and 2008.

The planners decided to put those buildings outside the innermost perimeters, where security is tightest. Instead, it was relegated to the less-secure outer ring, which at presidential campaign events is patrolled by local law enforcement rather than Secret Service agents.

But there was a problem. Local authorities didn’t have the resources to secure the entire facility, and they said so to the federal agents in charge of the operation, Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger told The Washington Post.

Advertise with us

Security experts say they didn’t need to. Two officers stationed on the roof would prevent anyone from getting up there unnoticed.

In a decision that has baffled everyone from former agents to casual observers, they didn’t. Days after the shooting, Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle told ABC News it was because the roof’s slant presented a danger — even though her department’s counter-snipers were positioned on more steeply slanted roofs on the Butler Farm Show grounds less than 200 yards away.

“It’s hard to imagine such a failure. It’s also hard to imagine why the head of the Secret Service still has her position,” David McCormick, the Republican U.S. Senate candidate who hunkered down with other lawmakers and guests after gunfire rang out at the Butler rally, posted on X.

There were officers nearby, though. Members of Beaver County’s SWAT team had been positioned in an adjoining building, Mr. Goldinger said.

The location is a “perfect place” to stage a tactical team that could quickly respond to anything near the security bubble, Mr. Russell said. But it makes little sense if the goal was to secure the nearby roof.

Advertise with us

“I've never heard of anyone — whether it was an agent or a police officer — saying, ‘Hey, watch this, but just watch it through the window,’ ” Mr. Russell said. “That's very strange to me.”

As the rally began early Saturday afternoon, with local officials and Republican candidates giving speeches to warm up the crowd, the roof remained empty. Among the people who’d gathered outside the secure perimeter was Crooks.

Something about his behavior caught the attention of a local officer, who alerted others about an hour before Trump took the stage. A video obtained by WTAE shows him meandering on the grassy area between the stands and the industrial complex. Twenty minutes or so before he fired the first shots, a sniper from a local agency took a photo of him.

Among the things that aroused suspicion was his use of a rangefinder, a scope used to measure distance.

The revelation, in a briefing to U.S. senators, prompted one to call for Ms. Cheatle to lose her job.

Advertise with us

“He was identified as being suspicious one hour before the shooting. He had a rangefinder and a backpack. The Secret Service lost sight of him,” Sen. John Barasso, R-Wy., posted on X.

But that, on its own, isn’t enough to deem him a definite threat, Mr. Russell said.

“Having a rangefinder doesn't equate to: I'm going to try to carry out a shooting,” Mr. Russell said. “He’s really not a threat until he’s on that roof.”

At 6:05, an hour later than scheduled, Trump took the stage. Within minutes, Crooks, now armed with a rifle, made his way to the back end of the industrial building nearest the stage.

He clambered onto the roof on the east side of the building — a part of the structure with trees between it and at least one of the two Secret Service sniper teams stationed on rooftops behind the stage. He stayed low, hugging the slope of the roof that faced away from the snipers, video posted by rally-goers shows.

Advertise with us

They began yelling for police, pointing to Crooks as he slowly made his way up the roof while Trump continued speaking in the distance.

Nearby, two Butler Township officers — part of a seven-officer contingent assigned to traffic duty — peeled off their assignments and went to investigate, according to a statement from township Commissioner Edward R. Natali.

One helped boost the other up so he could grab the edge of the roof and pull himself up.

He was met with the barrel of Crooks’ rifle pointing at him, Mr. Natali said. The officer dropped from the roof to avoid being shot, injuring himself in the process.

Things began moving quickly.

Advertise with us

The officers would’ve radioed in what they had seen, alerting Secret Service and others to the gunman, Mr. Russell said. Videos of the event show the agency’s snipers suddenly turn to focus on the rooftop.

Trees near the building Crooks was on might have prevented the closest team from spotting him, and the roof’s slope might still have partially hidden him from the farther team.

When the snipers did spot him, his clothing might have caused them to pause. He wore khaki pants and a muted gray shirt with an emblem of an American flag on the shoulder. The shirt had a blocky image of an eagle on it in a color scheme similar to some military-inspired clothing.

Secret Service agents familiarize themselves with the uniforms and tactical gear of local departments before every event to prevent accidentally firing on them, but mistakes happen, Mr. Russell said.

“It would give a counter-sniper pause. You don’t want to get that wrong and take out a SWAT guy that wore the wrong shirt that day,” he said.

Advertise with us

In the frantic seconds while this was happening, Crooks moved to the peak of the roof, took aim and began shooting, Mr. Goldinger said. Soon after, a Secret Service sniper fired back, killing him, according to the agency.

As multiple federal investigations of the attempted assassination and security failures unfold, officials are broadening their scope beyond the Secret Service. On Thursday, Sen. Chuck Grassley, former chairman of the Judiciary Committee, sent letters to Beaver and Butler counties and Pennsylvania State police, asking for video and audio recordings from that day, and documents showing what their officers were responsible for during the event.

Regardless of what those records show, however, one agency was in charge.

“It's the Secret Service’s site and event,” Mr. Russell said. “They're responsible for anything that happens.”

Staff writer Ben Kail contributed to this report.

Advertise with us

Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; @wrschgn

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com