A judge on Wednesday denied a motion by attorneys for Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers seeking to exhume the defendant’s father for paternity testing.
Defense attorneys for Bowers filed the request with U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville early Tuesday. It followed several days of repeated implications by prosecutors that any mental illness on the side of Bowers’ father could be moot because of paternity doubts.

Attorneys for Bowers acknowledged the untimeliness of the motion, attributing it to the sudden injection of the paternity issue by prosecutors.
“It is clear that the defense itself injected the issue of paternity in this case,” Judge Colville wrote in denying the motion to exhume Randall Bowers.
He said defense attorneys were clearly aware that it could be an issue for some time.
“The defense surely had access to, or at least the ability to learn, this information at a much earlier juncture so as to avoid confronting this court with a motion seeking the extraordinary relief it now seeks 31 days into the trial in this matter,” Judge Colville admonished.
Read More
Bowers, 50, of Baldwin was convicted last month of all federal charges against him in connection with the Oct. 27, 2018, shootings at a Squirrel Hill synagogue. Three congregations worshipped there: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Eleven people were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.
Jurors now are hearing evidence that they will weigh in deciding Bowers’ sentence: life in prison or the death penalty.
The questions surrounding paternity stemmed from testimony by clinical psychologist Katherine Porterfield, who was hired by the defense to reconstruct Bowers’ childhood. Notes from her interview with Bowers’ mother indicated she’d expressed some doubt as to whether Randall Bowers was her son’s father.
Bowers’ defense team said paternity is central to their mitigation efforts, as it bolsters their assertion that their client is mentally ill. Bowers’ father, Randall Bowers, was diagnosed with schizophrenia during his time in the Navy. He killed himself in 1979 when Bowers was 7, though Randall Bowers was estranged from the family by that point.
Notes from an interview with the mother’s former neighbor indicated that he, too, expressed doubt as to Randall Bowers’ paternity, though he based that on the volume of visitors she had, Ms. Porterfield testified.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt, in her cross examination of Ms. Porterfield, called attention to the fact that the psychologist left those notes out of her presentation to the jury.
“Whether or not Randall Bowers was the defendant’s father, the fact remains that Dr. Porterfield omitted key facts in her recitation and analysis of the defendant’s family history,” prosecutors wrote in their objection to the exhumation.
Judge Colville seemed to agree.
“Moreover, the cross-examination was independently relevant to [Ms. Porterfield’s] credibility,” he wrote, noting that the defense team had access to Bowers’ mother, who is one source of the paternal doubt.
“The court concludes that the defense simply made a strategic decision in not pursuing the extraordinary relief at issue at an earlier juncture,” he said.
Prosecutors began pulling at the paternity thread Thursday in the cross-examination of Ms. Porterfield, the defense’s first expert witness for the sentence-selection phase of the trial.
The attorney returned to it again Monday, asking about Ms. Porterfield’s testimony that she had no indications paternity was in question.
“So I guess you meant, other than the fact that the mother herself said it was a question?” Ms. Vasquez Schmitt asked.
Ms. Porterfield explained: “What I was responding was that there was a lot of data about Mr. Bowers’ childhood, about Randall Bowers being his father. There was official documentation. There was an entire family … who acknowledged Robert Bowers is their grandson.”
Defense attorneys accused the government of asking questions concerning paternity “purely to continue to instill doubt in jurors’ minds.”
Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.