In one instance after the next, the adults in Robert Bowers’ life — namely his mother — failed to get him the help that he needed.
When he was just months old, both parents threatened to kill him. They were divorced before Bowers was a year old.
When his language regressed to unintelligible high-pitch squeals as a toddler, doctors told his mother it wasn’t a hearing problem and to follow up. That didn’t happen.
When he was in first grade, a teacher referred him to the school psychologist. After his mother found out, she demanded any type of treatment stop, and she pulled her son out of the school the next year.
When he was 7, his father killed himself on the eve of a trial on rape charges. His mother told him the news with little care or concern, expecting it would not affect the boy.
A fourth-grade teacher raised concerns about Bowers’ emotional well-being in a note on his report card. There is no record of any follow up.
Read More
When he was 10, he became preoccupied with suicide. He stood on top of a bluff near his home and thought about jumping off. He told his mother. Nothing was done.
From fourth grade through seventh grade, he missed more and more school: 15 days, then 24 days, then 25 days and 31 days in seventh grade.
“There’s a real pattern of his mother having a really difficult time hearing that she needs to do something,” Dr. Katherine Porterfield, a clinical psychologist and expert in trauma, testified for the defense on Thursday in the fifth-floor courtroom of the federal courthouse in Downtown Pittsburgh.
Thursday marked the first full day of testimony from defense experts in the sentence-selection phase of the trial of Bowers, a Baldwin resident who was convicted in June of all 63 federal charges against him in connection with the Oct. 27, 2018, shooting at a Squirrel Hill synagogue that killed 11 people. Those killed were Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.
Jurors decided last week that Bowers, 50, is eligible for the death penalty. Now they are hearing evidence that they will need to weigh in ultimately deciding if he is sentenced to life in prison or the death penalty.
As the beginning of this last phase of the trial, survivors of the attack on the three congregations — Tree of Life, Dor Hadash, New Light — gave tearful testimony for more than two days as to the physical and emotional scars left by the attack and the unfillable voids left by their slain loved ones.
For at least the next week, defense attorneys are expected to recreate Bowers’ childhood and life circumstances in a bid to mitigate any aggravating circumstances presented by prosecutors. The defense team has indicated there are more than 100 mitigating factors that they intend to prove to jurors.
Ms. Porterfield, a staff psychologist at the Program for Survivors of Torture at New York’s Bellevue Hospital, testified Thursday as to the effect of trauma on a child, particularly when it is chronic and severe.
She said multiple severe, chronic traumatic life events and circumstances increase the risk of a child experiencing mental illness and emotional problems.
There are two prongs to that, she said: A genetic predisposition to mental health issues and trauma, as well as the experiences and environment of the child. In Bowers’ case, she pointed to numerous relatives on his mother’s side of the family who suffered mental illness or other traumatic circumstances.
Traumatic experiences and a traumatic environment interrupt the normal development of a child, Ms. Porterfield said, even if that trauma doesn’t necessarily include physical abuse. It can hinder a child’s sense of self, sense of other people, and their ability to regulate their body and their emotions.
In all, Ms. Porterfield reviewed some 21,000 documents and records, and interviewed several people who knew Bowers extensively, including his mother.
She said his mother admitted being depressed and overwhelmed in her attempts to parent her son, telling him multiple times she wished he’d never been born and sometimes cutting herself in front of him. She told Ms. Porterfield she was a terrible mother.
At 13, Bowers was committed to a psychiatric ward at McKeesport Hospital. Records indicate he’d chased his mother with a flammable liquid and threatened to kill himself as well. He was withdrawn and fearful, doctors wrote.
“He’s a completely out-of-control child,” Ms. Porterfield said.
After 2 ½ weeks at the hospital, he was sent to Southwood Psychiatric for more than a month. When doctors at McKeesport had told him he would be sent to an inpatient facility, he began hitting windows and walls, threatening staff and hitting his head on the bed and wall.
He was sedated and put in restraints for 24 hours, most of which was spent in the type that restrain both arms and legs. Notes on hospital records indicated Bowers cried, asked to be removed, and asked for the doctor.
From Southwood, he was moved to the Bradley Center, another inpatient facility. He began to improve there, Ms. Porterfield said, until he was sent home to the same environment and with no follow-up services.
All told, he was institutionalized for eight months.
He made several more suicide attempts at ages 16 and 17, resulting in more hospitalizations.
“This was a childhood of trauma, neglect and adversity from the beginning,” Ms. Porterfield said, calling the events and circumstances of his youth an “extraordinary amount of adversity and caregiver neglect.”
In a long and wide-ranging cross examination, Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt first took aim at Ms. Porterfield’s credibility and then tried to cast doubt upon the severity and impact of Bowers’ childhood traumas.
She pointed to the fact that Bowers was too young to remember his father’s time in his life, including any threats he made toward Bowers or his mother or any violence perpetrated on his mother by his father, Randall Bowers.
She also questioned the veracity of some of Bowers’ suicide attempts and threats. She noted that one document from when he applied for disability benefits in the 2000s indicated Bowers reported only one suicide attempt in his life, when he was 17.
Ms. Vasquez Schmitt also took aim at Bowers’ mother’s reliability as a narrator and historian.
For example, Ms. Porterfield testified that Bowers’ mother indicated in their interview that she’d had sex with men in front of her son in their one-room apartment. According to his mother’s timeline, Bowers was a toddler in one instance. In another, he was around 8 years old.
Ms. Vasquez Schmitt pointed to Ms. Porterfield’s notes in which she had written that his mother reported instances of “PDA that got out of control.”
The psychologist said the implication was that the public displays of affection meant sexual intercourse.
Ms. Vasquez Schmitt asked if that was implied but not actually said.
“I believed that from this long conversation in which she became ashamed and humiliated, yes,” Ms. Porterfield said.
The prosecutor also pointed to notes in which Ms. Porterfield referred to Bowers’ mother as impaired social, cogitatively and emotionally. She questioned why Ms. Porterfield was relying on a woman she deemed impaired as a significant source of her information.
“She was the one raising this little boy,” Ms. Porterfield said.
Ms. Vasquez Schmitt asked if she thought Bowers’ mother cares for him.
Yes.
Did she think she would do anything to help her son?
“I think she’s devastated by what happened,” Ms. Porterfield said.
Did she think Bowers’ mother would make things up to help her son?
“I thought about that,” Ms. Porterfield said. “I did not feel she was lying to me. The things she told me were quite shameful and humiliating.”
Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.