Outside of Pittsburgh police Officer Timothy Matson’s front door, there’s a weed in a bucket.
It’s been there a long time now, since sometime between when he thought about dying and when he decided to get his “boots back on the ground.”
Officer Matson was shot multiple times Oct. 27, 2018, as he and fellow SWAT team members tried to take down an active gunman holed up in the upper floors of a Squirrel Hill synagogue. That gunman, Robert Bowers, is now on trial for his life as his trial moves through its sixth week.
“I went to work one day and took 22 weeks to go home,” Officer Matson told jurors.
Those jurors — seven women and five men — have already convicted Bowers of all 63 federal charges against him. Earlier this month, they deemed him eligible to face the death penalty.
The testimony they’ve heard over the past three days — from Officer Matson and other survivors and the loved ones of the 11 killed — is part of what they will ultimately weigh in deciding Bowers’ fate.
Read More
Three congregations worshipped in the synagogue at Shady and Wilkins avenues: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Eleven were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.
Officer Matson was among the last to deliver their victim impact testimony Wednesday morning. Later in the afternoon, Bowers’ defense began their presentation of mitigating evidence: 112 factors they say should push jurors to give him life in prison rather than the death penalty.
The officer — a man over 6 feet tall and weighing more than 300 pounds at the time — spent 16 weeks in three different hospitals as doctors worked to repair his shattered bones.
Swelling in his limbs and abdomen put a dangerous amount of pressure on his muscles, a condition called compartment syndrome that often follows a severe injury. To save the muscles, doctors performed what’s called a fasciotomy — that is, they cut open his arms, legs and part of his torso to relieve the pressure.
Those wounds required skin grafts to close them again, though he said one leg never did heal properly. Bone was cut from his hip to rebuild his tibia, and his kneecap had to be rebuilt and reattached with screws. He took his first steps again in January 2019.
He spent six weeks living in a teammate’s basement until he could walk the steps to his own home. For two months after that, another teammate had to drive him to appointments and to therapy.
Officer Matson told jurors he went to a dark place. Assistant U.S. Attorney Soo C. Song asked if he ever didn’t want to live.
Yes.
He said it got to a point where he’d had enough.
“I felt it would be better if I ended it,” he said.
He went outside. A friend had been weed-whacking for him since he’d been injured. There was a minnow bucket — a bucket in which he kept live fishing bait.
There was a weed in it.
Rainwater helped it grow roots.
“Man, that’s one tough [expletive] weed,” he said he thought to himself.
No one wanted the weed, but it hung on and it grew. Officer Matson had a massive support system. He goes to therapy now — “happy school,” as he calls it — and he cries daily. He said there’s a stigma surrounding law enforcement officers and mental health but “I’m pretty sure nothing about me says ‘weak.’”
He watered the weed. It grew a root system. He gave it some potting soil. The minnow bucket and weed are on his front porch now.
“I see it every day,” he said.
While Officer Matson was at one end of a hospital hallway recovering, Dor Hadash congregant Dan Leger was at the other. Bowers shot him once in the abdomen, and Mr. Leger, in his 70s, spent 45 agonizingly conscious minutes bleeding to death on the synagogue stairs.
He lived, though, and awoke on a ventilator in the intensive care unit, having undergone emergency surgery and a massive blood transfusion. He couldn’t talk, and so he spelled with his fingers into the hand of his wife, Ellen.
“Let me go,” he told her.
“I assumed I was gravely injured or so disabled I was going to be a great burden to my wife and family,” he told jurors.
The pain, he said, was exquisite. He remains in some level of pain daily, more than 4 ½ years later.
He underwent numerous emergency surgeries, and he will likely have a colostomy for the rest of his life. The damage to his abdomen is a constant reminder of what happened that day.
“I live with this body that doesn’t feel like it’s mine,” he said.
For a time, he couldn’t eat. He lost 30 pounds, and there was a real fear he would die from a lack of nutrition.
“I know people think I look like Tim Matson,” he deadpanned, “but my normal weight is around 140.”
In the hospital, he dropped to around 110.
When he learned Officer Matson was down the hall from him, he made it a physical therapy goal to walk to the officer’s room. He ended up fudging that goal a bit, he said, when he heard the SWAT operator was going to be moved to another hospital.
“He didn’t know it at the time, but I didn’t walk all the way,” he said.
A nurse wheeled him down the hall, and he walked in with his walker. It was exhausting, he said.
Mr. Leger has tried to go back to work as a hospital chaplain, but his energy isn’t there anymore. He still uses a cane sometimes and has troubles with his balance. He doesn’t do well with firecrackers, and he’s suspicious of people, especially in crowds. He can sleep, but there are nightmares.
He told jurors he never thought about ending his life, but he often thought it would have been better if he had died that day.
Jerry Rabinowitz was a friend for more than a decade, and he died that day. That’s been especially hard, Mr. Leger said. He and fellow Dor Hadash survivor Marty Gainor are honoring their friend by reading one page of the Talmud every day — a 7½-year endeavor.
Family members of victims have each made their own efforts to remember their lost loved ones. For Michele Rosenthal, it’s been promoting “Love Like the Boys,” which encourages random acts of kindness in the name of her brothers, Cecil and David.
Affectionately called “the boys,” both had intellectual and some physical disabilities born out of a genetic disorder called fragile X syndrome. They lived together with a roommate in housing provided by Achieva, an organization that works with people with disabilities. Every Friday night, though, they went to their parents’ home for Sabbath dinner. Saturday morning, the brothers would go to services at Tree of Life.
Those were the most important things to her brothers, Ms. Rosenthal said: their family and Tree of Life. The last time she saw her brothers was the Monday before Oct. 27, 2018, when she had a cookout at the home she shares with her husband.
Among the worst parts of Oct. 27, she said, was calling her parents, who were in Florida. She’d told her dad to prepare for the worst about Cecil — a custodian who was in the synagogue and had tea with the boys each Saturday morning before services said he’d seen Cecil on the floor, bleeding.
When her parents arrived in Pittsburgh, her father mouthed a question to her from the wheelchair he was being pushed in: “David?”
“I just shook my head ‘no,’” she said. “He just became hysterical.”
In a recorded statement, her father, Eliezer Rosenthal, detailed the pain he felt after his sons were killed. He referenced the idiom, “time heals all.”
“I know that term does not apply,” he said.
Cecil, he said, is forever 59. David, forever 54. They were killed in “a place they felt welcome and safe.”
They never expected to bury their sons.
“Our hearts are empty every single day knowing our sons are gone forever,” he said. “Our family will never be the same.”
Never the same — a common refrain amongst those left behind by the 11 victims.
Andrea Wedner survived the attack. Her 97-year-old mother, Rose Mallinger, did not.
It disrupted her entire rhythm of life, Ms. Wedner told jurors.
“After it happened, I wanted to pick up the phone and call her, tell her something,” she said.
She told jurors of the physical pain, too. Her arm was essentially blown apart by gunfire as she hid under the pew with her mother, she said. Even after multiple surgeries, she hasn’t been able to return to her job as a dental hygienist. Another surgery is scheduled for later this year.
The invisible scars include startling easily, particularly around fireworks. She hasn’t gone consistently to Shabbat services since her mother was killed. She used to go every week so that she could take her mother. It’s not the same now, she said.
“I’m haunted by what happened to me and by what I saw and what I heard that day,” she said.
She had to step over Cecil Rosenthal when SWAT officers rescued her from the Pervin Chapel.
“Not a day goes by that I don’t think about what happened. The hardest part for me” — she took a long pause, then continued: “Is knowing what happened to her and how she died.”
Daniel Stein asked little of others, though others gave everything to him. And he acted in kind, his family said.
“People gravitated to him,” said his wife, Sharyn Stein. “He liked a good laugh.”
Photos shown to the jurors showed a proud grandfather holding his tiny grandson. He got only seven months with the boy.
“He was over the moon when he found out my daughter-in-law was pregnant,” Ms. Stein said.
And he was a helper, she said. He volunteered at the Jewish Community Center and at the food pantry.
Most people called him Dan. She called him Danny.
Joseph Stein called him Dad.
He told jurors about how much his father loved him and loved his sister. He was speaking for her Wednesday, he said — his birthday.
“I get a lot from people who say, ‘I don’t know how you’re doing this,’” he said. “I didn’t ask for this. No one asked for this.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.