Defense attorneys for Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers on Monday continued their in-depth presentation of their client’s difficult childhood, this time presenting jurors with testimony from an elementary school classmate and a fifth grade teacher.

Attorneys also questioned a second cousin of Bowers, Naomi Grimm, who testified that there was a long history of abuse and mental illness among the maternal side of the convicted killer’s family.

Ms. Grimm, of East Rochester, Ohio, said she didn’t know that Bowers’ mother, her cousin, even had a child until after the FBI and reporters began calling her in the aftermath of the Oct. 27, 2018, shootings at a Squirrel Hill synagogue.

In June, jurors found Bowers, 50, guilty of all 63 federal charges against him in the killings at the synagogue. Earlier this month, they deemed him eligible for the death penalty. The jury must now decide if he should receive life in prison or the death penalty.

Advertise with us

Three congregations worshipped at the synagogue that Bowers attacked: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. He killed 11 people: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Ms. Grimm didn’t know Bowers or that he existed until that news broke. She did, however, know of the extensive abuse that her own mother — Bowers’ aunt and the sister of his mother — suffered throughout her childhood and early adult life. That abuse, she said, played out again in generation after generation.

“Because of the abuse they took — we’re kind of a reflection of that abuse,” Ms. Grimm said.

While prosecutors in the case have presented testimony they say shows Bowers’ crimes were so heinous that they deserve the ultimate punishment, defense attorneys now are reconstructing Bowers’ life up until the shooting in a bid to mitigate that heinousness.

Ms. Grimm, through her testimony, gave jurors a glimpse into the generational trauma passed down on Bowers’ mother’s side of the family.

Advertise with us

She said her grandmother — Bowers’ great-grandmother — sent all nine of her children to the McCullough Home for Children in Ohio in 1931. Among the nine children: Martha, Ms. Grimm’s mother, and Patricia, Bowers’ grandmother. Patricia was the youngest of the nine and was a toddler when the children were sent to the McCullough home.

Ms. Grimm said sexual abuse was rampant at the home, perpetrated by the man who ran it. When her mother reported the abuse to a cook, the cook told the man running the home. Ms. Grimm said her mother was thrown out of the home on Christmas Eve when she was 17.

“It was a very harsh place,” she said. “A lot of cruelty went on.”

Of the nine children sent to the home, many have since suffered mental illness and alcoholism and have been either the perpetrators or victims of chronic domestic violence and abuse, Ms. Grimm said. That includes Patricia, Bowers’ grandmother, and Martha, Ms. Grimm’s mother.

Defense efforts to lay out the problems that Bowers dealt with as a child began last week. Earlier experts testified to the problems Bowers’ mother had parenting her son. She divorced his father, who was violent and suffered his own mental illnesses, before Bowers was a year old. She married another man not long after and followed him to Florida. He, too, was abusive and he attempted suicide at least once.

Advertise with us

“She felt she was truly incapable of parenting [Bowers],” clinical psychologist Katherine Porterfield told jurors last week.

Ms. Porterfield, who is based in New York and specializes in childhood trauma, began her testimony Wednesday as the opening witness for the defense in this stage of the trial. Her time on the stand followed more than two days of emotional testimony from shooting survivors and victims’ family members about the impact of the shooting and of losing their loved ones.

Ms. Porterfield spent nearly three days telling jurors about Bowers’ childhood, which she reconstructed through some 21,000 records and documents along with interviews with his mother and others who knew him.

Her testimony Monday was a continuation of that. Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt’s cross examination of Ms. Porterfield also largely paralleled that of last week as she pointed to discrepancies between what Ms. Porterfield gleaned from her research and what Bowers told experts in recent months and years.

For example, Ms. Vasquez Schmitt questioned why the psychologist didn’t update the PowerPoint presentation she had created for the jury after she read about the discrepancies with reports by prosecutors’ experts. The attorney again tried to paint Bowers’ mother as an unreliable narrator and historian.

Advertise with us

Voices from Bowers’ past

Jace Wingard went to elementary school with Bowers from second through fifth grade at Faith Community Christian School in Bethel Park. He remembered a young Bowers as relatively normal, although he had some quirks — eating chalk dust on several occasions to get a rise out of classmates and breaking a toy Mr. Wingard once brought to recess.

He recalled one specific instance in which he and his mother drove Bowers home from Mr. Wingard’s birthday party. After his mother returned Bowers to his home, she told her son she was concerned about the boy. Mr. Wingard said she did not elaborate.

Dennis Kavanaugh, Bowers’ fifth grade teacher at the religious school, also recalled several incidents that stood out in his mind even 40 years later.

In one instance, he said, Bowers began visibly shaking and became incredibly upset at the prospect of a timed math competition.

Advertise with us

Another time, he said, he noticed Bowers with his head down not working on a writing assignment he’d been given. When Mr. Kavanaugh asked what was wrong, he said, Bowers told him, “I can’t touch that kind of paper. I had to go to the hospital once because of that kind of paper.”

“It was pretty striking,” Mr. Kavanaugh said.

The school’s principal later told Mr. Kavanaugh that Bowers was having thoughts of self-harm and might have even tried to hurt himself. Mr. Kavanaugh said he tried to give Bowers the opportunity to talk one-on-one several times after that to no avail.

Defense attorneys called two psychiatrists who worked at facilities where Bowers was an inpatient when he was 13: Dr. Earl Brink, a psychiatrist at McKeesport Hospital in 1985, and Dr. Alan Axelson, a psychiatrist at Upper St. Clair’s Southwood Psychiatric Hospital.

Neither remembered Bowers, but they added another layer of context to the medical records from the time.

Advertise with us

Bowers was admitted to McKeesport in September 1985 because of suicidal ideation, depression and behavioral issues. In his notes, Dr. Brink wrote that Bowers needed treatment beyond what McKeesport would offer, and he suggested the patient be evaluated for insipient schizophrenia — that is, Bowers showed what could be early signs of it but likely wouldn’t present with the mental illness for another few years.

“I didn’t know what was coming,” Dr. Brink said, “but something was coming and that was a possibility.”

At Southwood, Bowers remained isolated for the first two weeks of his stay, refusing often to brush his teeth or eat, let alone engage with counselors or the other children, Dr. Axelson said.

After two or three weeks, doctors approached him about trying antidepressants. He at first refused but later agreed. Dr. Axelson said medical records indicated Bowers saw a marked improvement.

“This was a kid who went from curled up to part of the group,” he said.

Advertise with us

The prognosis given at Southwood was “poor to guarded,” records showed. Dr. Axelson said the belief was the progress might continue so long as he continued treatment and was not returned home to his mother.

The final witness Monday was Ashley Hatcher Peralta, an investigator with the public defender’s office.

After the FBI finished its investigation into Bowers’ Baldwin apartment several weeks after the shooting, the space was turned over to his landlord who in turn allowed Bowers’ mother to come in and take her son’s belongings. Ms. Hatcher Peralta was there as well, and Bowers’ mother allowed her to take several boxes of materials.

Among them were documents and records of Bowers’ father, Randall Bowers,  sent to him by his paternal grandmother in 2003.

Randall Bowers killed himself Oct. 23, 1979, with a shotgun blast to the chest in Tionesta. He was about to face trial on rape charges. Among the documents Bowers had was the envelope his father’s suicide note had been in.

Advertise with us

Written on the front was, “My last word” and “by Randall George Bowers.”

The 10-page handwritten note was not in the envelope, although a copy of it was briefly shown in the courtroom.

“Dear mom,” it began. “I just want to say I’m sorry about this.”

Testimony resumes Tuesday morning.

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com