Defense attorneys for Robert Bowers filed a motion early Tuesday to exhume the body of Randall Bowers, the man believed to be Bowers’ father, to confirm paternity.

The move comes after several days of implications to the contrary by government prosecutors.

The defense has been working to build a case that a family history of mental illness supports the conclusion that the shooter suffered from similar issues.

Bowers, 50, of Baldwin was convicted last month of all federal charges against him in connection with the Oct. 27, 2018, shootings at a Squirrel Hill synagogue. Three congregations worshipped there: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. Eleven people were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Advertise with us

Jurors now are hearing evidence that they will weigh in deciding Bowers’ sentence: life in prison or the death penalty.

Defense attorneys for Bowers have presented evidence throughout the trial that he has schizophrenia. Among myriad other evidence and pieces of testimony, attorneys have pointed to the fact that Bowers’ father, Randall Bowers, was diagnosed with schizophrenia before his suicide in 1979.

Prosecutors in the case have held tight to the fact that Bowers’ mother mentioned her own vague doubts as to her son’s paternity. In addition, a former neighbor interviewed by clinical psychologist Katherine Porterfield in her reconstruction of Bowers’ childhood also expressed doubts.

Defense attorneys pointed to prosecutors’ attempts to “instill doubt” by repeatedly referring to Ms. Porterfield’s notes from her interview with Bowers’ mother. Among the notes: His mother was “[not] positive Dell [Randall Bowers] was the father.”

Another note was from an interview with a neighbor who remarked that “he did not think that Dell was the defendant’s father.” Defense attorneys noted that this neighbor did not give the source of his speculation.

Advertise with us

“I actually queried that a bit,” Ms. Porterfield testified. “[Bowers’ mother] spoke many hours with me about Randall Bowers as the father. I actually examined things like birth certificates and checked, OK, well, who’s recognized here as the father.”

Randall Bowers killed himself in October 1979 just before he was about to stand trial on rape charges.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt began pulling at the paternity thread Thursday in her cross-examination of Ms. Porterfield, the defense’s first expert witness for the sentence-selection phase of the trial.

The attorney returned to it again Monday, asking about Ms. Porterfield’s testimony that she had no indications paternity was in question.

“So I guess you meant, other than the fact that the mother herself said it was a question?” Ms. Vasquez Schmitt asked.

Advertise with us

Ms. Porterfield explained: “What I was responding was that there was a lot of data about Mr. Bowers’ childhood, about Randall Bowers being his father. There was official documentation. There was an entire family … who acknowledged Robert Bowers is their grandson.”

Defense attorneys accused the government of asking questions concerning paternity “purely to continue to instill doubt in jurors’ minds.”

Confirming paternity for the jury is necessary, they wrote.

“The evidence establishes that there was serious mental illness of Mr. Bowers’ maternal side of the family,” they wrote.

“The evidence also establishes that Randall Bowers was diagnosed with schizophrenia. Evidence establishing mental illness on Robert Bowers’ paternal side, particularly from a first-degree relative such as his father, strengthens the basis for concluding that Mr. Bowers, too, suffers from a serious mental illness.”

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com