Jurors wept last week as Amy Mallinger told them about the days spent sitting on her grandmother’s Squirrel Hill porch, watching dogs and squirrels and people. She talked about playing games after family dinners and about how her 97-year-old “bubbe” loved the Chicken Dance.
“Now she doesn’t get to play games, she doesn’t get to dance at my wedding,” Ms. Mallinger said, weeping.

Many jurors wiped away tears as Dan Leger described waking up in the hospital after he was shot and nearly died in the Oct. 27, 2018, attack on his Squirrel Hill synagogue. When he awoke in the intensive care unit, he was intubated and couldn’t talk. He spelled with his fingers into his wife’s hand.
“Let me go,” he told her.
Mr. Leger was the final survivor to deliver victim impact testimony in the final phase of gunman Robert Bowers’ death penalty trial. Twenty-one survivors and family members of the slain victims gave emotional testimony last week to often very emotional jurors.
Victim impact statements — which have become common in most types of criminal cases over the past few decades — walk a fine line in terms of their place in the courts, said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney now teaching at Saint Vincent College.
Read More
In a trial, jurors must consider all of the evidence and information, including the impact of the crime on victims. The way in which jurors should consider that impact, though, is limited per instructions to them.
“The fact that someone has suffered a terrible loss at the loss of a loved one is not an aggravating circumstance,” Mr. Antkowiak said.
Aggravating factors are those that jurors weigh in deciding if the crime rises to the ultimate punishment, like the number of victims or if the victims were particularly vulnerable. Jurors can consider the impact of the crime, but they cannot use the emotionality of the impact statements as a weight on their scale when deciding life versus death.
“The concern is that this is not going to be a reasoned judgment but one simply as the result of passion and prejudice,” Mr. Antkowiak said. “Jurors have to be told to keep this victim impact evidence in its proper perspective: They are to assess what this crime meant to people left behind but not use this simply to feed a sense of vengeance or just blind retribution.”
The sheer number of victims in this case meant jurors spent more than two days listening to loved ones describe the pain of their loss.
Bowers shot and killed 11 people when he stormed the synagogue at Shady and Wilkins at the start of Shabbat services that morning: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger. Three congregations worshipped in the synagogue where the shooting took place: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash, and New Light.
These same jurors in June convicted Bowers, 50, of all 63 federal charges against him, and earlier this month they deemed him eligible for the death penalty.
The evidence they are hearing in this last phase will go toward weighing the actual sentence: life or death. Defense attorneys on Wednesday began countering the prosecution’s efforts, beginning with a deep look at Bowers’ traumatic childhood.
Though no guidelines for victim impact testimony were articulated in the courtroom, it was clear that the U.S. attorneys prosecuting the case had warned their witnesses as to what they could and could not talk about. No one testifying on the crime’s impact could speak about the crime itself, but rather they were limited to discussing the aftermath.
That was wise on the part of counsel, Mr. Antkowiak said.
“When this gets appealed to the 3rd Circuit, as it will, one of the [appeal factors] will be whether the verdict was the result of passion or prejudice,” he said.
The jury deliberating the case at this point includes seven women and five men.
In weighing the death penalty, there is no law to guide them. The decision is a moral one. A decision of imposing the death penalty must be a unanimous one. The court must trust that jurors will follow the instructions given as to how they can consider and weigh victim impact testimony.
“How will the jury assess them? In the quiet and private of the jury room,” Mr. Antkowiak said. “Will the instructions be effective? We don’t know, but one of the things the law always assumes is that jurors do follow the instructions of the court.”
The concept of victim impact statements came out of one of the more notorious homicide cases in American history: The murder of actress Sharon Tate in 1969 by members of the so-called Manson Family, a criminal commune led by Charles Manson. Members of the group killed Tate, her unborn child and four others Aug. 8, 1969, at her Los Angeles home.
The actress’s mother, Doris Tate, founded the Coalition for Victims’ Equal Rights in 1982 as one of her daughter’s killers came up for parole. The group developed what was called the Victims’ Bill of Rights. Chief among its demands was that victims be permitted to read a statement in court rather than limiting their testimony to answering attorneys’ questions.
All 50 states and the federal government now allow some sort of victim impact statements during sentencing, but the admissibility of such testimony has come under the scrutiny of the U.S. Supreme Court numerous times over the years.
In 1987, the court’s decision in Booth v. Maryland ruled that Maryland’s allowance of victim impact statements in death penalty cases violated the Eighth Amendment. The ruling indicated that the “emotionally charged opinions” of survivors and family members could undo the “reasoned decision-making” required of jurors in capital cases.
Two years later, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that in South Carolina v. Gathers, ruling that victim impact testimony was inadmissible because it wasn’t related to the circumstances of the crime.
All of that was reversed in 1991, with the high court’s decision in Payne v. Tennessee. That ruling wiped out the previous decisions, finding that victim impact testimony in capital cases did not violate the Eighth Amendment because it allowed jurors or the judge to assess the damage done in the crime. The Victims’ Rights Act of 2004 cemented that idea.
It is also written into Pennsylvania’s Victims’ Bill of Rights.
“In cases of homicide, it gives the surviving family the opportunity to talk about their loved one — who they were, their interests, children left behind, their life plans,” said Chris Chambers, supervisor of the homicide and community violence unit at Pittsburgh’s Center for Victims.
In other words, she said, such a statement can give those in the courtroom — including jurors — a chance to understand that the victim was a living, breathing person who was truly important to others.
She said the ripple effects go beyond just the victim and immediate family, and people should understand that it also impacts “the community of people known to that person.”
In the Bowers case last week, Judith Kaye told jurors how it took her 60 years to find the love of her life, Irv Younger. Michael Simon and his sister, Michelle Weis, talked about how their parents, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, were the center of their family’s world. Joseph Stein said his father, Dan Stein, was over the moon to be a grandfather but got just a few short months with his new grandson before he was killed.
The opportunity to present that loss and those emotions can be therapeutic, too, Ms. Chambers said.
“This may be the only opportunity for the murder victim’s family to have a voice in the justice system,” Ms. Chambers said. “A voice in the court process allows them to feel empowered and feel as if they have had a chance to represent their loved one who is not able to be with them that day to tell their story.”
This type of victim impact evidence does have an impact, according to at least one study.
The 2011 study had 135 people watch a video recording of a real death penalty trial. Seventy-three participants watched the entire recorded trial, including victim impact statements. The rest watched the recording save for the impact testimony.
Of those who saw the victim impact statements, 62.5% said they would impose the death penalty. That group was also more likely to feel anger, hostility and vengeance toward the defendant. They were also more likely to feel sympathy for the victim.
Among those who did not see the victim impact statements, 17.5% said they would impose death. Of those who did not see the statements, 44.4% said they would sentence the defendant to life without parole and 38.1% said they would vote for life with the possibility of parole.
“Those who viewed victim impact testimony perceived significantly more harm and suffering inflicted on the victim’s family,” concluded the authors of the study published in the journal Criminology.
“Those who viewed the victim impact evidence and those who actually imposed a death sentence were significantly more likely to think that a sentence of death would help the victim’s family find closure or help them recover from their loss.”
Victim impact statements in the Bowers’ case concluded last week. Defense testimony will resume at 9 a.m. Monday.
Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.