An accusatory court filing by prosecutors in the case against alleged synagogue shooter Robert Bowers accused his defense team of running to the federal judge with issues and questions without even trying to hash out of it out with the government.

The filing also refuted the allegation that faulty evidence was turned over for testing last month.

Mr. Bowers’ defense team made the claims by way of its own snappy motion late last month. The attorneys claimed that test tubes the government was ordered to hand over were either empty or nearly empty and demanded an explanation.

In a filing last week, the U.S. Attorney’s office wrote that if defense attorneys had read reports provided months ago, they’d have known that the vials were not empty but rather needed to be rehydrated.

Advertise with us

“The defendant’s motion, filed without any effort to confer with the government, raises questions that previously disclosed laboratory notes … readily answer,” federal prosecutors wrote, indicating that those notes were turned over in April and June.

They accused the defense team of “perpetuating a recent pattern of engaging the court on issues that the parties might be able to resolve or at least narrow before resorting to motions practice.”

Mr. Bowers, 50, is accused of gunning down 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue at the start of services Oct. 27, 2018. He faces hate crime charges resulting in deaths, as he allegedly ranted on social media and to first responders against Jewish people.

The defense filing includes a report from a lab technician that indicated he found several test tubes empty when he removed them from a centrifuge, which was used to “spin down” the contents. Other tubes contained so little DNA material that no test could be performed without using up all the material.

In its response, the government pointed out that it would make sense if the liquid used to suspend the DNA in the vial had evaporated after more than four years. The DNA sample would remain behind, just without liquid.

Advertise with us

“Although the defendant complains that several vials are ‘empty,’ his motion and accompanying affidavit are silent as to whether his expert attempted to rehydrate the relevant vials,” prosecutors wrote.

Defense attorneys had also claimed the government failed to turn over requested DNA swabs, although the response contends that reports provided months ago “contained ample information” about what material remained and how much there was.

“Again,” prosecutors wrote, “it is unclear whether the defendant provided this information to his own expert so that the expert could take appropriate steps in handling and analyzing the evidence.”

The government filing noted that investigators have documented the DNA findings and so the defense team can perform tests that will use up all the remaining material if necessary. U.S. District Judge Robert Colville ordered the sides to meet by Jan. 4 to discuss the issues.

The government is seeking the death penalty. Defense attorneys have offered a guilty plea in exchange for life in federal prison to no avail. Mr. Bowers is set to go to trial in late April — four-and-a-half years after the shootings.