Federal prosecutors have asked a judge for permission to have accused Tree of Light shooter Robert Bowers examined by a psychiatrist in advance of his upcoming trial.

In a motion filed Friday, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Pittsburgh said the evaluation would be done in response to a defense filing that Mr. Bowers intended to raise mental health evidence in the penalty phase of the trial should he be convicted. If he is exonerated, the results of the evaluation would not be introduced.

Prosecutors said they wanted the examination to be conducted before the trial so that it didn’t delay proceedings once the trial is underway and noted, “a district court has the authority to order a defendant who states that he will use evidence from his own psychiatric examination in the penalty phase of a trial to undergo a psychiatric examination by a government-selected psychiatrist before the start of the penalty phase.”

The defense last month indicated it intended to introduce a mental condition defense if Mr. Bowers is convicted of killing 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue in October 2018. The trial is scheduled for April.

Advertise with us

The motion proposed that the government’s experts may question the defendant “about the charged crimes and his conduct before and after committing the crimes, and any other matter as is necessary and probative to rebut or confirm the anticipated defense expert mental health testimony.”

It also said no attorneys for the defense or prosecution should be present during the examinations but the government’s psychiatrist should be able to record the interview.

If Mr. Bowers is acquitted, the rebuttal expert reports from the psychiatrist may be destroyed upon order of the court, the motion proposes.

But, “If he is convicted of a capital crime, the envelopes labeled ‘For Defense’ will immediately be provided to defendant. He will have 24 hours to confirm or withdraw his intent to offer mental health evidence. If he withdraws the intent, the reports may be destroyed upon order of the Court and never provided to the government. If he confirms the intent, . . . the envelopes labeled ‘For Government’ will be provided to the government, at which time defense counsel should also provide the government with their own expert reports.”

Last week, U.S. District Court Judge Robert Colville held a status hearing in the case and announced potential jurors in the case would begin filling out questionnaires starting Monday.