Attorneys for accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers claim that federal investigators sent them more than a dozen empty and near-empty test tubes after a judge ordered DNA evidence be turned over to the defense for independent testing, according to recent court documents filed in federal court.

After a series of dueling court filings last month, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville granted a request from Mr. Bowers’ defense team to allow DNA evidence in the case to be sent to an independent laboratory for testing.

Defense attorneys in mid-November argued that they should be entitled to have the DNA evidence independently tested by Cellmark Forensic Services in England. Federal prosecutors argued that defense attorneys had years to perform their own testing.

Judge Colville ultimately granted the motion, saying the defense team “may retrieve the DNA extracts and any swabs or portions of swabs that may exist pertaining to these items of evidence.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Bowers, 50, is accused of gunning down 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue at the start of services Oct. 27, 2018. He faces hate-crime charges resulting in deaths, as he allegedly ranted on social media and to first responders against Jewish people.

The government is seeking the death penalty. Defense attorneys have offered a guilty plea in exchange for life in federal prison to no avail. Mr. Bowers is set to go to trial in late April — four-and-a-half years after the shootings.

In a motion filed Tuesday, the defense team explained that it had retrieved and shipped the evidence to the overseas lab. The lab technician who opened the package two days later noted two bags of DNA tubes: one containing 17 tubes and one with 12 tubes.

Of the 17 in one bag, 11 were empty when lab tech Andrew McDonald removed them from the centrifuge, which was used to “spin down” the contents to see which still had DNA extract. The other six, he wrote in his report, contained so little that any test would use up all the material.

Defense attorneys said the government also failed to produce any swabs or portions of swabs related to the DNA evidence as ordered by the judge, according to the motion.

Advertise with us

Mr. McDonald’s report from the lab, according to the motion, indicated that “no actual swabs, portions of swabs or other samples have been received for further testing to supplement the empty tubes for independent DNA testing.”

In his original order granting the defense access to the DNA evidence, Judge Colville noted that any tests should not be consumptive — that is, tests should not use up the entirety of the remaining DNA evidence.

“Though the government has had exclusive control over the evidence in this case,” the defense wrote, “it has now produced empty plastic tubes and an extraordinarily small amount of liquid in other tubes, essentially preventing the defense from independent testing of the crime scene DNA evidence.”

Mr. Bowers’ defense counsel asked that the judge order the government to explain why the test tubes were empty or nearly empty and reveal whether any swabs or portions of swabs of DNA evidence even exist.

Depending upon the government’s explanations and answers, defense counsel wrote, the judge should grant permission for defense experts to use up any remaining DNA evidence in the course of their testing.

The government has until Wednesday to file a response.