No matter how many times the defense attorney tried to imply it, the alleged victim never wavered.
“You’re indicating you never said to him during this time, ‘Let’s hook up,’?” Lee Rothman asked.
“Absolutely not,” the woman answered.
“ ’Hey, follow me home?’ ” Mr. Rothman continued.
“That’s disgusting. Absolutely not,” she replied. And then to herself — but loud enough to hear — she mumbled, “That’s sick.”
The 25-year-old who said she was attacked by Pittsburgh restaurateur Adnan Pehlivan in her home on the South Side Slopes last spring got repeatedly frustrated and angry at questions the lawyer asked Thursday while cross-examining her during his client’s sexual assault trial in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
Read More
She occasionally answered him flippantly, and at one point, strenuously questioned how what he was asking was relevant.
But it was when he asked her specifically about the position of her legs during the sexual assault, that she needed to take a break.
“I don’t know. I don’t know. I don’t know,” she said, becoming increasingly distraught. “That’s the most disgusting question.”
Then she began to cry.
Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning called for a recess.
It was the second day of trial for Mr. Pehlivan, 47, who owned the now-closed Regent Square restaurant Istanbul Sofra. He is charged with involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, burglary, sexual assault, aggravated indecent assault, simple assault and stalking.
Police said he stalked the woman and her two friends as they left Kopy’s Bar on the South Side early May 15 and followed them to their apartment.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette does not identify alleged victims of sexual assault.
On Thursday, the woman testified that when they got home, the three friends ate and drank juice boxes in the living room before going to bed about 1 a.m.
The alleged victim said she returned to her bedroom in the basement, took off her shorts and got into bed wearing her T-shirt and underwear. She was dizzy from the alcohol, she said, and fell asleep.
When she awoke, “there was oral sex being performed on me,” she testified. “I was stunned. I was confused.
“It took me a minute to realize I wasn’t dreaming.”
Then, she continued, “I grabbed the defendant’s head and pulled it up to see the defendant.
“’What are you doing? Who are you?’” she screamed.
“He tried to run.”
The woman testified that Mr. Pehlivan jumped up from the bed and tried to flee.
“I screamed ‘no,’ and I ran after him,” she continued. “I was able to grab his shirt collar.”
For 10 to 15 seconds, the woman said, they struggled.
“I was punched. I was pushed.”
Ultimately, she said, she was shoved into the corner of the wall — leaving a large abrasion on her back — and knocked into a laundry basket.
The defendant headed for the door and left but then reached back inside a second later to grab his suit jacket, which he’d laid out on her dresser.
Immediately, she began screaming for her roommates upstairs.
“ ’He was here. He was between my legs. He ran,’ ” she shouted.
One of her roommates came downstairs and called 911. Even as the alleged victim waited for the police to arrive, she was still naked from the waist down.
“I was terrified putting anything on my body would destroy evidence,” she said.
“Had you given Adnan Pehlivan permission to enter your apartment?” asked Assistant District Attorney Ed Scheid.
“No,” the witness answered emphatically.
“Were you aware that you were being followed by Pehlivan?” the prosecutor continued.
“Absolutely not,” she responded.
During a 90-minute cross-examination, Mr. Rothman’s questions repeatedly suggested that the interaction between the woman and Mr. Pehlivan was consensual.
He asked multiple times about the woman’s level of intoxication — noting how many drinks she consumed and questioned why she would accept drinks from Mr. Pehlivan, even though she said she found his behavior odd.
“You, again, never refused any of the drinks he bought?” Mr. Rothman asked.
“Correct.”
“And you were happy to drink them?”
“Correct,” she responded.
Testimony concluded Thursday with the alleged victim’s roommate on the stand.
The roommate testified that she was in her bedroom that night when she heard the alleged victim screaming downstairs.
“[She] was crouched down. She wasn’t wearing pants,” the roommate told the jury. “She was inconsolably crying and screaming.”
The roommate called 911, and before the dispatcher began to speak, one of the women said, “He followed us.”
Later, the dispatcher asked what the caller meant.
“She thinks it looks like the guy at the bar we were at,” the roommate told the dispatcher. “I don’t remember a car following us or anything.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.