Three young women, their faces and clothing pixelated to protect their identities, appear on the screen at 12:38 a.m.
Heading home May 15 after visiting a bar on the South Side, they don't seem to notice the silver BMW pull up to the intersection and turn right onto Carson Street, passing them.
The car pulls over a short distance away, and the driver turns off the lights. The women pass within a few feet of the car's passenger side 45 seconds later.
The car moves up another block, pulls over again, douses its lights and waits as they continue their walk on Carson, stopping at a pizza shop.
For 14 minutes, the repeating scene played out until, prosecutors say, the driver followed the women as they got in their car at 18th and Carson streets and drove 1.3 miles to their Josephine Street home in South Side Slopes.
There, authorities said, Adnan Hilton Pehlivan, 46, who owns the Istanbul Sofra restaurant on Forbes Avenue in Regent Square, broke in a short time later and sexually assaulted one of the women as she slept.
Read More
Owner of Istanbul Sofra's bond was revoked
On Thursday, Allegheny County Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni played the video, taken from surveillance cameras throughout the South Side, to help make her case that Mr. Pehlivan, 46, is a danger to the community and a flight risk who should have his bond revoked.
"It is clear he is stalking them," she said, calling it "predatory behavior."
Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning agreed, calling what he saw on the video a "brazen act of stalking.
“You can’t describe it any other way.”
Based on the video, as well as information Ms. DiGiovanni presented stemming from what she considered to be a similar incident in 2012, the judge revoked Mr. Pehlivan's bond, although he told defense attorney Jimmy Sheets that he would consider placing the restaurateur on home electronic monitoring.
According to Ms. DiGiovanni, the woman called police immediately after the assault, telling them that she woke up as she was being attacked.
She said she immediately recognized the man as having bought her and her friends drinks at a bar that night on the South Side. She also said that as she fought off her attacker, she scratched his neck and tore his shirt.
Police recovered from the alleged victim’s home a piece of cloth from the torn shirt, Ms. DiGiovanni said, as well as a distinctive button from another shirt the attacker wore.
When investigators served a search warrant at Mr. Pehlivan's Swissvale home the next day, the prosecutor said, they recovered the torn shirt, as well as another shirt with the same distinctive buttons previously recovered. They were purchased in Turkey, Ms. DiGiovanni said.
Mr. Pehlivan also had scratches on his neck that matched where the woman told police she scratched him, Ms. DiGiovanni said.
The DA’s office is awaiting DNA results from a sexual assault examination kit that was collected from the alleged victim.
Ms. DiGiovanni told Judge Manning about an incident on Feb. 11, 2012. According to a police report at the time, officers on patrol on the South Side saw Mr. Pehlivan crouched down in an entryway at 17th and Carson streets at 2:25 a.m.
His pants were down, and he was over a 22-year-old woman who was intoxicated and unresponsive.
The officers detained Mr. Pehlivan and spoke to the woman's friend, who arrived on the scene.
Both women said they did not know Mr. Pehlivan. The woman who had been unconscious said she did not know how she got there. There was no evidence of sexual assault.
Mr. Pehlivan told officers he was urinating.
He was released and never charged.
Mr. Sheets dismissed the incident and denied that his client is a flight risk.
Mr. Pehlivan was supposed to be in court on Thursday asking for permission to take his 13-year-old daughter on a trip to Australia, where he had purchased tickets last year for a One Direction concert.
Mr. Sheets told Judge Manning that his client, who is from Turkey and became a U.S. citizen in 1996, had no criminal record and was not a flight risk.
But Ms. DiGiovanni told Judge Manning that Mr. Pehlivan travels extensively, including to Turkey, which would not extradite him to the United States if he refused to return. She also said Mr. Pehlivan has access to substantial funds; he posted his $20,000 straight bond in cash within three hours.
Mr. Sheets countered that had his client wanted to flee, Mr. Pehlivan could have done so as soon as he was released on bond.
"There was more than ample opportunity for a person with means ... to be out of here by now," he said.
But Ms. DiGiovanni said that, perhaps, Mr. Pehlivan did not know how strong the case is against him.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.