A judge on Wednesday again denied bond for a Regent Square restaurant owner jailed on charges of sexual assault.
Adnan Hilton Pehlivan, 47, on Tuesday made his third request to be released from jail pending trial, with his defense attorney arguing to Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning that his client should be presumed innocent and is not a flight risk, despite ties to Turkey, where he was born and raised. He became a U.S. citizen in 1996.
In a three-page order issued Wednesday, Judge Manning said that defense attorney Lee Rothman presented no new evidence at the bail hearing Tuesday that would cause him to change his earlier rulings.
"[W]hile the defendant remains cloaked in the presumption of innocence, this court has not been presented with anything new that would cause it to reconsider its prior finding that no conditions, or combination of conditions, would reasonably assure the safety of the community," Judge Manning wrote.
Mr. Pehlivan, who owns Istanbul Sofra, was charged with involuntary deviate sexual intercourse and related counts following an incident in the early morning of May 15.
According to investigators, Mr. Pehlivan was at a South Side bar the night of May 14 with a group of women and bought drinks for them. Police said he then followed a group of three of them as they walked down Carson Street.
Read More
Surveillance video shows Mr. Pehlivan driving his silver BMW behind the women, then passing them, pulling over to the curb and turning off his headlights. He then repeated that behavior until they got in a car and drove to their home on Josephine Street in the South Side Slopes.
Police said Mr. Pehlivan followed their car, broke into the women's apartment and sexually assaulted one of them.
Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni said that the victim tore her attacker's T-shirt as he tried to flee, and police found a torn T-shirt at Mr. Pehlivan's home. DNA test results have not yet been completed.
Following the defendant's arrest, he was initially released on a $20,000 straight bond. However, the prosecution asked to have his bond revoked, and on May 24, Judge Manning did that, after viewing the surveillance video.
Again on Tuesday, Ms. DiGiovanni objected to Mr. Pehlivan's release on bond and called his behavior "predatory."
Mr. Rothman, however, argued to the court that his client is an integral part of his restaurant business, does charitable work and is the father of a teenage girl. He told the court Mr. Pehlivan is not a flight risk.
But in his order, Judge Manning said he had already ruled on bail at a hearing in May and again in June in which he found Mr. Pehlivan should remain incarcerated pending trial.
"If anything, given the outcome of the June 19, 2018, preliminary hearing, where all charges were held for trial and stalking charges were added in light of the surveillance video, the commonwealth's position is stronger," Judge Manning wrote.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.