Even after Adnan Pehlivan bought the three women multiple shots of Fireball it took 45 minutes before they began to really interact with him.

As he sat chain-smoking at Kopy's Bar with his body turned toward them, they turned away, chatting and laughing among themselves, using their cell phones.

Mr. Pehlivan, a Pittsburgh restaurateur, went on trial Wednesday, accused of stalking the women through the South Side, breaking into their Josephine Street home in the South Side Slopes and sexually assaulting one of them early on May 15 until she fought him off.

During his opening statement, Allegheny County Assistant District Attorney Ed Scheid described Mr. Pehlivan, 47, to the jury of eight men and four women as a “restaurateur by day...sexual predator by night.”

Advertise with us

But defense attorney Lee Rothman said that there was no crime.

Despite bar surveillance footage played for jurors that showed the women at first largely ignoring Mr. Pehlivan’s attempts to engage them, Mr. Rothman said that his client had actually made an "arrangement" with the alleged victim, whom he described as a "young lady who was struggling to pay her rent."

"She was having a jovial and good time with my client," Mr. Rothman told the jury in his opening statement. "She was leaning into him."

Mr. Pehlivan, who owned the now-closed Turkish restaurant Istanbul Sofra in Regent Square, is charged with involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, burglary, sexual assault, aggravated indecent assault, simple assault and stalking.

The alleged victim — a 25-year-old woman with a master's degree in social work — was called to testify Wednesday and will return Thursday morning to the courtroom of Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette does not name alleged victims of sexual assault.

About half of the two hours the woman sat on the witness stand was spent watching bar video.

At first it showed Mr. Pehlivan reaching across one of the woman’s friends to light her cigarette five minutes after he entered the bar around 10:48 p.m.

Eight minutes later, he bought the first of four rounds of Fireball shots over an hour.

The group clinked glasses and drank.

Advertise with us

One of the alleged victim's friends hugged Mr. Pehlivan, but then the women continued talking, excluding him from the conversation.

He bought the next shot just five minutes later — while the women drank theirs quickly, he appeared to sip his.

At 11:30 p.m., Mr. Pehlivan bought another round of shots. Again, the women drank theirs, but he appeared to have poured his out on the bar and then wiped it up.

A few minutes later, the women begin to include Mr. Pehlivan in their conversation and interact with him, with one of the friends even taking a selfie with him.

During her testimony, the alleged victim said Mr. Pehlivan told the women that he owned a restaurant and that he was taking a trip to Australia; he even showed her the airline ticket on his cell phone.

Advertise with us

Later, she said, he started doing magic tricks.

During the course of the night, the alleged victim testified, she and her friends talked with Mr. Pehlivan about his restaurant and her work, but she said they never spoke about sex in any way, and she did not tell Mr. Pehlivan where she lived — even though he asked.

Just after 12:30 a.m. on May 15, the women left Kopy's, with the alleged victim waving goodbye to Mr. Pehlivan.

Within five seconds, Mr. Scheid said, Mr. Pehlivan left, too.

The prosecutor told the jurors that he will show them footage from video surveillance cameras along East Carson Street, showing Mr. Pehlivan following the women, and then pulling ahead as they passed by on foot.

Advertise with us

Upon arriving home, Mr. Scheid said, the victim, who was dizzy from the alcohol she’d drank, undressed to her T-shirt and underwear and went to bed.

Within a half hour, the prosecutor continued, she woke up, to find Mr. Pehlivan's head between her legs.

"She reaches down, and she grabs his hair and raises his head, and she sees him," Mr. Scheid said. "He jumps out of bed, and she screams. They struggle."

The alleged victim grabbed onto Mr. Pehlivan, the prosecutor continued, and tore off a piece off his white undershirt, which Mr. Scheid said, was found to match the rest of an undershirt recovered from the defendant’s home.

During that exchange, Mr. Scheid said, the defendant punched the woman and pushed her.

Advertise with us

She fell back into a laundry basket, and Mr. Pehlivan fled through the door, grabbing his suit jacket off a dresser on his way out, the prosecutor said.

But Mr. Rothman, in his opening statement, discounted much of the prosecutor's description of what happened that night.

"There is virtually zero evidence my client gained entry into this house surreptitiously," Mr. Rothman said.

Pittsburgh police Detective Jeffrey Palmer testified that both the screen and pane of a window that leads into the alleged victim’s living space were open, and that items on a dresser directly underneath the window inside had been knocked over or to the floor.

But Mr. Rothman pointed out that there were no scuff marks on the window nor did any of the dirt on it look as if it had been disturbed. He also questioned why all of the items on the dresser weren’t askew given the allegation that Mr. Pehlivan climbed through the window above it.

Advertise with us

The defense attorney also told the jurors that no fingerprints were recovered from the window.

The woman had consumed three beers, Mr. Rothman said, as well as four to five shots at Kopy’s in 90 minutes and was “extremely intoxicated.” He said that alcohol consumption leads to lessened inhibitions, and that when the alleged victim realized what was happening, she regretted her decision to “hook up.”

Common sense, the defense attorney continued, shows that his client did not commit any crime: Mr. Pehlivan made no attempt to disguise himself when he entered the home; did not restrain the alleged victim and did not “pleasure himself,” during the incident.

“I would suggest to you, ladies and gentlemen, he was an invited guest, and that he and [the alleged victim] made an arrangement to hook up,” the attorney said. “This is not — not — the actions of a predator.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.