A convention of volunteer firefighters this weekend promises traditional competitions and parades, but first, it addressed the biggest concern facing departments statewide — recruiting and retaining members.
On Friday morning, the Western Pennsylvania Firemen’s Association, meeting in Arnold, heard plans for a study on why the number of volunteers has been steadily dropping.
John “J.C.” Tedorski, former fire chief of Arnold No. 2, is now deputy state fire commissioner and told association members the state fire commissioner's office would be researching the issue.
According to a state legislative report from 2018, there were about 300,000 volunteers statewide during the 1970s. By 2018, there were 38,000. Mr. Tedorski said that there are “pockets” across the state that have no problems, but that many rural departments could be struggling because they don’t have the population base to recruit enough potential firefighters and paramedics.
He said his office would be interviewing 1,000 former firefighters to find out why they stopped serving. And “I don’t have time” is not a sufficient answer for him and colleagues — they said they would be digging deeper to find out the root causes.
Bruce Crivaro, a captain with the New Kensington Fire Department, said his city is fortunate because a lot of retired men still serve as active firefighters. But since the 1970s, more families have become two-income households, meaning it’s harder for many to justify sacrificing the time to serve as a firefighter.
Read More
More companies also need to spend time raising money at events in order to stay afloat, he said.
“You’re spending more time raising money than you are training,” Mr. Crivaro said. But there’s no one reason for a decline in volunteers, he added.
Eric Gartley, fire chief of Arnold No. 2, said there could be many reasons people leave a fire company: personality conflicts with others on the job, or young firefighters having an idea of what the job would be like and then realizing the difference once they start.
“TV and Hollywood doesn’t really do a lot of favors for us, as to what the honest truth is for what firefighters do in the community,” Mr. Gartley said. “It’s not always the glory of running into a burning building, there’s a lot of other things that we do.”
He said the convention serves as an important venue for the hundreds of fire companies across Western Pennsylvania as they try to address recruitment, retention, and other issues. Bruce Davis, an assistant fire chief in New Kensington, said it’s good to pick the brains of “old-timers” at the convention in order to learn more about what they have faced during their careers.
There are also equipment issues to consider, Mr. Gartley said. His department has a 30-year-old fire engine that it needs to replace, which will cost about $750,000, he said. And other departments are in similar situations, he said.
“It takes an awful lot of funding to get to that point,” Mr. Gartley said, whether it’s state or municipal money, fundraising or loans.
The meeting on Friday occurred in a cafeteria at Roy A. Hunt Elementary School in Arnold, where members also nominated new executive officers for the association’s upcoming year. Don Ferrante, president and assistant chief of Arnold Company No. 2, said he was happy to serve in the role for the past year, but glad to pass the torch to fellow firefighters. Elections began for the following nominees:
- President: James Eley, Fayette City
- First Vice President: Dennis Remich, New Kensington
- Second Vice President: Mr. Crivaro, New Kensington
- Third Vice President: Sherri Eley, Fayette City; or Amie Shank, New Kensington
- Executive Director — Secretary: Thomas Shank, New Kensington
- Executive Committee (two-year term, vote for five members): James Potlas, Bob Paterson, F. Chris O’Leath, Cindy Davis, Amie Shank, Nick Wuckovich (all serve various departments across the region)
- Place for Convention 2026: Somerset or Patton, Cambria County
Mr. Ferrante said election results would be announced Sunday evening. The convention also serves as an important kickoff for Arnold Company No. 2, which marks its centennial year in 2024, he added.
The meeting on Friday was one of the first events of the convention, which is being attended by hundreds of members, and another meeting of the executive meeting would occur at 6 p.m. A Battle of the Barrel, in which teams direct hoses at a suspended barrel in a kind of reverse tug of war, is scheduled for 9 a.m. on Saturday in front of Roosevelt Park, followed by a parade at 6 p.m. through downtown Arnold.
On Sunday, an Old-Timers luncheon was scheduled at the AVECO Club, followed by a memorial service at 2 p.m. at Calvary Lutheran Church for fallen firefighters and concluded with a 6 p.m. awards banquet at St. Vladimir Social Hall.
A reorganization meeting at the AVECO Club at 10 a.m. on Monday concludes the convention.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.