A Bellevue council member and several residents have concerns about the future of fire and emergency services in the borough after the volunteer fire department was decertified last month, but officials from the municipality and city of Pittsburgh say there shouldn’t be an impact for at least the next few weeks. 

At a meeting earlier this week, residents and Glenn Pritchard, the borough’s former volunteer fire chief, called on council to reverse its decision. They said the decision to disband the fire department was made without providing notice to volunteer firefighters and residents, and would potentially jeopardize public safety.

Last month, the Bellevue Borough Council voted to decertify its volunteer fire service because of a decrease in volunteer firefighters responding on service calls in recent years, according to information posted on the borough’s website. Two council members, Sabreena Miller and Dan McKelvey, voted against decertifying. 

The number of volunteer firefighters in Pennsylvania, and nationwide, has decreased greatly in recent decades. According to a state legislative report from 2018, there were about 300,000 volunteers statewide during the 1970s. By 2018, there were 38,000. 

Advertise with us

That’s caused debate in multiple municipalities about whether volunteer companies should be decertified. Last month, the McKees Rocks Borough Council unanimously voted to derecognize its volunteer fire department.

For Bellevue, Pittsburgh’s fire department will give “automatic aid,” meaning city firefighters will provide additional assistance on fire and EMS calls if needed.

The Pittsburgh fire department has a station in Brighton Heights, less than 2 miles from Bellevue’s Borough Hall. Pittsburgh public safety spokeswoman Amanda Mueller said in an email that the department was already providing assistance to municipalities that requested help.

“We already provide mutual/automatic aid to any community that might request it, this is not a new situation for the Bureau,” Ms. Mueller wrote.

Ms. Miller, who voted against decertifying, said in an interview she was concerned with how council decided to vote. She said council voted without notifying all of the volunteer department members, or council members, with specifics about the decision or future of fire and emergency services in the borough before the meeting. 

Advertise with us

Ms. Miller added that she believes there is no long-term plan for fire and EMS service in the borough. The council’s Future of Fire committee has been established to discuss those issues, but Ms. Miller said questions remain about what types of service will be provided. This week, there was a motorcycle accident in the borough where only one person from the borough’s fire department responded, she said.

Mr. Pritchard said typically, at least four rescue technicians and two paramedics would respond to a call like that. If only one person responds, that could cost the victim valuable minutes if they’re pinned underneath a car or in great danger, he said. 

There are about 30 volunteers with Bellevue, about 15 to 20 of which are active, Mr. Pritchard said. He disputes much of the data about service calls that council used to make its decision. Borough officials said last year that 21% of calls had no volunteer response, 82% had four or fewer volunteers respond, and more than half of calls had two volunteers or fewer respond. 

“I don’t believe [council] did this in good faith, they did not even attempt to reach out or even talk about the shortcomings that either of us had … I think that 99% of this can be resolved with communication,” Mr. Pritchard said.

Council President Jodi Cerminara, who voted for decertification, said via email Friday that the data collected was reported through the State Fire Commissioner’s Office, which was then reported to the National Fire Incident Reporting System. The council’s Future of Fire committee is looking at hiring a paid fire chief, along with other options, regarding future fire and rescue services, she wrote. 

Advertise with us

Last year, no volunteer firefighters in the borough were dispatched to 120 calls, where paid firefighters were assisted through mutual aid via other local fire departments, Ms. Cerminara said. 

Borough officials have said a paid fire chief could result in better oversight and accountability for the fire department, as that person would need to report to council. Council’s public safety chairperson had tried to collect financial documents, bylaws and other information last year but was unsuccessful, Ms. Cerminara said.

“This vote was taken just in the same manner as other municipalities who have decertified their volunteer departments, and was done in accordance with the recommendation of the Future of Fire Committee after their careful consideration of studies about the viability of [volunteer fire departments] and the long-standing relationship between the Bellevue Fire Department and Columbia Hose, Hook & Ladder,” she said.

Ms. Mueller said the Pittsburgh fire department is confident it will be able to handle calls from Bellevue — in 2022, the borough’s fire department responded to eight structural fires. The city’s fire department responds to that many structural fires each week, she said.

Ms. Miller agreed that the city should be able to handle the additional calls from Bellevue, and Mr. Pritchard said that Pittsburgh’s firefighters provide a “superb service.” But Mr. Pritchard said decisions to decertify volunteer fire departments impact the ability for suburbs to assist each other on calls — including on a recent fire in Stowe Township, where Bellevue was unable to provide help because it no longer has a volunteer fire department.

Advertise with us

Moving forward, Ms. Miller is concerned about the long-term plan for fire and EMS service in Bellevue.

“I’m really urging the other council people to bring everybody to the table and really be serious about timelines, and phases, things that residents can really grab onto and say OK, I understand this,”Ms.  Miller said. “If this is the best decision for the borough, show them in a plan, and through action, what that is going to look like.”