If it’s not broke, don’t fix it.
That, in short, was the message to Allegheny County Council from Pittsburgh-area restaurant owners whose comments capped off a public hearing Wednesday on the proposed system for posting A-B-C cleanliness grades on restaurant doors.
The grading plan was referred to council’s health and human services committee for debate in October after it was passed by the county’s Board of Health a month earlier. Council is expected to hold a final vote early next year.
A persistent criticism of the plan, that it violates state law, was addressed at the outset with an opinion from county solicitor Andrew Szefi. Councilwoman Sue Means, R-Bethel Park, requested his advice after state Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, chairman of the agriculture committee, told elected officials and the health department such an ordinance would require a change from the Legislature.
Calling the plan “perfectly legal,” Mr. Szefi said counties in Pennsylvania have the ability to inspect and license restaurants. But there is no provision in state law saying what a restaurant grading plan should look like, and there has been no legal challenge to the current three-color system, he said.
“If that [legality] argument could be made about both [the current and proposed systems] but it’s only being made against one, the legal argument is somewhat of a red herring,“ Mr. Szefi said.
Read More
Restaurant owners contend the current system, adopted in 2001, is working well. Green indicates an establishment passed a health inspection; yellow means it is under consumer alert; and red signifies it was ordered to close.
Donna Scharding, the health department’s food safety program manager, told council members the ultimate goal of a grading system is to prevent food-borne illness.
If adopted, the plan would not change inspections themselves but modify the way conditions are reported. In 2013, according to the health department, 56 percent of full, annual inspections in Allegheny County had one or more significant violations such as cross-contamination and temperature violations.
“Having a grade posted will allow the consumer to make an immediate and informed decision,” Ms. Scharding said.
Ms. Scharding said the second of two six-week pilot programs found that in 502 inspections, 77 percent of restaurants received an A; 15 percent received a B and 7 percent a C; less than 1 percent scored below 70. In 127 follow-up inspections, 91 percent improved to an A; 8 percent a B and 0.9 percent a C. No grades were posted during this test phase, which occurred in October, nor in an earlier pilot.
In the first year, restaurants would have a chance within 14 days to improve a grade lower than “A” before it is posted. In future years, the grade will go up and then the restaurant can be reinspected to improve its score.
Restaurant owners were joined at the hearing by Christopher Hickey, the New York City regional director, New York State Restaurant Association. That city passed its own grading system in 2010.
“Letter grades have not solved the problem,” he said. “They’ve created a culture of fear.”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.