Allegheny County Council members Tuesday evening overwhelmingly rejected a controversial plan that would have required restaurants to post A-B-C letter grades on their doors informing the public how the establishments had fared in annual health inspections.
The proposal, which had been approved by the county’s Board of Health last fall, was defeated 12-1, with Councilman Nick Futules, D-Oakmont, who owns a catering business, abstaining.
The grading plan came under fire from local restaurateurs who argued that the current inspection system works and a new system would be costly, inconsistent and risky for businesses.
Under the current system, adopted in 2001, green indicates an establishment passed a health inspection; yellow means it is under consumer alert; and red signifies it was ordered to close.
Proponents, none of whom spoke at Tuesday’s meeting, had claimed the grades would help consumers make informed decisions about where to dine and encourage restaurants to quickly fix health code violations.
“We’ve always worked well with the health department,” said Jeff Cohen of the Pennsylvania Restaurant & Lodging Association. “This would have created an adversarial relationship. Besides, it could have destroyed someone’s life. There’s a fine line between staying in business and not, especially in Pittsburgh, where the winter months are tough. The system we have now is working well. We grade ourselves every day, and our customers grade us every day.”
Read More
Kevin Joyce, owner of the Carlton Restaurant, Downtown, said, “There’s nothing more important to food service professionals than serving safe food in a clean environment. That is our No. 1 goal. This proposal does not increase this goal. Rather it is about catching, punishing and embarrassing.”
Mike Mitcham, operations director with Primanti Bros., told the council that a bad grade at one of the chain’s restaurants could be devastating.
“We are currently growing our brand outside of the Pittsburgh market,” he said. “If one of my restaurants receives a grade lower than an ’A,’ it will not simply affect that particular restaurant, it will affect our entire brand. Public perception would be that all of our restaurants are either dirty or serving unsafe food.”
“Most of us believe in having an ‘A’ restaurant,” said Pamela Cohen, owner of Pamela’s restaurants, who quoted a projection that the system could cost the county $1.4 million. “It can really destroy a small business or a large business. I really feel this is dangerous.”
John Graf, director of operations for The Priory on the North Side, suggested that the system would be “fraught with subjectivity,” with different inspectors flagging different violations to different degrees.
Councilwoman Amanda Green Hawkins, D-Stanton Heights, noted that most of the speakers Tuesday night owned restaurants in District 13, which she represents,
“I am concerned about these working people,” she said before casting her vote opposing the system. “I’m not convinced that this proposal increases food safety. But I am convinced that it would harm workers.”
Councilman Edward Kress, R-Shaler, said running a restaurant is a gamble that often doesn’t pay off.
“You put a ’B’ on somebody’s business, what’s that mean? Bankruptcy?” he asked.
Three years ago, when she was running for office, Councilwoman Heather Heidelbaugh, R-Mt. Lebanon, indicated that she supported a restaurant-grading system. Since then, she said, she has looked further into the issue and changed her mind.
“I don’t think that we have a problem in Allegheny County,” she said, adding that if the owners of Pamela’s and Primanti are against the system, “how could I be for it?”
Councilman John Palmiere, D-Baldwin, was the lone vote for the grading system.
“Now I know what a salmon feels like when it’s going upstream,” he said.
Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.