The Allegheny County Health Department is taking the offensive against critics of its restaurant grading plan.

The department Wednesday released a point-by-point rebuttal to eight “misconceptions” and “misrepresentations” it says are being served up by a group of local restaurant owners lobbying members of Allegheny County Council to kill the proposal.

The plan to post A-B-C grades on restaurant doors was approved by the county board of health in September. It needs the nod from county council before it can be implemented.

“We feel there is some miscommunication” from critics “and we wanted to make sure we clear those up,” health department director Karen Hacker told board of health members at their bimonthly meeting Wednesday.

Advertise with us

One common complaint leveled by local restaurant interests is that grades that are based on annual inspections are unfair because they only represent a snapshot in time.

The department answered that charge Wednesday by saying that the public expects restaurants to employ safe food handling and sanitation practices “at all times.”

“That said, each facility will have the opportunity to improve their grade at a follow-up re-inspection if they are unhappy with the results of the initial comprehensive inspection,” the department said. Restaurant owners also could request a third chance to improve by paying $150 for up to one additional reinspection per year.

Other common criticisms are that the grading plan violates state law and that it would do nothing to improve food safety in the county.

“The grading system is legal,” the department said in its rebuttal, which was emailed to county council members last week. “It does not in any way alter the food safety regulations that are required to be enforced uniformly across the state.”

Advertise with us

The system “is simply an administrative tool used to more transparently convey the results of the inspection to the public.”

The department has said the grading plan underwent a legal review.

As for the effect that grades have on food safety, the department said there was “ample national evidence that grading systems lead to improved inspection results and therefore improved food safety.” The prospect of having to display a poor grade provides added incentive for food establishments to strictly follow the rules, the department said.

Last month, the grading plan was referred to county council’s health and human services committee for debate. Committee chairman John Palmiere on Wednesday said he will hold several meetings and at least one public hearing on the matter before the committee makes a recommendation to the full council.

“I’m not seeing anything done until January,” he said. “We will vet this thing completely. We will hear both sides.”